Yesterday strangely suited us off the ball, let us play deep and defend that way. We know that the players can do that. Nothing really learned, but a big three points as far as safety is concerned. I was worried at half time.
Ruben Amorim - Manchester United Head Coach
- Thread starter sewey89
- Start date
Again. It's a load of over romanticised nonsense. Just like the "United DNA".
The United way post 1990 has been the winning way. Fergie wasn't scared about drifting away from the club’s "ideals" if it meant winning football matches.
Even in our last season of playing anything close to what people see as the "Busby Way" back in 2007/2008, Fergie went uber defensive in the two games against Barca (Mourinho esque if you will) to get us over the line.
There isn't a blueprint of how the players should play in the academy (like there is at say Barca or Ajax). We might try and implement wider skills but I don't think we've ever had a set style, a way to win etc that was tangible like the clubs mentioned above.
You're reading it as a native English speaker though, the context of the sentence is not what you're saying.
He's basically saying they want us to do something for some reasons i.e. they have a tactical plan and the players need to follow it. I feel like you're going to the extreme of bruno saying 'I have no idea why we do some things' etc. which is very at odds with the context of the whole segment.
It doesn't feel like we've won 6 and drawn 1 of our last 10. The performances feel like about 8 losses and 2 draws.
Maybe there's something positive there though as surely we can only get better
Maybe there's something positive there though as surely we can only get better
The point still stands.
Here's a thing. Why should we have the stomach for it? We're gonna have another ticket price hike in the summer, fans are routinely treated like shite by the club etc.
The club routinely spends 150 million + every summer but we keep being told that we need to spend more because the players signed the previous year aren't up to it.
We keep being told we need a rebuild but there's only 2 regular starters from Ten Hag's first season that played last night.
We're currently in the bottom half of the table because the new manager insists on a formation that suits hardly any of our current players but we're told there's essentially a long term plan but nobody really knows who's in charge of actually implementing that long term strategy/vision.
We've been told that there's no money for a rebuild. So a manager who can work with most of these players is needed.
Nothing before this has ever really been a proper rebuild. To rebuild something you have to break it down. Most of what we've done is paper over the cracks.
The club is taking the piss out of the fans, we shouldn't be taking the toll for the Glazers mismanagement.
I think you just stated the point, we have spent over 600m since Ten Hag came in and have wasted it and created a worse squad than he inherited.
We were also bottom half of the table when Ten Hag was sacked and he created this squad, I have faith in Amorim, their is definite room for criticism in the way we play and some tactical decisions. That being said doesn't mean he should chuck out his principles for these players, they have shown for an extended period they are clearly not good enough, there needs to be a compromise to get results.
The result last night has put the relegation story to bed, performance was bright in patches with the usual defensive mistakes, the 3 points was more important than anything, this is where we are atm.
The only proper transfer window the current Sporting board have had was the January one, no ETH influence, they loaned out multiple players deemed surplus to requirements, signed a potential in Leon and a starting LWB who looks like he can handle the physicality and perform in the PL in his short spell so far, had a wobble last night but all young players will.
Am I confident we are going to suddenly turn this around no, but I have more faith in these than I have at any other point since Sir Alex left.
7 wins, 3 draws and 2 lost in last 12 games is not a bad thing, Its just the kind of performances, We could have won few games in December too if it was not Onana's series of blunders.
I am happy that Rubin clearly knows our defenders are good with Low-Block stuff but not the same when it comes to high press which is the reason even TenHag had to go back to old ways. On top of this another issue we need to address is our midfield is not too good to quickly take the ball forward so we need to address it along with getting a proper goal scorer in summer.
When they scout our next set of players, I hope they look at the players who are good at high press. Until then no point in trying that style with our current defenders and midfield who cant cope that style.
The way Rubin sets up against Arsenal/Pool gives me a hope that he may win one of Europa or FA cups as he comes across like a Little Jose in that kind of matches.
I am happy that Rubin clearly knows our defenders are good with Low-Block stuff but not the same when it comes to high press which is the reason even TenHag had to go back to old ways. On top of this another issue we need to address is our midfield is not too good to quickly take the ball forward so we need to address it along with getting a proper goal scorer in summer.
When they scout our next set of players, I hope they look at the players who are good at high press. Until then no point in trying that style with our current defenders and midfield who cant cope that style.
The way Rubin sets up against Arsenal/Pool gives me a hope that he may win one of Europa or FA cups as he comes across like a Little Jose in that kind of matches.
Agreed. Previously the 'rebuilds' were basically just managers spending big money on new players. Nothing really changed behind the scenes structurally, they made up some new titles but literally nothing changed in terms of the issues from Moyes through to ETH. Now there is a bit of hope, it is also vastly more sensible to buy younger players and develop them but it also means form is hugely erratic.
Indeed. The amount of moaning in here is quite frankly breathtaking at times. People would rather Amorim abandoned his entire ethos just to gain a couple of league positions.
He's being slick whether people recognize it or not. Sure most of it is regular sports mumbo jumbo but the two key phrases are
You could feel in moments that it's not working but for some reason the manager wants us to do that
we have a big staff and they watch so many games and prepare themselves and if they do that in the right way
Now after both those parts he says we have to listen and follow instructions etc. but you can feel the doubt coming from the captain. Doesn't sound like a guy who is fully bought in to the new system and I wouldn't be if I was him either because there is no natural role for him in the team. He's too sloppy and weak as a CM and his physical limitations and inability to beat a man make him unsuitable as the 10.
Any excuse to take a pop at the best player in our team, eh?
Best player in a team that is currently 14th in the league. What an achievement. And try to respond to the post not the poster, I put the Bruno thread on ignore so I wouldn't have to listen to the morons in that thread. So keep your circlejerk about this average player in there if you don't mind.
Please untwist your panties. I was responding to the bit in your post about Bruno, obviously. It wasn't a personal attack. Equally obviously, Bruno has previously been the best player in a team that has finished a lot higher than 14th. Including being the best player on the pitch the last time we actually won something.It's madness. We finally have a coach who is not interested in papering over cracks which is exactly what this club needs and it's what most on here have been crying out for yet they want the man sacked before he's even had a summer.
We hear that every year. I would be surprised if we don't spend around the same as we did last summer.
He was not the best player on the pitch in the FA cup final, that was a teenager playing in midfield.
Playing defensive in one off games doesn't mean United don't have the tradition of attacking football, come on mate.
He clearly was.
Literally no manager on the planet can work with these players.
He absolutely was
Well spotted... sorry, I was 28 not 38 in 1974....(born in 1946 actually) ....those little grey cells must be departing quicker than I thought
No he wasn't. A quick glance at the match day thread confirms that most people had Mainoo as MOTM as did I and the official MOTM award went to Mainoo as well.
Oh yes the ever reliable match day thread.
Always have, always will....we had a few years wandering in the football wilderness* when Busby departed (including after 1974/75) until Fergie came... don't know how many years of wandering and waiting I have left!!
My old man (also a United fan) passed just as Fergie was beginning to get somewhere, he missed out on the "You never win anything with kids" era and Eric the Red, all that, in particular the 'treble'.
* Liverpool were in the ascendancy then, looks like they are making a return.... again
I really hope you're correct but I just don't have this optimism at the moment. The only times I've had genuine faith that we were on the right track was first under Mourinho when we seemed to have a run of beating everyone 4-0 then the period under Ten Hag when we beat City, Barca and won the League Cup.
With Amorim, I'd like to see where we're at come October. A lot of these wider issues aren't his fault but he'll ultimately lose his job if he can't imorove performances consistently.
My main concern after that is if he is sacked, will Ratcliffe go for a similar manager or are we gonna someone completely different and have another 12-18 months of everyone blaming the last guy for poor performances.
You’ve had about ten responses that instantly proved your point
I'm not sure.
Post Moyes, we lost the last of Fergie's core (De Gea aside really) and spent with big Van Gaal. Everyone was buzzing when we finally started spending big on the likes of Di Maria. That felt like a proper rebuild at the time.
Then there was Mourinho when the focus seemed to be on power and experience. Signing Pogba, Lukaku, Matic etc in addition to Zlatan.
Then we moved to Ole. Then we moved to Ten Hag. Again, the team is massively different from when Erik in 2022.
Ultimately the real rebuild needs to happen off the pitch. Otherwise anything on the pitch is always going papering over the cracks until the wider structure gets sorted.
But (and this is the main problem) we still need to perform well on the pitch. We need a level of short term success for many reasons and go give people time to implement that long term plan.
I keep making this point but we're seemingly getting rid of staff and increasing ticket prices to raise a few million but the team being shite and finishing in the bottom half without winning a trophy could cost us 80-100 million?
Is this the same midfielder that won 1 duel and played 21 passes the entire game? Great game that. Must have done some wild runs to open up space for the rest.
Apparently the Villa press officer jumped in and said no Rashford questions during a Tieleman interview...how it should be done!
It's open season with the United press officer where everything is allowed and for as long as you wish.
Amorim should be facing No more questions about INEOS or staff redundancies fir the rest of the season.
It's open season with the United press officer where everything is allowed and for as long as you wish.
Amorim should be facing No more questions about INEOS or staff redundancies fir the rest of the season.
W
We should have told the ref not to count them cause some of the Cafe don’t like us scoring from set pieces!
Problem is the press officer was part of the staff redundancies
I think there's valid criticism in terms of open play creation, but set pieces shouldn't be scoffed at. We want to be good at both.
Thats quite funny because if you go watch all of our games.
Forrest - scored goals by pressing us... Morgan Gibbs white
Everton pressed us quite high
West Ham under Potter are more a pressing team
Ipswhich both games were pressing us
So go have a look at that again.
Many years of bad transfer dealings coupled with bad luck. It has caught up with us and will take many more years to recover from.
Kafkaesque claimYou’ve had about ten responses that instantly proved your point
There is also little evidence that completely rebuilding the squad to suit amorim will be worth the effort