I think the lesson here is that whatever @Tarrou thinks about acting, if you think the opposite you're probably correct.
As a former child star who once played the role of a clownfish during a ten show run in a small junior dramatic society to stunning 200 capacity crowds, I can say with confidence that @Tarrou is on the wum.I think the lesson here is that whatever @Tarrou thinks about acting, if you think the opposite you're probably correct.
I love the way they shot the sequence, like it was almost a dream for Joel. He knows what he is doing is wrong, and that Ellie would hate him for it, but he just can’t stop himself. He couldn’t save Sarah, but he will not let Ellie die.Wow. That was an incredible finish. Felt some of the same unforgettable emotions as when I played the game.
Eh?What a remarkable person. She can remember her birth.
If you're being serious, don't think that was what they were trying to get across at all.What a remarkable person. She can remember her birth.
I was joking.If you're being serious, don't think that was what they were trying to get across at all.
But that's fairly obvious, so perhaps I'm the one being an idiot.
Really was brilliant. Brutal as well but they managed to not make that aspect of it unwatchableI love the way they shot the sequence, like it was almost a dream for Joel. He knows what he is doing is wrong, and that Ellie would hate him for it, but he just can’t stop himself. He couldn’t save Sarah, but he will not let Ellie die.
I think he was wrong given the bigger picture and thats what helps make it all so conflicted.Good finish.
Was Joel right or wrong ?
i think he was right given the situation , but wrong to lie.
It's a fantastic moral dilemma, don't think there truly is a right or wrong answerGood finish.
Was Joel right or wrong ?
i think he was right given the situation , but wrong to lie.
Good finish.
Was Joel right or wrong ?
i think he was right given the situation , but wrong to lie.
The FF were wrong. Ellie should have been told and been given the choice. Also remember it’s still uncertain if it will work. So Joel was put in a situation where he had to act..I think he was wrong given the bigger picture and thats what helps make it all so conflicted.
Of course he was right, the utilitarian decision Marlene came to was wrong.Good finish.
Was Joel right or wrong ?
i think he was right given the situation , but wrong to lie.
He was definitely in the wrong if you consider the "greater good".Good finish.
Was Joel right or wrong ?
i think he was right given the situation , but wrong to lie.
Recreating Ellie’s conditions of birth means infecting potentially tens or hundreds of women. And then waiting to see if the baby develops immunity. Those who don’t probably die as well.Of course he was right, the utilitarian decision Marlene came to was wrong.
Plus the episode makes her look worse . Given she was there just after Ellie's birth and her close relationship with mom, she's either incredibly stupid not to figure out the cause of immunity or if she did, why not create a program to recreate Ellie's voluntarily, instead of risking everything on one teen.
Being willing to straight up sacrifice Ellie without a back up with what she knows is silly but most importantly like most ultilitarians she wouldn't put herself through it for the greater good, which is an option with her knowledge from the second she knew Ellie was immune.
She had all the knowledge and took away Ellie's choice and Joel's ability to accept that choice had Ellie made it.
Solid contribution to the thread as always.episode seven is slow af
when do they start lezzing it up?
I know the series is grim in general, but if you're waiting for a full hour to watch a couple of thirteen year-olds 'lez it up' then you might want to go do something else.episode seven is slow af
when do they start lezzing it up?
can't believe you waited a full hour for that!I know the series is grim in general, but if you're waiting for a full hour to watch a couple of thirteen year-olds 'lez it up' then you might want to go do something else.
Actually in hindsight I missed what @nimic posted, and hadn't seen your previous efforts in the thread. Sounds lovely.
Is that confirmed?Second and third season will be from game two
During season three, game three will be released.
Season four and five from game three.
There's a good few rumours about it, and they've said they had a storyline planned for Part 3, but currently nothing more than that and they seem unsure whether the thing will happen at all.Is that confirmed?
It is just their plan. The game developers are a part of the TV show, so it is a cohesive team moving forward.Is that confirmed?
How are they surviving. Are they in an area that's only accessible by using the ladder to climb up?Solid finale and they included the giraffes scene!
Weird way of saying it's not confirmed and you're regurgitating rumours as fact.It is just their plan. The game developers are a part of the TV show, so it is a cohesive team moving forward.
As long as they can eat, who's gonna tackle a massive feck off giraffe? Especially when there's a few of them.How are they surviving. Are they in an area that's only accessible by using the ladder to climb up?
The giraffes? I always assumed that the infected had no interest in animals and that they attacked humans as a means of "reproduction". It could also be that very few infected remain in SLC.How are they surviving. Are they in an area that's only accessible by using the ladder to climb up?
As long as they can eat, who's gonna tackle a massive feck off giraffe? Especially when there's a few of them.
Hmm you're right I haven't seen any other infected animals. It was a nice moment to remind us of the things we take for granted.The giraffes? I always assumed that the infected had no interest in animals and that they attacked humans as a means of "reproduction". It could also be that very few infected remain in SLC.
But that doesn't make it right. The world and stuff is pretty much established, a slower more careful approach that is voluntary is far more logical than her choices given what we now know.Recreating Ellie’s conditions of birth means infecting potentially tens or hundreds of women. And then waiting to see if the baby develops immunity. Those who don’t probably die as well.
They are in apocalypse, choices most of the time won’t be perfect or easy. Overwhelming number of survivors shown on screen have made these kind of choices already. If the operation succeeds and they get the cure, no one would care about Marlene’s choice.