Jose Mourinho's press conference - Brighton (FA Cup) - 14:00 GMT

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kant-ona

Full Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2013
Messages
980
Honestly, I think his argument is valid if it says: "Don't expect from us the same quality in this season like City is delivering now."

But it is not valid if it should explain why we lost the way we did against Sevilla.
 

Nytram Shakes

cannot lust
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
5,287
Location
Auckland
Agree with the underperforming players but we should have quality in depth so when they are not performing we can bench them and replacements come in andn still play at a great level, what have most of those listed contributed this season? Not much, except for Smalling and in my opinion he shoild a be squad player and not good enough for the level we need at the back.
Well:
  • Darmian i'm with you he has been very disappointing since his signing its time for him to leave, but that hasn't really effected our form as Valencia has been so good!
  • In fairness to Blind he has been out Injured for a lot of the season, I'd say over his time here he has been a very useful squad player, maybe not a starter but a good squad player who can player a number of positions, personally i'd like to see him stay.
  • Fellaini, well i have a bit of an irrational hatred for Fellaini, mainly becuase of he represents that mess of a first summer when Fergie left and that I associate him with awful long ball football. But the manager has stated on many occasions how good he thinks he is and how important he is to his plans and the club, so if where talking about what Mourinho judges as deadwood this guys certainly wouldn't be on his list.
  • Herrera has had a disappointing season, he seems to have taken been dropped quite badly, but last season he was arguably our most consistent player, people were discussing him to be our captain in the summer so saying he should go at this stage seems very harsh. I mean we have just given Rojo a new contract who has had one good season(last year) in the time he has been here and has been injured for basically a year,
  • As for Smalling and Jones, well Jones had an incredible season last year and i'd probably say this year despite the odd bad game he probably has been our best centre back, but obviously he still has the issue with injuries . Smalling has had a better season then he did he did the 18 months previously, i still wouldn't say he was back to his form a a few years back, plus the amount he pulls shirts always terrifies me. The main issue with Smalling and Jones is they play badly together, however both have had better seasons then Lindelof, so selling one of them when we have a worse centre back seems daft, also our defensive record is actually great.

Your never gonna have a squad of 25 super stars, for my money we have an excellent squad, granted not as good as city's(as much as it pains me to say) but easily the second best in the league, which happens to be where we are. Obviously we should be beating Seville though(i dont agree with Mourinho that many of their players would get in out team), but bad results happen the tactics we played were awful, but thats the same tactics that has won Mourinho two champions leagues and won us the europa league last year, so its hard to criticise especially when if you didn't know this is how he played before he became our manager then they can't watch much football.

So for me i don't think deadwood is the issue, we have a bit of deadwood but any squad does, for me that isn't the issue, even the fact players like Pogba and Sanchez are under performing isnt the issue, the issue is simple in order to get away with the kind of tactics Mourinho plays you have to win a trophies every year other wise fans get pissy. and its hard to win trophies when you have a team like City in your league and winning knock out tournaments is a bit of crapshoot.
 
Last edited:

afrocentricity

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
27,148
He has Martial and Rashford in the squad who could both be instructed to stay wide and attack the fullback, having a 'winger' doesn't seem a priority
The post you 2 replied to stated that he missed out on the fourth piece of his puzzle. You and the other guy claimed that Sanchez is the last piece of that puzzle. That's not true.

Sanchez was signed because there was an opportunity to do it. Mourinho himself has confirmed that.

I suspect we'll get our winger in the summer.
 

Minimalist

New Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2013
Messages
15,091
I think you can tell the real 'agenda' going on with some posters on here. Most of which are going on ignore as they're santimonious top red shite is insufferable.

If these quotes and that conference was given by a certain Davie Moyes, they'd soon change their tune I bet.
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,611
Supports
Mejbri
I think you can tell the real 'agenda' going on with some posters on here. Most of which are going on ignore as they're santimonious top red shite is insufferable.

If these quotes and that conference was given by a certain Davie Moyes, they'd soon change their tune I bet.
And what, ignore everything else, nullify context completely and only look at the conference in isolation? Makes sense...
 

IppoKun

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 21, 2017
Messages
33
Supports
Benfica
We won the trophy last year. Sevilla were knocked out of the CL by Leicester City that time.

Moreover, people have already pointed out that this is not the same Sevilla team which won 3 back to back ELs. It's a shadow of that side with the majority of the players and the manager having been replaced.

If anyone, it's you who needs to check facts before trying to act all high and mighty.

After spending 300 mil, if Mourinho turns up with that tumescent shite at OT while getting kicked out of the CL and then making excuses that the Sevilla side is better than us, then he needs replacing before the players.

As for that crazy analogy about exes and crap, no one here is saying that we need to dominate the PL for a decade. It's you who went on that tangent. In fact you are the one bringing up SAF to somehow counter a point which was never raised.

Honesty, the way you speak sounds like you are Jose yourself.
Yes, I know that United won the trophy last year, I support and watch every United game. I also said "post SAF" and that doesn't include just last year. Since you mentioned facts, lets talk about facts: Sevilla are in the final of Copa del Rey for the first time since Emery was their manager (with a better team like you are trying to say, that team that got 3 ELs). They beat that other "shitty" team Atlético Madrid (5-2 agg). Since Emery, they had their best league place (4th) last year (when they lost against Leicester, with this "new" team). They are currently 5th on the league, the same place they usually finished with Emery.

Because they lost against Leicester City (3-2 agg) last year, you ignore everything else and call Sevilla shit and a shadow of the team that got the three ELs, despite them doing better now than they did back then. Also, they changed manager but the there's at least half of the players on the team from those 3 ELs trophys, not even going to mention they got some decent players too.

Now that the facts are over and the one acting mighty and superior is actually you and not me regarding Sevilla, lets talk about United. (I couldn't care less about Sevilla, but I don't disrespect them like some fans here do).

The game against Sevilla was "tumescent shite" I do agree with you, I hated it every bit. Unfortunately, the tactics were not good and some players under-performed, some were playing with fear in my opinion. But you can't just ignore some of the good recent games we had, against Liverpool and Chelsea. I disagree that Mourinho was making excuses (if by excuse you mean the some Sevilla players would play on United). He was simply respecting Sevilla value, because unlike a lot of you that say they are shit team, they are a good team and doing good in their competitions. Actually some Sevilla players would be good (not World Class, which United doesn't have that many with that quality too) alternatives to United (specially when our midfield is so thin, missing a right winger, no fullbacks etc). Before someone mentions it: Yes, we should have won the game because we have more quality, things just didn't go well in all aspects.

Why so many of you feel necessary to hear from the manager that it was is own fault, it's over me. He knows that he failed, some players also failed, what matters is improving and moving on. It's way more important knowing that he wants the fans to expect more and better from United and that he's with the club, staff, owners and players, all together trying to rebuild United to be respected like it was before.

My point about post SAF is simply that since then, United have struggled, they won't perform anywhere good and consistently. I guess even you can agree on this, it's not about dominating, it's about being decent enough to try and win something. United have never reached 2nd place, nor even 3rd place in PL since SAF. We are doing some progress, despite that very bad loss against Sevilla. I just don't share the doomsday view and the negativity that people here like to do whenever United looses. And like you said, "no one here is saying that we need to dominate the PL", but we are growing.

Also, I wouldn't mind being Mourinho account. That paycheck would be great.

If the team is not where he wants them to be after spending 300m then he only has himself to blame. If the team is not in a position to be playing attacking football against (Parking the bus in Seville no less) Sevilla then he's to blame. It's one thing to just lose to Sevilla but losing because we played cowardly football is infuriating. And Sevilla didn't even play well.

The fact that we're doing better last season is neither here nor there. The question we need to ask is if he's the right man to lead us to the league or CL. On the basis of this season you'd have to seriously question that. An now he's players and the club as a whole under the bus for his deficiencies. Nonsense like this only works if you're winning things.
I think people here just automatically throw the word "bus" on Mourinho teams because he was famous for it. Have you even checked our line-up and where Fellaini was? Fellaini was brought in place of McTominay to bring more attacking power and try to score first. He never set the team to park the bus, besides the 4 defenders and Matic, there's no more bus to it.

We created some chances in the 1st half but unfortunately the goal didn't appear and I think the team started to feel a bit nervous because of the high pressing that Sevilla players were making. United started to withdraw more in their own defense (remember that in players minds, one goal from Sevilla would mean game almost over, as the time was starting to reach the end). Mourinho even took out Fellaini before Sevilla scored, to attack even more (despite Pogba being shit lately). How can one really think that Mourinho set the team to draw/park the bus is beyond me. The tactics didn't worked out sure, but he never parked the bus. It's a conjunction of the tactics not panning out like Mourinho wanted and players underperforming with some even being sloppy.

And yes, lets just ignore the progress we made comparing to last years, because it totally makes sense. Ignore Liverpool and Chelsea games, that we are 2nd for the first time since SAF years, that United managed to get back in CL, despite not going well against Sevilla. Just sack Mourinho despite all that, clone Pep the messiah and bring him to United to turn water into wine in 1 year and a half maximum.
 

Mozza

It’s Carrick you know
Joined
Jul 13, 2002
Messages
23,353
Location
Let Rooney be Rooney
The post you 2 replied to stated that he missed out on the fourth piece of his puzzle. You and the other guy claimed that Sanchez is the last piece of that puzzle. That's not true.

Sanchez was signed because there was an opportunity to do it. Mourinho himself has confirmed that.

I suspect we'll get our winger in the summer.
What if we buy a winger this summer and he gets injured? Is Mouriniho incapable of adapting his tactics to win without the perfect combination of players?
 

Wanderlust_09

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 14, 2018
Messages
130
I watched the press conference twice and am extremely annoyed!
Jose spoke like a man whose ego got hurt badly after Tuesday's defeat, and instead of accepting the mistakes and moving on, tried his best to defend his reputation and put the entire blame on Utd's so called "Football Heritage".
He spoke as if he was doing a big favour to the club.
What I despised the most was him trying to separate himself from the club: For us fans the club, the manager and the players all combine together to form a single identity called Man Utd. But for Jose, he is different from the club. This is evident from his repeated mentions of "I won the Europa League (instead of we won it)", "I finished with 15 points".
None of us fans are deluded enough to think that we would have won the UCL. But the manner of loss to a weaker team at home largely due to the manager getting his tactics horribly wrong is certainly something Jose has to own up for, instead of trying to project his "manager heritage".

But hey, we all knew Jose and what he was going to be like and bring to Utd when he was made the manager. For now, we should just stick with him, because we need stability more than anything else and we should bear his tantrums and negative style of football for at least a couple of seasons. Hope things dont go horribly wrong until then.
 

Jacko21

Full Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2016
Messages
4,579
Location
Manchester
I think you can tell the real 'agenda' going on with some posters on here. Most of which are going on ignore as they're santimonious top red shite is insufferable.

If these quotes and that conference was given by a certain Davie Moyes, they'd soon change their tune I bet.
Works both ways remember.

There are some on here who'd sooner pledge allegiance to a different team if the only alternative was to praise Mourinho.

Mourinho polarises opinion, so a little bit of objectivity wouldn't go amiss all round.
 

afrocentricity

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
27,148
What if we buy a winger this summer and he gets injured? Is Mouriniho incapable of adapting his tactics to win without the perfect combination of players?
Take that up with @SuzieQ. I was just pointing out that Sanchez wasn't the 4th player. The 4th player still hasn't arrived (a winger that we've needed for a while I might add). Pertinent point imo.
 

whatwha

Sniffs Erricksson’s diarrhea
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
7,612
Location
Norway
No excuses.

Mourinho on Alex Ferguson after Porto beat Man Utd in 2004: "He has some top players in the world and they should be doing a lot better than that. You would be really sad if your team gets as clearly dominated as that by an opponent who has been built on maybe 10% of the budget"
:lol: Nice.
 

ti vu

Full Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2015
Messages
12,799
No excuses.

Mourinho on Alex Ferguson after Porto beat Man Utd in 2004: "He has some top players in the world and they should be doing a lot better than that. You would be really sad if your team gets as clearly dominated as that by an opponent who has been built on maybe 10% of the budget"
In the end of this PC, Mourinho said the fan and player should be sad, critical and keep high expectation of the club.
 

Jazz

Just in case anyone missed it. I don't like Mount.
Joined
Feb 11, 2014
Messages
31,056
Mate, I reaslise taht you are an LVG fan, but don't even try to make out that LVG was doing a great job.
The improvements that Jose has brought in, compared to to LVG is night and day.
LVG was a 4th/5th place manager and if we gave him 10 years, he wouldn't have been able to win the title.
Jose has taken us to 2nd place in the league, in his 2nd year and hopefully, he'll win the title next season. Should this happen, there will be a major meltdown in here and I can't wait.

And regarding the press conference. It was passionate and I hope Jose can get our players to play with just as much passion.
Where in my post have I made out LVG was doing a good job? I simply stated that he would have at least brought improvements to those particular players. The basics of what LVG was trying to teach the players is correct. However, in no way do I believe he could have taken us that much further, but at least he focused on technique - shit execution at times but he had a plan. Jose has no plan. I'm not fooled by being 2nd at the moment and if he continues with his crazy attitude we'll drop to 5th.
For me he disrespected the club with his deflection, nothing passionate about his ramblings. He completely lost me when he throws our club under the bus to protect his reputation. That's not passion mate, that's just classless.
 

Giggsyking

Full Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2013
Messages
8,559
only 3 players from Sevilla who played against us on Tuesday Escudero, Banega and Nzonzi played in the final against Liverpool two years ago, the rest is a whole new team including the manager.
So the point of Seville has more heritage is none sens. He is trying so hard to defend himself, but for what, the fans can easily google Seville team players in the last 7 years.

#the_caward_one
 

The Hacker

Full Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
530
Very interesting debate here.

I think some of the words he used have been taken out of context or he meant something else by them completely.

Given ‘history’ in football can be as long or as short as you want it to be depending on the point your are making, If I take his headlines he’s not far off the truth.

He inherited a poor squad in the main. Players we all knew wouldn’t be good enough to challenge for anything much bar a decent cup run.
Other teams doing well have, in the same time he’s been here, progressed better but from probably a better baseline of players to build on.
Getting knocked out now or in the next round of the CL amounts to the same thing as we wouldn’t have had the quality to win it anyway - this is an interesting point for me. He doesn’t see it as losing to Sevilla, he sees it as losing the tie irrespective of who it is. We as fans see it as a team we should beat. He sees it as a tie that we lost.

If the board all are behind him as he says then we should all buckle down and get used to this slow rebuild. I just hope we don’t lose the likes of Martial and Pogba in the journey!
 

OverratedOpinion

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
6,512
It's understandable that he's frustrated. Anyone having to deal with the constant barrage from the press would be frustrated.
Him playing defensively is one thing - I don't mind a good defence as you can't win by going all out attacking. You need to have the right balance between defence and attack. At the moment, attack is non-existent and defensively (surprisingly) we're not much better. On top of that, he sets us up cowardly and we play with fear - that comes from the manager.
I thought he'd learnt a lesson when his same cowardly methods got Chelsea knocked out against PSG in the CL some years ago, but he hasn't learnt, and it doesn't seem as if he cares to address that problem. This is I believe the big issue, coupled with his complete lack of respect for Manchester United. He had a breakdown at Chelsea and was still given another chance, and backed by our club, yet he's ungrateful and disrespectful. It's completely unforgivable in my eyes.
Well if my maths is correct and we play 3 more games in the FA Cup this season we are on course to score 108 goals in all comps (based on our average up to this point). Doesn't sound like a particularly low scoring season to me, mind I don't generally keep track of those types of statistics. He didn't win the Champions League with Chelsea because his Chelsea team was not even in the top 3 in Europe, same way our team is not in the top 5 in Europe. Not many coaches in the last 20 years have won the Champions League without having at least one of the top 2 or 3 squads on paper, in fact one of the only people who have is Jose himself.

The reason people back Jose is because he has won things everywhere he has been, I do agree that he needs to focus on instilling a more cohesive style of gameplay but I think the progress is obvious. My hopeful expectations this season would have been 2nd or 3rd in the league and Quarter Finals of the Champions League, going out one stage earlier just doesn't feel like a cardinal sin to me.

If you are referring to the press conference then I don't know what to tell you, we have been terrible for a number of years. I don't see addressing that as disrespectful to the club, especially considering how salient it is.
 

OverratedOpinion

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
6,512
Checkmate.
Sir Alex did alright after that. Although if we are all going to be held accountable for things we said nearly a decade and a half ago then I need to hold my hands up and admit that I was wrong when I said Amir Khan would go on to be the best boxer on the planet.
 

Jazz

Just in case anyone missed it. I don't like Mount.
Joined
Feb 11, 2014
Messages
31,056
Well if my maths is correct and we play 3 more games in the FA Cup this season we are on course to score 108 goals in all comps (based on our average up to this point). Doesn't sound like a particularly low scoring season to me, mind I don't generally keep track of those types of statistics. He didn't win the Champions League with Chelsea because his Chelsea team was not even in the top 3 in Europe, same way our team is not in the top 5 in Europe. Not many coaches in the last 20 years have won the Champions League without having at least one of the top 2 or 3 squads on paper, in fact one of the only people who have is Jose himself.

The reason people back Jose is because he has won things everywhere he has been, I do agree that he needs to focus on instilling a more cohesive style of gameplay but I think the progress is obvious. My hopeful expectations this season would have been 2nd or 3rd in the league and Quarter Finals of the Champions League, going out one stage earlier just doesn't feel like a cardinal sin to me.

If you are referring to the press conference then I don't know what to tell you, we have been terrible for a number of years. I don't see addressing that as disrespectful to the club, especially considering how salient it is.
It was disrespectful to me and others. You never discuss anything like that in public. Never ever. He needed to shut up and get working on things behind the scenes. It sounded like he holds our club in contempt and that fecking hurt to hear a Manchester United manager throwing shit on the club to cover up his cowardly management.

I can deal with losing, I don't have any problem if I can see the manager has a plan and is working well with the current players to get the best out of them - but this isn't what he's doing.
 

Water Melon

Guest
Knocked out by Sevilla managed by a rookie manager. Tottally outplayed while having the most expensive squad in England. Being miles off the City and doing worse in CL with Utd than Moyes, while having brought in 7 players. This is not good. We do not seem to be a real team, we more look like a team that relies on individual quality. If no CL or EPL trophy by the end of next season, get rid. By that time we will have spent half a billion under Jose.
 

OverratedOpinion

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
6,512
It was disrespectful to me and others. You never discuss anything like that in public. Never ever. He needed to shut up and get working on things behind the scenes. It sounded like he holds our club in contempt and that fecking hurt to hear a Manchester United manager throwing shit on the club to cover up his cowardly management.

I can deal with losing, I don't have any problem if I can see the manager has a plan and is working well with the current players to get the best out of them - but this isn't what he's doing.
Whether it was appropriate or not is probably largely down to pre-existing perspective. You probably don't like the bloke so it felt wrong, I have always liked him personally (begrudgingly before) and to me it looked like he was backed into a corner and felt forced to respond which he did accurately. Felt much more like an attack on our recent failings than an attack on the club which he has always spoken of very highly when it comes to larger historical terms.

The truth is probably somewhere in the middle, maybe he shouldn't have said it but not the end of the world.

Either way Jose will continue to manage the way he has managed, he would be stupid not to as it has elevated him to the point that he is probably going to be viewed as one of the top 5 to ever do the job when he retires. These conversations will keep happening and my god are they already boring.
 

OverratedOpinion

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
6,512
If no CL or EPL trophy by the end of next season, get rid.
No offence but I think if we keep taking this attitude whilst giving the manager a weird mesh of 3 or 4 half built teams and hoping they can throw enough money at the problem then we will go a long time without winning either. I have been very clear about my fondness for Jose but honestly I just want us to pick a manager and back them properly with the time they actually need. People will talk about what Pep has done so quickly but Man City have been a very good attacking side for nearly 10 years.
 

Jazz

Just in case anyone missed it. I don't like Mount.
Joined
Feb 11, 2014
Messages
31,056
Whether it was appropriate or not is probably largely down to pre-existing perspective. You probably don't like the bloke so it felt wrong, I have always liked him personally (begrudgingly before) and to me it looked like he was backed into a corner and felt forced to respond which he did accurately. Felt much more like an attack on our recent failings than an attack on the club which he has always spoken of very highly when it comes to larger historical terms.

The truth is probably somewhere in the middle, maybe he shouldn't have said it but not the end of the world.

Either way Jose will continue to manage the way he has managed, he would be stupid not to as it has elevated him to the point that he is probably going to be viewed as one of the top 5 to ever do the job when he retires. These conversations will keep happening and my god are they already boring.
For your information I never liked nor disliked him before so I have no pre-existing perspective. Nevertheless, I wanted him to succeed. I thought he would think of this as a great chance to change, but it's clear in my eyes that he can't or won't or both.

He's only ever spoken 'highly' of the club when things are going his way. He doesn't give a shit about anything or anyone except his ego. If you haven't realised it by now, you soon will.

As for his management, it doesn't work anymore - that's been clear for a while. He is wrong not to change but that's on him.
 

Water Melon

Guest
No offence but I think if we keep taking this attitude whilst giving the manager a weird mesh of 3 or 4 half built teams and hoping they can throw enough money at the problem then we will go a long time without winning either. I have been very clear about my fondness for Jose but honestly I just want us to pick a manager and back them properly with the time they actually need. People will talk about what Pep has done so quickly but Man City have been a very good attacking side for nearly 10 years.
How do you define the time that a manager actually needs? 3 years, 6 transfer windows, half a billion net spent. Seems more than fair for me to expect at least one CL or EPL trophy.
 

mitchmouse

loves to hate United.
Joined
Oct 8, 2014
Messages
17,637
All the idiot callers to Six O Six and pundits say he is being arrogant, actually he sort of reminded me of Keegan and "we'd love it, we would". he seems to have lost it! let's hpe he's shown that anger to the players who were so piss awful in midweek
 

OverratedOpinion

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
6,512
For your information I never liked nor disliked him before so I have no pre-existing perspective. Nevertheless, I wanted him to succeed. I thought he would think of this as a great chance to change, but it's clear in my eyes that he can't or won't or both.

He's only ever spoken 'highly' of the club when things are going his way. He doesn't give a shit about anything or anyone except his ego. If you haven't realised it by now, you soon will.

As for his management, it doesn't work anymore - that's been clear for a while. He is wrong not to change but that's on him.
You've called him cowardly and said the only thing he cares about is his ego. I think it is fair to say you don't like him :lol:

Yes, people tend to be more upbeat conversationally when things are going well. Of course he has no special affinity with the club, much like any manager we will ever hire outside of former players (and most players that will ever play for us).

It won him the title at Chelsea, it won him the title at Real Madrid, treble at Inter Milan. Even last year it won us a European trophy and the league cup and has us above Klopp, Poch, Conte and whoever the next darling is this year. When exactly did it stop working? Was it when we lost one match against Sevilla?
 

Man of Leisure

Threatened by women who like sex.
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
13,931
Location
One Big Holiday
Just seen the press conference. Childish rant from Mourinho. Lowering expectations after all the money he’s spent is a joke.
 

DannyCAFC

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2014
Messages
2,427
Supports
Charlton Athletic
Knocked out by Sevilla managed by a rookie manager. Tottally outplayed while having the most expensive squad in England. Being miles off the City and doing worse in CL with Utd than Moyes, while having brought in 7 players. This is not good. We do not seem to be a real team, we more look like a team that relies on individual quality. If no CL or EPL trophy by the end of next season, get rid. By that time we will have spent half a billion under Jose.
How have you concluded that United's squad is the most expensive in England over City's? This is simply not true.
 

marko goalo

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Feb 8, 2017
Messages
111
Whether he stays or not will probably come down to whether he can hang on to the dressing room. As an outsider looking in there appear to be a few cracks appearing. And with player power where it is now there will probably only be one winner
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
22,967
Location
Somewhere out there
Knocked out by Sevilla managed by a rookie manager. Tottally outplayed while having the most expensive squad in England. Being miles off the City and doing worse in CL with Utd than Moyes, while having brought in 7 players. This is not good. We do not seem to be a real team, we more look like a team that relies on individual quality. If no CL or EPL trophy by the end of next season, get rid. By that time we will have spent half a billion under Jose.
How have you concluded that United's squad is the most expensive in England over City's? This is simply not true.
Oh @DannyCAFC... don't be letting a good fact get in the way of @Water Melon making a complete Melon of himself. :lol:

City's current squad cost 918 million euros, it's the most expensive squad ever assembled in World football.
 

Z1L3

Full Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2017
Messages
231
Supports
Partizan Belgrade
Mourinho could do with hearing a few home truths too. Its easier to be "cool and witty" when you get the job done, maybe he should start there.
That's exactly his problem and where he disappoints me; when faced with a bad result he becomes overly preoccupied about what the media is saying. He could've just acknowledged that Sevilla was a bad game and move on. Instead he starts a war with the press that is completely unnecessary.
 

Water Melon

Guest
Oh @DannyCAFC... don't be letting a good fact get in the way of @Water Melon making a complete Melon of himself. :lol:

City's current squad cost 918 million euros, it's the most expensive squad ever assembled in World football.
https://www.sportskeeda.com/amp/football/10-most-valuable-squads-clubs-europe-football
Now tell me what are the prices that Pep bought his players for? How much did KdB, Jesus cost at the time? How much did we pay for Pogba and Lukaku? How much did the scouse pay for Salah and what is his current value? We have spent tons of money yet we did nothing of note in Europe. There is zero evidence that Jose is still one of the best in England let alone in the world. On the contrary, there is plenty of evidence that teams actually flourish when he leaves.
 

Z1L3

Full Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2017
Messages
231
Supports
Partizan Belgrade
https://www.sportskeeda.com/amp/football/10-most-valuable-squads-clubs-europe-football
Now tell me what are the prices that Pep bought his players for? How much did KdB, Jesus cost at the time? How much did we pay for Pogba and Lukaku? How much did the scouse pay for Salah and what is his current value? We have spent tons of money yet we did nothing of note in Europe. There is zero evidence that Jose is still one of the best in England let alone in the world. On the contrary, there is plenty of evidence that teams actually flourish when he leaves.
As far as evidence that he is still one of the best; name one team where he left before winning trophies. And the fact that teams flourish after he leaves has nothing to do with his work at those clubs? I guess if he left clubs in ruins (like his predecessors at United) that would make him a better manager?

If you want your club to flourish, then hire Mourihno and then make him leave, and voila, your club will flourish. Unbelievable!
 

Water Melon

Guest
As far as evidence that he is still one of the best; name one team where he left before winning trophies. And the fact that teams flourish after he leaves has nothing to do with his work at those clubs? I guess if he left clubs in ruins (like his predecessors at United) that would make him a better manager?

If you want your club to flourish, then hire Mourihno and then make him leave, and voila, your club will flourish. Unbelievable!
Chelsea were 1 point above relegation during his last season with them. Fact. Real Madrid sacked him and went on to really dominate the world football without Mou, fact. Chelsea's last EPL trophy is all on Conte, whereas Reals are on Ancelotti and Zizou. Jose has got nothing to do with those. What Mou is directly resposible is for throwing a towel to the league before new year and being schooled by a rookie manager of a team with a tiny fraction of a budget compared to United's in Europe. I am ready to bet now that he will not win the Prem or CL next season. I am sure you are brave enough to take this bet. If you are happy with top 4 finish and no CL or EPL cups, then we have different expectations.
 

Z1L3

Full Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2017
Messages
231
Supports
Partizan Belgrade
Chelsea were 1 point above relegation during his last season with them. Fact. Real Madrid sacked him and went on to really dominate the world football without Mou, fact. Chelsea's last EPL trophy is all on Conte, whereas Reals are on Ancelotti and Zizou. Jose has got nothing to do with those. What Mou is directly resposible is for throwing a towel to the league before new year and being schooled by a rookie manager of a team with a tiny fraction of a budget compared to United's in Europe. I am ready to bet now that he will not win the Prem or CL next season. I am sure you are brave enough to take this bet. If you are happy with top 4 finish and no CL or EPL cups, then we have different expectations.
Absolutely false, all of it. Chelsea won the title the year before and their downfall the following season was due to conflict between players and manager. The same team finished 3rd the previous season. So, 3rd and 1st with Jose before getting sacked, and then 1st again the following season. That's a team that he built.

Real Madrid didn't win the cup for 18 years, the league in 3 (and Barcelona was at the height of its power), and hadn't progressed into quarterfinals of CL for something like 7 seasons before he went there. In 3 seasons he won the cup, the league, and took them to two semis of the CL.

The fact is that he produces results everywhere he goes and when he leaves the clubs are set up for success after his departure. That's what the facts show.

I also have concerns regarding some of his behavior, but the fact that the fans are a bunch of spoiled unrealistic babies who are not backing him despite obvious progress is not helping. The amount of negativity throughout this season is extraordinary considering that the team is 2nd in the league, in the semis of FA, and won the group in the CL. Yes, there have been bad performances, yes it's sometimes boring, yes the Sevilla thing was disappointing, but one would think that the team is out of all cups and in relegation battle listening to the pundits and some of the fans.

Liverpool (pretty much guaranteed not to win anything), Chelsea, and Spurs are still very much uncertain of top 4 finish but all the talk is about United. I get the feeling that most pundits wouldn't be able to bare it if United won a major title with Jose, and the fans are apparently unable to see through that.

People complain that the team is spineless and then turn around and criticize Mourihno when he calls out the players for it. I guess he made too many enemies over the years so now he can't do anything right.
 
Last edited:

Water Melon

Guest
As far as evidence that he is still one of the best; name one team where he left before winning trophies. And the fact that teams flourish after he leaves has nothing to do with his work at those clubs? I guess if he left clubs in ruins (like his predecessors at United) that would make him a better manager?

If you want your club to flourish, then hire Mourihno and then make him leave, and voila, your club will flourish. Unbelievable!
No. The evidence shows that he was one of the best. Is last 7 years is enough time span for you? How many league titles and CLs has he won during this period? Compare that with other managers. For the record we were beaten by Sevilla this season. We are yet to challenge properly for the league. We have different opinions, but that is the beauty of this forum, so case closed for me. Agreed to disagree.
 

Water Melon

Guest
Absolutely false, all of it. Chelsea won the title the year before and their downfall the following season was due to conflict between players and manager. The same team finished 3rd the previous season. So, 3rd and 1st with Jose before getting sacked, and then 1st again the following season. That's a team that he built.

Real Madrid didn't win the cup for 18 years, the league in 3 (and Barcelona was at the height of its power), and hadn't progressed into quarterfinals of CL for something like 7 seasons before he went there. In 3 seasons he won the cup, the league, and took them to two semis of the CL.

The fact is that he produces results everywhere he goes and when he leaves the clubs are set up for success after his departure. That's what the facts show.

I also have concerns regarding some of his behavior, but the fact that the fans are a bunch of spoiled unrealistic babies who are not backing him despite obvious progress is not helping. The amount of negativity throughout this season is extraordinary considering that the team is 2nd in the league, in the semis of FA, and won the group in the CL. Yes, there have been bad performances, yes it's sometimes boring, yes the Sevilla thing was disappointing, but one would think that the team is out of all cups and in relegation battle listening to the pundits and some of the fans.

Liverpool (pretty much guaranteed not to win anything), Chelsea, and Spurs are still very much uncertain of top 4 finish but all the talk is about United. I get the feeling that most pundits wouldn't be able to bare it if United won a major title with Jose, and the fans are apparently unable to see through that.

People complain that the team is spineless and then turn around and criticize Mourihno when he calls out the players for it. I guess he made too many enemies over the years so now he can't do anything right.
This is false. The facts are facts Chelsea were 1 point above relegation due to Jose and his fall out with players. So the reason is Jose. Conte walked the league, when all of Pep, Mou, Klopp and Poch were here. So the fact is that Conte did with Chelsea better than Mou with United. Another fact is that by the end of this season Pep will have done much better with City than Jose with United. Also, the last two stints of Jose prior to joining United show that he has complete meltdowns, loses the dressing room and once he leaves those teams, their new managers do better. Zizou did what Mou was not able to do with Real and this is another fact. Unless Jose wins the league with United, I can not call him the best manager in the league, let alone one of the best ones in the world. Last season, Mous level was 6th in the Prem and the best in EL. This season not being able to beat Sevilla is total failure. Beaten fair and square by a complete rookie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.