We could buy another fred+bailly for this 90m. Sounds good.
What would be an acceptable offer for Pogba?
- Thread starter Bastian
- Start date
- Status
Some of the comments in this thread were shambolic 
. Funny how much has changed in just a month
If spurs want 300m for kane,Pogba's at least worth 250m
. Funny how much has changed in just a monthIf spurs want 300m for kane,Pogba's at least worth 250m
Pogba is a bigger talent than that slack jawed cnut will ever be. If Kane is 300 Pogba is 400.
Ive read this a few times and still dont get it. You would have sold him for less in a heartbeat even though you thought he would fetch more in the summer?
He’s priceless.
No point selling when you’d be replacing with a vastly inferior player.
No point selling when you’d be replacing with a vastly inferior player.
I guess us fans are emotive. I was also reading the thread in the TF forum earlier titled ‘Potential Pogba replacements’ (or something like that). Lot of people seemed to think we’d move on quite easily.Some of the comments in this thread were shambolic
If spurs want 300m for kane,Pogba's at least worth 250m
There is no player that can replace Pogba. Which makes us very fortunate to have him. Other teams have ‘midfielders’. We have a Pogba.
Absurd to entertain thoughts of selling him. If he has to go we should demand a WR fee as I don't see any reason to be willing to sell.
That's a slightly over the top. We have had better CMs than Pogba in the past. Also it's disrespectful to how well the likes of Herrera have been playing to claim Pogba is our midfield.
But yeah no chance we should sell him. He is one of the best midfielders in the game.
Wouldnt even get us a 27 year old CB
How is his value only going down when you just said you think we could get more for him in the summer? On current form he's double the 90.
Take it you don't like Kane much
Bet you'd swap him for Lukaku instantly though right?
Funny isn't it? It's astonishing how people were quick to turn against players and buy into Mourinho gibberish.
Nah, I quite like him, just find his slurry speech annoying, that is in addition to the ridiculous overrating. Rashford is as much a talent as Kane, Pogba is just a notch above both, which anyone with two eyes and lack of ABU can see.Take it you don't like Kane much
Bet you'd swap him for Lukaku instantly though right?
If Pogba transfers from us and goes to Barca\RM, then you will see everyone that criticise him doing an 180 immediately and have him as the best midfielder in the world instantly.
Apart from Scholes who is one of the all time best, who else we have had in the PL era who's better than Pogba? And why is it disrespectful to Herrera to say Pogba is out best player?
Pogba is a better player than Kane. This is not even a debate. Pogba is world class, Kane isn't.Take it you don't like Kane much
Bet you'd swap him for Lukaku instantly though right?
You said other teams have a midfield we have Pogba which literally implies that it's all about Pogba and nobody else.
Roy Keane? Most would would say Robson before that. I think Pogba is great but let's calm down a tad. He's not playing for Spurs. He's an at elite club. Doing really well at the moment but he hasn't lived up to expectations thus far let alone touch our all time greats.
It isn't a debate only because you seemingly don't have an argument to back up your aimless claims.
I'd possibly take Pogba over Kane but it is a debate and Kane has our performed Pogba in their time together in the premier League. He just hasn't been lucky enough to play for Juventus or France.
I think what the guy who said that meant is that Pogba is an unique kind of midfielder, a level above any other midfield like Messi is above any other player.
Pogba is twice the player Roy Keane was. Robson, I didn't watch him play to have a fair personal view of him, how many years he played in the PL format?
I think both Pogba and Kane have similar value in the market and to their team and are unquestionable star players. They would both start at any club in world football, the debate is pointless who is worth 10m more or less.
Pogba shouldnt be sold, give him a new contract and tell him to ditch his fat agent if possible.
Pogba shouldnt be sold, give him a new contract and tell him to ditch his fat agent if possible.
Okay, twice the player Keane was. Class above like Messi. You clearly are just a huge fan of Pogba's and have no objectivity in this regard. Let's leave it at this.So you were fine when we sold japp stam.?
Why are you guys trying to sell Pogba?
300, dont want him to go though, he is our star player we need more like him.
It'd be difficult to compare them as they don't play in same position. Going by pure talent and how they've been decisive for the teams they played in, Pogba is the best player.
You what? You never watched Roy Keane play or something?
Completely agree re Pogba. I think if you play Pogba in the position that gets the best out of his qualities there aren't many better midfielders in world football. Be madness to sell him now that we have a manager that plays him in the position where he can damage the opposition like he has been these last 6 matches
It's difficult but you already comapared them. Pure talent? Sure, Pogba has him beat. Decisiveness? Pogba has often been dropped while Kane I think scored more goals than anybody in 2017?
Two excellent players and I wouldn't trade Pogba out of personal preference but your view appears heavily biased.
Pogba and Kane play completely different positions so bit hard to debate who is a better player - it's like comparing De Gea and Ramos for the sake of argument.
But come on, Kane not world class? I don't see many better no. 9's out there at the moment and would snap him up if we could.
Keane was the best midfielder of the premier league era. Scholes is then battling with Vieira for second spot.
Pogba does have more pure talent, but how good a player is involves a lot more than only pure talent.
Watched him plenty of time. Great player and leader, but Pogba is simply better player than him.
People thought the same about Keane,Scholes, Beckham ,Giggs, any "key" player.
Fact is, all players can be replaced. Its all about how you plan the transition . Will be disastrous to sell him now or summer - i give that.
Again, absolutely batshit.
Great leader Keane, good tackler, decent passer, but that's kind of it. He doesn't posses even a quarter of Paul's technical abilities.
Dunno why I feel that most people overrate Keane just because he was a leader.
Viera and Scholes were better player. But I don't want this debate again, everyone with his opinion.
Keane was the best midfielder of the premier league era. Scholes is then battling with Vieira for second spot.
Pogba does have more pure talent, but how good a player is involves a lot more than only pure talent.
As a leader,Keane has no peer in Utd's history. Alongside Pogba now we'd have the best midfield in the PL
Keane was the best midfielder of the premier league era. Scholes is then battling with Vieira for second spot.
Pogba does have more pure talent, but how good a player is involves a lot more than only pure talent.
What on earth?
Truly embarrassing stuff coming from supposed 'fans' of the club
The likes of Henderson,Jorginho,Lucas fecking Torreria and Delle Alli even being mentioned in the same sentence...I think that's enough internet for me today
Jose had really managed to turn a decent portion of the fanbase into diet Graeme Souness's
He'd certainly add weight to the deal.Take it you don't like Kane much
Bet you'd swap him for Lukaku instantly though right?
In the current market? 300 million, if you consider inflated prices, quality and marketing potential.
What in the holy world of shit is this? I'm not even a Utd fan but even I know this is utter nonsense of the highest order.
Only if you watched Pogba under Mourinho. If you watched him at Juve and in his NT you'd have a different opinion.
- Status