He shouldn't be going out on loan in my opinion
16
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 1
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 0
- Status
He shouldn't be going out on loan in my opinion
Dan James was starting up til the day he was sold
I thought signing them two was signalling our intent that we're moving on from Sancho, only for us to go and sign him the next window for £73m anyway
I mentioned this at the time of the Sancho signing. Nothing against Sancho as a player but 2 young wingers bought the previous year, plus a young Mason already in the team…yeah let’s add another young winger into the squad for 75 million…everyone will be happy!
Needs to be somewhere where he can play on a regular basis, I'd be happy to see him in the championship or the Scottish Premier league. He should shine at these kind of levels. If he doesn't then at least we'll know.
Still hope he goes to Feyenoord. Arno Slot is one of the best young coaches in Holland.
We have mengi and Chong already on loan at Birmingham.
Can we loan them one more? Waht are the rules these days?
Can we loan them one more? Waht are the rules these days?
He is with United because he is injured. Bowyer has said that he hopes that Chong will play for them again this season, which means he is eligible and formally a Birmingham player until June.
Probably bulshit as its coming from the mail , but him going to derby might not be too bad as he'll get regular game time.
Weird that no top teams want him. I mean, Barnsley and Derby are pretty much already going down and Birmingham is pretty bad right now too.
Derby will probably end up being safe, especially with a decent transfer window now that they can bring players in.
The top teams all have settled first XI's/core 14-15 players that they use so won't want to rock the boat.
Without their points deduction, Derby would be comfortably midtable so they're not a bad side.
I know all this but the odds are still not in their favor.
He doesn’t need to hope. He already got Mengi I’m sure we will sort him out without thinking if it’s best for Amad.
Do we even have a scout liaison person at United.
Amad had some of the highest presser p90 minutes when he was given minutes under Ole, over the likes of Rashford, Sancho have now.
Most teams don’t want to take an 18 year old winger/no.10 and do the key bits of developing him only for the parent club to take him back and loan him to a better side/keep/sell themselves for profit. Especially in January. It makes sense why it’s only the desperate sort of clubs interested.
Supposedly we want to keep him in England to preserve homegrown status too, (however true that is I don’t know). I feel like someone said that on here or quoted a Romano or something. If so, that excludes the likes of Feyenoord and any other mid level leagues interested.
Championship is a tough, physical league. There's no doubt Amad's main issue right now is his physicality, so I understand why many clubs may feel he's a risk, for all his classy technique.
Someone like Elanga would be less of a risk, although he may be more raw technically.
We need more central depth rather than wing depth. I would love him but we got Reiss Nelson from Arsenal on loan already, unless we cancel that I dont see this happening. I would love Garner or Galbraith on loan though.
Must be doing something right
Also looks like it won't be Derby anyway
Last edited:
His technique and imagination has to pay off even better in smaller spaces while his athleticism doesn’t matter as much, I’d imagine.
Hopefully we’ll find a good side to loan him to.
His technique and imagination has to pay off even better in smaller spaces while his athleticism doesn’t matter as much, I’d imagine.
Hopefully we’ll find a good side to loan him to.
He'll need a good fecking imagination with the amount of minutes he's getting for us right now.
Would love him to move on loan to a mid table or bott table PL team who have a decent style of play.
Really think we have a player with huge potential but he is probably needs to prove he can handle the physical aspect of the PL.
I think if he can join a team where he can play 15+ first team games before the end of the season will do wonders for his development.
Really think we have a player with huge potential but he is probably needs to prove he can handle the physical aspect of the PL.
I think if he can join a team where he can play 15+ first team games before the end of the season will do wonders for his development.
Man has been given 2 and half games total this season between the under 23s and first team.
That's some criminal attempt at development.
The fact he wasn't loaned due to injury and never plays for the first team means we should have been playing him atleast every third or so under 23 games
Terrible development by the club. Watch that performance versus wolves.
U23s have played 6 matches since he returned, he’s played 2. Thats 1/3 just like you asked for.
He played the first ones just as he got back from injury.
First one he wasn't at all fit.
Second one he tore it up and got two goals and an assist.
No matter what way we slice it it's been poor development of him by the club.
Literally the best player in the 23s every time he has played bar his first game back from injury.
The weight of that pass for the James chance is delicious
He was about to go on loan where he would probably have started regularly before we bought him. Seems like we might be trying to ruin another young player
Dan James would be starting now if we had not sold him. Ralf loves an energizer bunny.
I don't watch the Champo apart from the playoffs but Whoscored suggest Diangana has been horrible for West Brom and Nottingham Forest don't have a RW of even average quality.
The Prem has gotten so deep it's tough to find a loan team that makes sense and immediately sticks Amad on the right.
Surprised Southampton aren't in for him actually. Could make the case they're playing most like Rangnick and their wingers are the weak spot on the team. Broja looks good and the other spots are a mess.
We already have the perfect team to loan him to. The $#%@ing first team.
Its amazing what a little data or research can do. So many posters here just like to slag off the club without getting their facts first.Just as well he was shipped then
I don't know about that, it all went wrong right after we sold Dan, remember how optimistic we were after those first three games. Who could have forseen that Dan was the key to making Oleball work
When we sold James or signed Ronaldo?I don't know about that, it all went wrong right after we sold Dan, remember how optimistic we were after those first three games. Who could have forseen that Dan was the key to making Oleball work
Has to be a loan to Derby. Championship is a strong, physical league with good quality teams. Probably on par with the Dutch league. He'd have a manager who most likely would play him which is the key thing here. Would be perfect to develop him.
Outside of that our handling of him is another in a long line of bad youth player handling. This kid has played a handful of reserve games and a few random minutes here and there. Hes talked as one of the most exciting talents and is roughly playing 1 full game a month...how that can be good for his development is beyond me. We seem to get stuck in Limbo with some players where they don't really play in reserve games in favour of training with the first team, but then get (if they are lucky) half an hour of first team football in a month, recent example being angel gomes, tuanzebe etc.
Outside of that our handling of him is another in a long line of bad youth player handling. This kid has played a handful of reserve games and a few random minutes here and there. Hes talked as one of the most exciting talents and is roughly playing 1 full game a month...how that can be good for his development is beyond me. We seem to get stuck in Limbo with some players where they don't really play in reserve games in favour of training with the first team, but then get (if they are lucky) half an hour of first team football in a month, recent example being angel gomes, tuanzebe etc.
If you're a young, talented player, why would you go to Manchester United to develop?
That James miss
He looked good in that. Especially the ball through to James.
I hope we can get him a loan to the Championship. If we can't do that, anywhere is better than him staying here and wasting another 5 months of the season. He's already wasted a decent amount of development time by staying here.
You don't. You go for the money.
Based on what exactly? He’s barely had minutes.
I agree.
WTF was the sense in buying Sancho when we had this young talent on the books and Mason on the RW because all we are seeing is Sancho struggling and Amad getting no game time!
The big money signings we have recently made have been nothing short of disastrous!
- Status