No-one's happy with how Valencia has played this year. That shouldn't have to be mentioned every time you post in this thread...but then that's pretty much all everyone does say. Again and again. It's weird. Valencia isn't playing well and Sir Alex is trying to play him through his slump because the other wingers aren't playing well and Valencia still does the basics better than Nani or Young. Nothing's changed with that all year so why does the exact same discussion take place over and over again? Is Valencia the reason we lost today? Or is he just an easy target to vent your frustrations? It's pretty much always the latter, IMO, and I personally feel obliged to defend United players from undeserved abuse. Criticism's unavoidable but is it so hard to criticise aspects of a player's game while still being supportive of them?
Probably is really. If he was anywhere near as good as what he used to be, we would have scored a goal or two for sure.
I wouldn't be so critical of him if he was on the bench mainly, but how on earth does he keep starting game after game, when there are people like Nani, Kagawa, Welbeck or Rooney all getting dropped or on the bench. Yet Valencia, who has had one of the worst seasons I've ever seen from a player (Torres-esque), keeps getting starts. you say he does the basics right but shouldn't the basics for a winger be to be creative and make chances for your strikers? He's a number 7 for Manchester United, not some shite team in the second division, he should be doing much more then offering protection to the defence better then the other wingers to get starts. Every time Nani plays, he works hard and looks pretty threatening, and makes chances at least. Valencia doesn't even offer much defensively anymore, certainly not enough to justify him starting.
It just makes no sense why Sir Alex is trying to play him out of his slump that has gone on all season, yet he isn't trying that with Nani, even though Nani has shown that he can be a world class winger when he feels his spot in the first team is safe.