EdWeatherall
TFD
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2006
- Messages
- 14,834
If his posts were so good in the football and United forums, and so bad in some of the others, was he ever banned from all but the ones he did good posts in??
We discussed this and every single modmin (I think), even the minority who wanted to give him a final, final, final, final, final warning and chance thought that there was zero chance that this would work and that Brad would, as usual, do what he liked, when he liked, in whatever forums he had access to. No access to the general? No problem I'll post the same stuff in the United forum and the modmins only have themselves to blame because they took my access to other forums away. Warnings would be ignored, infractions would follow, mega-drama would then ensue. Back to square one. The more I think about it the more I suspect that he never got over having his unsolicited application to be a mod declined.Your edit doesnt really make any difference to the general point being made, permaban from all forums seems overly harsh in the circumstances - I have seen several posters being banned from certain parts of the caf so it wouldnt be a first, and I think it could have been a solution for the good of the forum
Anyway I've said my bit and made my point, I havent heard anything which convinces me otherwise - whether it makes any difference I dont know, but I thought I'd throw it out there.
Who?I'm hoping CW still posts on here... she more than made for Brad's gayness.
Could have at least been worth a try - if he did as you think then fair enough, ban him.We discussed this and every single modmin (I think), even the minority who wanted to give him a final, final, final, final, final warning and chance thought that there was zero chance that this would work and that Brad would, as usual, do what he liked, when he liked, in whatever forums he had access to. No access to the general? No problem I'll post the same stuff in the United forum and the modmins only have themselves to blame because they took my access to other forums away. Warnings would be ignored, infractions would follow, mega-drama would then ensue. Back to square one. The more I think about it the more I suspect that he never got over having his unsolicited application to be a mod declined.
retweeted for LanceCantonasWife.
Good luck to Brad, one of my favourite posters and one of the nicest guys I've ever met here. I'm gonna miss him.
This....It's a fecking pathetic decision Rood, and not one made with the good of the forum in mind.
Another nail in the coffin.
Whenever you'll decide to come over and watch a game, you'll have on less "overly helpful", "going out of his way for others" person to find/give you his own ticket. This is one of the biggest losses for this forum IMO.Being banned from a web forum is insignificant in the greater scheme of things. Everyone moves on in their own direction and life goes on, usually with yet more interesting characters emerging. Hell, we've lost Davo and are still chugging along.
iPhone post!I agree with Rude.
And yet...you come back. Doesn't make a whole lot of sense.Now it's become almost an in-joke about how shit it is (and this is from someone who's generally championed it to the RR lot)..So whatever you want to say about things not being any different recently, I personally don't believe.
it's just becoming an incredibly segregated and uninteresting community ...
You obviously missed the gay internet wars - the majority of people you talk of aren't absent due to them being match goers.As someone who (sort of) knows Brad, along with Nome & Rood and many of the other match going-occasionally-gay-link-up-tollgate-crew, this definitely does seem like another nail in the Cafs coffin...Who knows? in a couple of years you'll probably have a new Brad, Mockney, Plech, Pert etc, but right now it really does seem to be getting to a ridiculous point where you're seemingly trying to deliberately feck up the whole (perceived) ethos of the Caf as we knew and loved it....You're definitely alienating a significant crew of match going reds, which considering the general OOT perception of the Caf amongst them as it is, seems to be a particularly counter productive exercise
We don't really want the RR crew back TBH so we don't care what they think. And if they are happy in a forum that is largely r mates who meet up at matches then that is fine, it serves its purpose. The Caf is so large now that we can't modmin it in the casual informal way we used to. It would be impossible.IMO....When I first met up with some heads off the Caf it was a communal (if embarrassing) experience....Now it's become almost an in-joke about how shit it is (and this is from someone who's generally championed it to the RR lot)..So whatever you want to say about things not being any different recently, I personally don't believe.
Brad did more than enough to be banned multiple times.I can't imagine Brad said anything racist or mental, and it was just a succession of gay infractions that lead to this scenario...But while we're in a stage where modmins are locking threads where posters are having jokes, attempting to ban Kermit pictures and banning posters like Brad, it's just becoming an incredibly segregated and uninteresting community ...
Very disappointing.retweeted for Lance
Do Canadians play American football? I always thought they were hockey type of people.footy, jeston.
picked up a pass about 35 yards out on the left, beat three or four players across the pitch and stuck it in the right corner low from 20 yards out.
now I'm going to smoke a shoobie-doobie.
fixedfooty, jeston.
picked up a lass about 35 yards out on the left, beat three or four players across like a bitch and came in the right ones cornrow from 20 yards out.
now I'm going to smuck a shoobie-doobie.
Yes, I did...for the follwing reasonYou obviously missed the gay internet wars.
All of which would be a brilliant argument...Had I been a poster pre-2006...or pre-2008...or even pre-2009...But considering I joined in 2009, and was poster of the year in 2010 (when I was clearly enjoying it) it makes all of that completely irrelevant really.The demographic of internet users has changed in a decade. We can't have NSFW pictures or links any more because Google will withdraw their adverts which pay for the servers. People now get sued for defamation committed on the internet, the data protection acts prevents us from doing all sorts of things we used to do to sort out trouble makers. We have many times more members. Etc
The football chat and camaraderie of the very early days will never return. The free for all of the pre-RR days will never return (and in retrospect it was very like the last days of Rome only with more photoshopped photos of pigeons, stoats and various posters getting jizzed on). It was bound to collapse sooner or later and it did. Sooner.
I disagree, personally, as it's indicative of the difference in the Caf all but a year on...Last year a very funny and irreverent thread (and a completely non libelous/NSFW one to boot) was left for posters to have fun in...This year it was locked. As I said, to me, a difference in the last year.Kermit pictures aren't banned (as far as I know) but they were getting very very annoying because they were everywhere. And we usually close/delete/whatever bumped pointless posts even in the general. That last one is nothing unusual or to complain about.
People do support the modmins..Loads of them do. In the threads that are left open to discussion there are plenty of posters who support you. If you only chose to see the dissenters, or pick them out as the obvious trouble makers rather than the genuinely vocally concerned, or think that no one should have anything bad to say about the running of this place, then alright then...we're obviously poles apart on what this forum should be like.If a few more people tried to support the modmins instead of being confrontational ALL the time it would improve the site but questioning every single little thing seems to have become commonplace over the last couple of years.
My whole life is spent looking for a better analogy...Better analogy need.
Yes, we call it Canadian Football. We play it in the couple of months between winter.Do Canadians play American football? I always thought they were hockey type of people.
Lance will skewer you and make you his bitch.I like this Lance fella. Lance, you can be my squire.
You are bannedAnd we can discuss the merits of Hall Pass while we're at it..
Leaving the Brad arguments aside for a second, I feel the need to pick some holes here.As someone who (sort of) knows Brad, along with Nome & Rood and many of the other match going-occasionally-gay-link-up-tollgate-crew, this definitely does seem like another nail in the Caf's coffin...Who knows, maybe in a couple of years you'll probably have a new Brad, Mockney, Plech, Pert etc, but right now it really does seem to be getting to a ridiculous point where you're (seemingly) trying to deliberately feck up the whole perceived ethos of the Caf as we knew and loved it....You're definitely alienating a significant crew of match going reds, which considering the general OOT perception of the Caf amongst them as it is, seems to be a particularly counter productive exercise, IMO....
When I first met up with some heads off the Caf it was a communal (if embarrassing) experience....Now whenever I do it's become almost an in-joke about how shit it is (and this is from someone who's generally tried to champion it to the RR lot)..So whatever you want to say about things not being any different recently, I personally don't believe, because clearly it is. From my perspective at least.
I can't imagine Brad said anything racist or mental, and it was just a succession of gay infractions that lead to this scenario...But while we're in a stage where modmins are locking threads where posters are being irreverent, attempting to ban Kermit pictures and banning posters like Brad, it's just becoming an incredibly segregated and uninteresting community to be a part of...
I know that my involvement in this thread will lead to much cliched drama bollocks if I continue, and it'll probably end up as a long 27 page thread, about nothing, so I'm not going to post again in here, and any replies to this can be done by PM....But obviously, this is just how Nazi Germany started. Well done.
Long live Brad.
This oneIs Google still breathing down our throats?
Anyway
What was Brad's last post?
In the sense that if we don't stop all of the NSFW stuff permanently they won't allow Niall to carry their adverts. This won't change ever I doubt.Is Google still breathing down our throats?
Anyway
What was Brad's last post?
What an implosion.
We've stopped it I thought...is it still happening? Maybe I'm not paying as much attention as I used too.In the sense that if we don't stop all of the NSFW stuff permanently they won't allow Niall to carry their adverts. This won't change ever I doubt.
And no idea what Brad's last post was I'm afraid.