Victor Lindelöf | Officially signs

Ekeke

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
53,445
Location
Hope, We Lose
I agree with you, per example Jan Hagen clearly overreacted about him, of course he has strong points and weaknesses, but you can trust Mourinho regarding central defenders, if there is 1 area on the pitch he understands is that.

By the way, if you want to check Lindelof quality, you should check the quarter finals between Bayern and Benfica in 2016, and check the defensive line where they handled well Bayern, he has quality, dunno if he will be number 1 or not, but imo he has more potential than Bailly, even if Bailly phisicality is more suited to England, wait and see.
Okay, thanks for the tip. I'll try to find that.
 
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
13,122
I am very interested, but also highly skeptical over this signing. Will of course let it pan out and hope for the best, he will need time like everyone else. I am Scandinavian myself and always remain worried when Scandis are signed by big clubs, especially if the country has never produced a top level-defender in the past. To put it simple, if he is going to be good enough for Man Utd, he needs to become one of the best defenders Sweden has ever had in its history. Sweden had Patrik Andersson at Barcelona and Bayern München, he was probably their best defender ever (at least in modern times), and top class for one or two seasons. I love Olof Mellberg for example, but if he "just" makes his level it is not going to be good enough for Man Utd I'm afraid. And of course, nationality doesn't always have to matter that much (Mkhitaryan), but in the grand scheme of things it often is. Sweden's best every players, Zlatan and Henke Larsson, both had one parent from another country, the same goes for John Carew who is probably the top player Norway has ever produced. Lindelof has luckily gone through the ranks of European football, that's important for sure.
Are we seriously looking about the nationality of a players' parents? Enlighten us, where were Larsson and Zlatan's parents born?
 

SATA

Full Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2005
Messages
15,271
Location
We all love United
So i expect Lindelof to be a regular in the first team while Jose will probably push Blind into midfield especially if we don't get a DM although he doesn't seem to play him there. Makes sense?
 

Web of Bissaka

Full Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Messages
8,553
Location
Losing to Comeback Winning!
Interesting, Mourinho's first signing this second summer is an exciting defender.

Similar to the previous summer Bailly :D seriously if Morata is officially signed next, this'll be fun.

Still waiting for the official total confirmation though, come'on Lindelof.

8 June 2016, Eric Bailly.

2 July 2016, Zlatan Ibrahimovic.

6 July 2016, Henrikh Mkhitaryan.

9 August 2016, Paul Pogba.
 

Isotope

Ten Years a Cafite
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
23,713
They're not exactly "youngsters". They're established first-team players at second-tier clubs and internationals.
But still, they are young players that only have very few years experience on Pro-level.


Probably Woody told him that he could have more money to spend if the players he sign are young/potential, for the long term. :D:D
Maybe he intends on staying long term.

Would love that kind of stability; on manager, and players also.
 
Last edited:

Isotope

Ten Years a Cafite
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
23,713
defenders aren't always the easiest to judge as even the greatest of defenders can't hold together a poor unit.
The Lindelof link has been here since January which leads me to believe he's been heavily scouted for a long time, quite possibly someone Mourinho fancied before getting the united gig even. If the manager and coaching staff are convinced his attributes would suit the style of defending we intend to employ then I'm all over it. As a fan the only concern i have at the moment is can he stay fit? please god let us sign a defender who can stay fit!
Agreed about this. For instance, I'd never thought that Pique could become the main CB for one of the greatest team of all time. He's also become the backbone of Spain NT to win WC and EUROs.
 

mirons

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 5, 2016
Messages
22
Location
Portugal
This is a great buy for United and at a reasonable price, given today's prices. I'm Portuguese and, above all, a huge Benfica fan.
We are sad to see him go but unfortunately we are used to losing our best players (especially the younger ones) after a brief period of time.

Having said that, United is my 2nd team (I'd say that I like United more than your casual fan from overseas) and I'm fairly convinced that Lindelöf will impose himself quite easily and quickly (like Bailly if it weren't for the injuries and African Cup of Nations).

We desperately needed a centre back and I doubt there's a better one in the market, factoring age, current ability, potential & price.

He reads the game superbly for a 22-year old and he's typical Scandinavian when it comes to calmness and concentration. Errors are almost inexistent, unlike Jones, Smalling and Blind. He's fairly fast (not a speedster, mind), strong and very difficult to beat on one-on-ones.

And he's commanding. He only started playing regularly in the league on January 31st, 2016, because of injuries to both Luisão (already injured for some time at that point) and Lisandro López (during a game). He was subbed in on that day, partnering Jardel, and never left teh starting lineup again, even when (club captain and legend) Luisão came back from his injury. By mid-February he had already played FC Porto and Zenit, then away games at Sporting and Zenit (partnering the adapted DM Samaris) in the beginning March and, by that time, he was already commanding the defensive line. This season, Luisão came back to the fore and it was Jardel who was dropped.

One of his best qualities is he's very good on the ball. If the opponents are marking the DM and leave him with space, he will for sure carry the ball (and the team) forward and he's great at finding (with quality) the RB or LB in advanced positions.

The only thing he's still lacking is assertiveness on dead ball situations, both defensively and offensively. Still a lot to improve there.

Bonus: he scored a peach of a direct free kick at Sporting in April (matchday 30 out of 34), earning Benfica a draw which kept us in the top-spot and proved out to be essential to our "TETRA" (4 league titles in a row). Never had even attempted one before (at least in the first team)... Don't know if he's going to keep working on that, but that was a helluva goal, when it mattered the most.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kag

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,942
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
This is a great buy for United and at a reasonable price, given today's prices. I'm Portuguese and, above all, a huge Benfica fan.
We are sad to see him go but unfortunately we are used to losing our best players (especially the younger ones) after a brief period of time.

Having said that, United is my 2nd team (I'd say that I like United more than your casual fan from overseas) and I'm fairly convinced that Lindelöf will impose himself quite easily and quickly (like Bailly if it weren't for the injuries and African Cup of Nations).

We desperately needed a centre back and I doubt there's a better one in the market, factoring age, current ability, potential & price.

He reads the game superbly for a 22-year old and he's typical Scandinavian when it comes to calmness and concentration. Errors and almost inexistent, unlike Jones, Smalling and Blind. He's fairly fast (not a speedster, mind), strong and very difficult on one-on-ones.

And he's commanding. He only started playing regularly in the league on January 31st, 2016, because of injuries to both Luisão (already injured for some time at that point) and Lisandro López (during a game). He was subbed in on that day, partnering Jardel, and never left teh starting lineup again, even when (club captain and legend) Luisão came back from his injury. By mid-February he had already played FC Porto and Zenit, then away games at Sporting and Zenit (partnering the adapted DM Samaris) in the beginning March and, by that time, he was already commanding the defensive line. This season, Luisão came back to the fore and it was Jardel who was dropped.

One of his best qualities is he's very good on the ball,. If the opponents are marking the DM and leave him with space, he will for sure carry the ball (and the team) forward and he's great at finding (with quality) the RB or LB in advanced positions.

The only thing he's still lacking is assertiveness on dead ball situations, both defensively and offensively. Still a lot to improve there.

Bonus: he scored a peach of a direct free kick at Sporting in April (matchday 30 out of 34), earning Benfica a draw which kept us in the top-spot and proved out to be essential to our "TETRA" (4 league titles in a row). Never had even attempted one before (at least in the first team)... Don't know if he's going to keep working on that, but that was a helluva goal, when it mattered the most.
Now calm down about praising Lindelof, I have been praising his qualities, but don't create expectations here they bought Nesta, because we have some posters over here who think he is not good enough for United.

Imo he has the potential for being the number 1, but still playing in Portugal is 1 thing, England another, atm I think Bailly will be the number 1 and lets see how he adapts, but regarding technique and reading he looks the better 1, but at the physical level he needs at least 6 months to adapt to a different way of playing football.
 

mirons

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 5, 2016
Messages
22
Location
Portugal
Now calm down about praising Lindelof, I have been praising his qualities, but don't create expectations here they bought Nesta, because we have some posters over here who think he is not good enough for United.

Imo he has the potential for being the number 1, but still playing in Portugal is 1 thing, England another, atm I think Bailly will be the number 1 and lets see how he adapts, but regarding technique and reading he looks the better 1, but at the physical level he needs at least 6 months to adapt to a different way of playing football.
Of course he's not Nesta. Nor was I trying to put him on that level.
I stand by everything I said, I seriously doubt United could have done better at that price, considering his age, his potential but also his current ability.
Language will not be a problem, unlike Bailly, for example.
And I'm sure Lindelöf will adapt very well to the English game, he won't have any problems with the physicality and seldom makes rash challenges.
I can give you another example... EURO 2016. Selected in at the last minute, with only less than half a season in Benfica's first team, he then went on to play every minute of Sweden's campaign. Had another good game against France last Friday, who had 5 PL players (+ Payet) in their starting lineup.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,942
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Of course he's not Nesta. Nor was I trying to put him on that level.
I stand by everything I said, I seriously doubt United could have done better at that price, considering his age, his potential but also his current ability.
Language will not be a problem, unlike Bailly, for example.
And I'm sure Lindelöf will adapt very well to the English game, he won't have any problems with the physicality and seldom makes rash challenges.
I can give you another example... EURO 2016. Selected in at the last minute, with only less than half a season in Benfica's first team, he then went on to play every minute of Sweden's campaign. Had another good game against France last Friday, who had 5 PL players (+ Payet) in their starting lineup.
I know, but give him 6 months because football in England is totally different and faster, but I already said here for me comparing with Bailly he already has Champions League experience, even if some posters here have suspitions about the performances against Dormund, Napoli or Besiktas, lets give him time to adapt.
 

Sunny Jim

Full Member
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
29,438
Location
Warsaw...that's too far away from Edinburgh...
This is a great buy for United and at a reasonable price, given today's prices. I'm Portuguese and, above all, a huge Benfica fan.
We are sad to see him go but unfortunately we are used to losing our best players (especially the younger ones) after a brief period of time.

Having said that, United is my 2nd team (I'd say that I like United more than your casual fan from overseas) and I'm fairly convinced that Lindelöf will impose himself quite easily and quickly (like Bailly if it weren't for the injuries and African Cup of Nations).

We desperately needed a centre back and I doubt there's a better one in the market, factoring age, current ability, potential & price.

He reads the game superbly for a 22-year old and he's typical Scandinavian when it comes to calmness and concentration. Errors are almost inexistent, unlike Jones, Smalling and Blind. He's fairly fast (not a speedster, mind), strong and very difficult to beat on one-on-ones.

And he's commanding. He only started playing regularly in the league on January 31st, 2016, because of injuries to both Luisão (already injured for some time at that point) and Lisandro López (during a game). He was subbed in on that day, partnering Jardel, and never left teh starting lineup again, even when (club captain and legend) Luisão came back from his injury. By mid-February he had already played FC Porto and Zenit, then away games at Sporting and Zenit (partnering the adapted DM Samaris) in the beginning March and, by that time, he was already commanding the defensive line. This season, Luisão came back to the fore and it was Jardel who was dropped.

One of his best qualities is he's very good on the ball. If the opponents are marking the DM and leave him with space, he will for sure carry the ball (and the team) forward and he's great at finding (with quality) the RB or LB in advanced positions.

The only thing he's still lacking is assertiveness on dead ball situations, both defensively and offensively. Still a lot to improve there.

Bonus: he scored a peach of a direct free kick at Sporting in April (matchday 30 out of 34), earning Benfica a draw which kept us in the top-spot and proved out to be essential to our "TETRA" (4 league titles in a row). Never had even attempted one before (at least in the first team)... Don't know if he's going to keep working on that, but that was a helluva goal, when it mattered the most.
Sounds promising. Thanks.
 

Minkaro

Full Member
Joined
May 1, 2009
Messages
11,651
Interesting, Mourinho's first signing this second summer is an exciting defender.

Similar to the previous summer Bailly :D seriously if Morata is officially signed next, this'll be fun.

Still waiting for the official total confirmation though, come'on Lindelof.

8 June 2016, Eric Bailly.

2 July 2016, Zlatan Ibrahimovic.

6 July 2016, Henrikh Mkhitaryan.

9 August 2016, Paul Pogba.
So Bailly - Lindeloff, Ibra - Morata, and Pogba - Fabinho? So who's the Mkhi this year? Perisic?
 

Drz

Full Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Messages
1,350
Anyone on here think that signing Lindelof means we might be going to Back 3 next season with Bailly, Lindelof and Rojo ?
Had the Sweden vs France game on, was Sweden playing a back 3? I couldn't really tell, but it seemed there were always 3 defenders close to each other when France was in the final tier of the pitch. The production was quite poor and zoomed out didn't help me spot Lindelof clearly in the game.
 

cheeky_backheel

Full Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2017
Messages
2,529
I am very interested, but also highly skeptical over this signing. Will of course let it pan out and hope for the best, he will need time like everyone else. I am Scandinavian myself and always remain worried when Scandis are signed by big clubs, especially if the country has never produced a top level-defender in the past. To put it simple, if he is going to be good enough for Man Utd, he needs to become one of the best defenders Sweden has ever had in its history. Sweden had Patrik Andersson at Barcelona and Bayern München, he was probably their best defender ever (at least in modern times), and top class for one or two seasons. I love Olof Mellberg for example, but if he "just" makes his level it is not going to be good enough for Man Utd I'm afraid. And of course, nationality doesn't always have to matter that much (Mkhitaryan), but in the grand scheme of things it often is. Sweden's best every players, Zlatan and Henke Larsson, both had one parent from another country, the same goes for John Carew who is probably the top player Norway has ever produced. Lindelof has luckily gone through the ranks of European football, that's important for sure.
You said exactly what I was thinking. I remember saying the same thing when AC Milan were stupid enough to sign George Weah. Who signs a footballer from a country like Liberia?
 

Baxter

Full Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2010
Messages
11,738
Ah well, he's foreign so he must be shite.


How do knobs like Wilkins still get paid to speak utter nonsense?
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,764
Location
Barrow In Furness
Ah well, he's foreign so he must be shite.


How do knobs like Wilkins still get paid to speak utter nonsense?
He just thinks clubs here should only sign English players. This from the guy who buggered off to Italy. Maybe he should be having a go at Chelsea and all their on loan youngsters.


Oh and he's not John Terry.
 

Tom Van Persie

No relation
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
24,971
Ah well, he's foreign so he must be shite.


How do knobs like Wilkins still get paid to speak utter nonsense?
'This guys done nothing'

So being a key player in a title winning side is doing nothing? Most pundits in this country just don't follow football outside the PL and they can't be bothered to research players coming to the PL.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,764
Location
Barrow In Furness
We did sign Jones and Smalling dint we? Did they improve after numerous opportunities?
That was a number of years ago. Wilkins has got worse as he has got older. The youngsters should get a chance, fair enough if they are good enough. Football clubs, especially the Top 6 are big businesses and need to maintain their position at the pinnacle.
 

GledTheRed

Full Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2005
Messages
15,164
Location
Twitter thread
My oh my Wilkins what an utter clown, how the fcuk are these people paid to talk about football?

I'm pretty sure neither Wilkins nor Parlour actually know who Lindelof is the cnuts.

Get back to pub lads.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,764
Location
Barrow In Furness
'This guys done nothing'

So being a key player in a title winning side is doing nothing? Most pundits in this country just don't follow football outside the PL and they can't be bothered to research players coming to the PL.
Half of them have no clue about players from other leagues. They watch the PL and spend the rest of their time playing golf.
 

Baxter

Full Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2010
Messages
11,738
My oh my Wilkins what an utter clown, how the fcuk are these people paid to talk about football?

I'm pretty sure neither Wilkins nor Parlour actually know who Lindelof is the cnuts.

Get back to pub lads.
:lol: saw this as a reply. It's quite amusing how brain dead these idiot are.

 

prtk0811

New Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2016
Messages
7,854
That was a number of years ago. Wilkins has got worse as he has got older. The youngsters should get a chance, fair enough if they are good enough. Football clubs, especially the Top 6 are big businesses and need to maintain their position at the pinnacle.
Still we were in for Reece oxford from west ham who West ham refused to sell, We have axel Tuanzebe from the academy, We developed Rashford and Lingard And gave them new contracts whomay represent England ,We invested 27 M on Luke shaw who has to get to his true potential. Despite Carrying Jones and Smalling and Rooney on Huge Wages. He's all Bull ....
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,764
Location
Barrow In Furness
Still we were in for Reece oxford from west ham who West ham refused to sell, We have axel Tuanzebe from the academy, We developed Rashford and Lingard And gave them new contracts whomay represent England ,We invested 27 M on Luke shaw who has to get to his true potential. Despite Carrying Jones and Smalling and Rooney on Huge Wages. He's all Bull ....
He comes up with the same when a foreign coach comes in. Still bitter that he cannot hack it as a manager. We do well bringing our kids through. They praise City to the heavens. What kids are they bringing through?
 

3KDré

Full Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2015
Messages
6,646
:lol: saw this as a reply. It's quite amusing how brain dead these idiot are.

Fools, the lot of them. People like him are why we're so poor as a National team. There is some strange preference strong fast players over players that read the game well and are good technically. That's why we're so devoid of creativity from the midfield and defence when it comes to international football.
 

3KDré

Full Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2015
Messages
6,646
It doesn't count if it's not in England.
Reminds me of when Marco Silva got appointed Hull manager, one of these clueless idiots asked why we couldn't have someone British managing an English side like 'Thierry Henry' :lol:.
 

AndyJ1985

New Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2016
Messages
8,954
Fools, the lot of them. People like him are why we're so poor as a National team. There is some strange preference strong fast players over players that read the game well and are good technically. That's why we're so devoid of creativity from the midfield and defence when it comes to international football.
Yep. Our national team won't ever come close to winning a tournament until the mentality of the coaches changes. Hopefully the new generation of English coaches are different to the lingering fossils that have a history of failure on their CV.
 

prtk0811

New Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2016
Messages
7,854
Yep. Our national team won't ever come close to winning a tournament until the mentality of the coaches changes. Hopefully the new generation of English coaches are different to the lingering fossils that have a history of failure on their CV.
Giggs Has the potential, But he wasted a complete year after rejecting to work under Mourinho and keep on working Like Pep Mourinho and Zidane did.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,764
Location
Barrow In Furness
Praise City? For what Exactly?:lol: Illeanacho's stock has massively regressed this season.
If we sign a foreign player they go bonkers, yet we play kids in our team from the academy system every year. City fielded a team of all foreigners towards the end of last season. Not one English player. Yet they have signed all of two foreign players this season and nobody says anything. Isn't their new goalie from the same team as Lindelof?
 

The United Irishman

"Martial is championship material at best"
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
2,870
Location
Birmingham
If we sign a foreign player they go bonkers, yet we play kids in our team from the academy system every year. City fielded a team of all foreigners towards the end of last season. Not one English player. Yet they have signed all of two foreign players this season and nobody says anything. Isn't their new goalie from the same team as Lindelof?
Yeah, and where's all the rising stars from this expensive academy they spunked a couple of £100m on??
 

KM

I’m afraid I just blue myself
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
49,772
Are all Sky pundits members of EDL?