Client6
Full Member
Bad keeper, terrible signing for United. The worst United have had since John O'Shea.
Trust me, it would make a huge differenceI guarantee that you could replace Onana with another keeper and it would make not a fecking jot of difference. When a team concedes shots at the rate we do, it's absolutely inevitable that there will be some that he lets in that he probably shouldn't.
I won't disagree with you too much on that, I wouldn't have him as a top shot stopper.It's just, how many times have we seen a goal this season where you think that the goalkeeper isn't specifically to blame but you'd want him to save that kind of shot.
How many goals have we conceded like that + the shit goals we've conceded that were definitely him to blame vs whoa Onana really saved our skin with that goalkeeping.
I'm really curious to hear which keeper you think would be getting the side conceding more shots per game than every side in the league bar the record-breakingly shite defence of Sheffield United into a much higher position than we are...Trust me, it would make a huge difference
A top keeper obviously wouldn't do much for this team. We're conceding more shots than any team in the league bar a side that has literally broken the record for goals conceded in Premier League history.I won't disagree with you too much on that, I wouldn't have him as a top shot stopper.
I'm not sure even a top one does much for this team, it's a mess.
Why is it that lower placed keepers, who always face more shots, usually have a good save percentage and their stats very strong and they get bought by teams higher up the leagues?I'm really curious to hear which keeper you think would be getting the side conceding more shots per game than every side in the league bar the record-breakingly shite defence of Sheffield United into a much higher position than we are...
You have zero clue about statistics. It's really that simple.A top keeper obviously wouldn't do much for this team. We're conceding more shots than any team in the league bar a side that has literally broken the record for goals conceded in Premier League history.
Anyone who thinks there is a keeper out there who would have us getting considerably better results knows feck all about the sport they're watching. I'm sorry, it really is that simple.
It wouldn't have made a bug difference in the league at this point but overall, looking at the season, it's had a big effect because going out of the CL like we did was in a big way on him. Psychologically it has no doubt had a big effect in a negative way on our squad.I won't disagree with you too much on that, I wouldn't have him as a top shot stopper.
I'm not sure even a top one does much for this team, it's a mess.
Onana's stats are strong, so I have no idea why you're bringing that up like it's a point against him.Why is it that lower placed keepers, who always face more shots, usually have a good save percentage and their stats very strong and they get bought by teams higher up the leagues?
Because while they face volume, their ability as shit stoppers means they can make more saves, not less.
Now variance happens depending on how clinical the opposition are but in general, teams will have pot shots and saveable shots, they won't all be worldies.
So just because he has a high volume of shots, doesn't mean he naturally has to ship the most goals.
But besides from the stats, the eye test. The guy cannot make routine saves.
If O'Shea played as goalkeeper for 3 months, he'd be better than Onana.Bad keeper, terrible signing for United. The worst United have had since John O'Shea.
Agreed. He doesn't have the ability to make saves he shouldnt be able to get to i.e. like the very best keepers do. Somehow they keep the ball out by pulling off a worldoe save.The difference between Onana and a top keeper is they save two of those goals, maybe three and keep us in the game.
And a top keeper doesn't kneel and pray for that last Edouard shotThe difference between Onana and a top keeper is they save two of those goals, maybe three and keep us in the game.
Meh, everyone absolutely despised him after his disasterclass against Ghana in the WC. I don't think he was the answer either.Terrible keeper. We could have got Costa from Porto for the same price.
Asking god for an interventionAnd a top keeper doesn't kneel and pray for that last Edouard shot
O'Shea kept a clean sheet.Bad keeper, terrible signing for United. The worst United have had since John O'Shea.
Decent shout.Anyone take a punt on Ramsdale?
Straight swap sure.Anyone take a punt on Ramsdale?
Christ no. Absolute bombscare of a keeper.Everton are going down. Picking up Pickford then?
Nah, he’s as bad as Onana. All mouth and no trousers.Everton are going down. Picking up Pickford then?
Edit: Oh shoot. They are 15th?