I didn't expect us to beat Barcelona over two legs. I was alarmed by Ole's team selections though. To play Shaw as a centreback for the first him in his career against the Barca front 3. In the 2nd leg to drop Lukaku when he saved us against PSG was baffling. I'm not impressed with his starting 11s or his substitutions and chopping and changing formations.
Not enough of a plan for me. You can't play games with only one tactic of counter attacking. He's been found out at the moment and if he thinks the Man United of old was just a counter attacking team then he's doing his old gaffer a disservice. We controlled many games from start to finish boxing teams in their own 18 yard box.
We have never come close to controlling games yet even when we've won.
We have controlled plenty of games under Ole, though mainly at the start before everyone got injured and realized they aren't fit enough to play how he wanted on a regular basis. Against City, Barcelona, obviously not. Since then we've lost a lot of form and the other performances havent been great, but he needs time to turn the squad around.
And so fecking what if you dont agree with all his starting 11s or tactics. The home game against Barca wasnt even that bad, we conceded basically no chances but also created very little against a vastly superior side. Who did we have in alternative? Would you prefer starting Smalling and Jones in CB against Messi if we put Shaw at left back? For what it's worth, the tactic largely did work anyway, so feck knows why you're complaining so much for that. Would you prefer a standard 433 where we try to dominate Barca but get thumped at Old Trafford because they have vastly superior players in every single position on the pitch? You adapt when you are the lesser team.
Hes chopped and changed formations just like every manager ever has done when results havent gone their way.
It basically sounds like you expected or wanted miracles out of him and will complain for everything else. Overall since his appointment (you cant ignore the shit form but you also can't ignore the good form), we're still "the 3rd best side" which is the absolute peak of what these current players can give. Not to mention that it was a different situation 3 months ago compared to now, where its obvious Herrera is gone, when De Gea has probably decided he wants out, and when Pogba has probably decided he wants out. We have to change our lineup, players aren't as motivated or injuries caught up with them, and at the end of the day, Ole is using a horribly balanced squad that needs complete replacing anyway.
If you think the following squad is better then simply fighting for 4th with Arsenal and Chelsea, then by all means, keep whinging. You're deluded if you think that though, and before Ole came in, we picked up 27 points in 16 games under Mourinho after he was here for a full 2 seasons prior. Give Ole at least a summer window to buy and sell some players.
De Gea, Romero
Young, Shaw, Dalot, darmian
Smalling, lindelof, Jones, rojo, bailly
Pogba, fred, mctominay, matic, Herrera, Pereira
Mata, lingard, martial, rashford, Sanchez, Lukaku
You can probably take half of them at most as players who will be here in a year or 2 regardless of manager in charge. So yeah, this summer is important. People have differing opinions on if Ole is the right person to oversee the transition, that is fair. Whatever the case, I don't think Pochettino was going to come to United anyway, so it was going to be a punt whoever we went after. We'll see how it goes, and next season will be fair to criticize if we dont improve. But right now? Not having that.