Auction Draft Chaos - Complete

Enigma_87 said:
I agree on the selling deduction that is changing the rules, but not for the 12 as a compromise. If it was 12 should be stated from the off. Makes no sense to keep compiling players you won't use anyway going forward. Especially with no subs allowed.
Click to expand...
I see your point re keeping the subs for no reason. What I meant as a compromise is I and I’m sure others assumed it had to stay at 13, you assumed it could be 11. It was a compromise of people’s assumptions due to not 100% accurately worded rules. That’s fair enough.

@Indnyc I’m not having a go at all mate. Appreciate you running this.
 
Enigma_87 said:
To be fair the rules are like this:

R.3) Initial funds of 700m for a 13 player squad. No substitutions allowed in the match but if you progress to next round, you must play your 12th and 13th player. By Q/F round, your entire squad must be utilized.

^^^ I bet it's not only us that based our RR plan on selling all subs for the QF's and there's no indication you need to keep 13 player squad all the time.

Our plan was keeping it to 11 players with playing the 2 subs from the initial drafting which was well within the rules. Keeping it to 12 or 13 always is what IMO changes the rule here, not the other way around..
Click to expand...

This.
 
Zlatan 7 said:
I see your point re keeping the subs for no reason. What I meant as a compromise is I and I’m sure others assumed it had to stay at 13, you assumed it could be 11. It was a compromise of people’s assumptions due to not 100% accurately worded rules. That’s fair enough.

@Indnyc I’m not having a go at all mate. Appreciate you running this.
Click to expand...
Aye, not having a go at @Indnyc either, done a grand job here, just trying to get round of what direction we should go :)
 
2mufc0 said:
You don't get face value back if you sell to the bank mate.
Click to expand...
I know mate, put the value there of what I paid.
willhse456 said:
@Zlatan 7 doesn't have enough money to make both of those bids.
Click to expand...

Reinforcement 50m pays for tostao.

Selling Socrates and Costacurta for 120m minus the 10m for each player deduction = 100m for the Nesta bid.

Unless I’ve fecked up somewhere?
 
Zlatan 7 said:
I know mate, put the value there of what I paid.


Reinforcement 50m pays for tostao.

Selling Socrates and Costacurta for 120m minus the 10m for each player deduction = 100m for the Nesta bid.

Unless I’ve fecked up somewhere?
Click to expand...

Oops, my apologies :wenger:
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50- Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 09:42 - Nesta - willHimannv - 110m @Zlatan 7
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50- Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 09:45 A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m

@willhse456
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50- Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 09:45 A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m
18/02 - 09:51 - B. Moore - willHimannv - 100m
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50- Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 09:45 A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m
18/02 - 09:51 - B. Moore - willHimannv - 100m
18/02 - 12:07 - Dani Alves - Don Enigma - 50m
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50- Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 8 52 - P McGrath- MJJ- 70m
18/02 - 09:45 A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m
18/02 - 09:51 - B. Moore - willHimannv - 100m
18/02 - 12:07 - Dani Alves - Don Enigma - 50m[/QUOTE]
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50- Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 09:45 A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m
18/02 - 09:51 - B. Moore - willHimannv - 100m
18/02 - 12:07 - Dani Alves - Don Enigma - 50m
18/02 - 14:50 - Van Basten - Ecstatic - 130m
 
1) Willhse/Himannv - 1) Garrincha (100m) 2) B. Robson (90m) 3) R. Giggs (70m) 4) O. Varela (60m) 5) Romario (120m) 6) R. Pavoni (30m) 7) HG Schwarzenbeck (40m) 8) M. Laudrup (70m) 9) D. McGrain (30m) 10) J. van Beveren (20m) 11) D. Alaba (20m) 12. Lucio (30m) 13. E. Hazard (20m)

3) MJJ - 1) L. Matthaus (120m) 2) Pele (150m) 3) M. Sammer (80m) 4) H. Stoichkov (70m) 5) A. Demyanenko (30m) 6) K-H Rummenigge (80m) 7) M. Preud’homme (20m) 8) C. Panucci (30m) 9) S. Lerby (20m) 10) B. Wright (20m) 11) A. Kopke (20m) 12) B. Hulshoff (20m) 13. Netto (30m)

8) Don/Enigma: 1) J. Cruyff (130m) 2) Xavi (90m) 3) E. Figueroa (120m) 4) H. Chumpitaz (70m) 5) N. Gonclaves (30m) 6) D. Bertoni (20m) 7) Rivaldo (70m) 8) R. Clemence (20m) 9) Leandro (20m) 10) A. Iniesta (70m) 11) E. Abidal (20m) 12) C.Taffarel (20m) 13. M. Silva (20m)

10) 2mufc/Gio: 1) F. Beckenbauer (130m) 2) Maradona (150m) 3) HP Briegel (30m) 4) G. Muller (100m) 5) G. Lato (30m) 6) J. Heynckes (20m) 7. Zito (40m) 8. Santamaria (50m) 9. Toldo (20m) 10. A. Vidal (20m) 11. D. Santos (70m) 12. J. Croy (20m) 13. F. Bene (20m)

11) Zlatan7: 1) Rivelino (90m) 2) F. Rijkaard (170m) 3) R. Baggio (70m) 4) A. Robben (50m) 5) S. Busquets (30m) 6) Socrates (70m) 7) G Zambrotta (30m) 8) C. Azpiliceuta (20m) + 90m cash 9) W. Suurbier (30m) 10) G. Chiellini (20m) 11) C. Puyol (30m) 12) G. Pagliuca (30m) 13) A. Costacurta (50m)

12) Ecstatic/Andeva: 1) C. Ronaldo (130m) 2) Kaka (70m) 3) Uwe Seeler (80m) 4) P. Vieira (70m) 5) Junior (30m) 6) JP Sorin (20m) 7) A. Hansen (40m) 8) L. Fernandez (20m) 9) E. Leao (20m) 10. Cafu (70m) 11. R. Carlos (70m) 12. T. Silva (20m) 13. E. Albertosi (20m)

13) EAP : 1) D. Law (90m) 2) P. Gento (90m) 3) J. Kohler (80m) 4) A. Benarrivo (30m) 5) A. Picchi (50m) 6) W. Sagnol (30m) 7) D. Blanchflower (30m) 8) D. Mackay (20m) 9) A. Carrizo (30m) 10) N. Stiles (30m) 11. S. Matthews (70m) 12. B. Charlton (100m) 13. X. Alonso (40m)

16) GSTQ 1) M. Kaltz (40m) 2) I. Viktor (20m) 3) R. Bonhof (30m) 4) L. Ronaldo (150m) 5) J. Tigana (60m) 6) Branco - 30m 7) Zico (100m) 8) F Baresi (120m) 9) T. Ravelli (20m) 10) R. Ferri (30m) 11) C. Ferrara (50m) 12) K. Mbappe (20m) 13) Clodoaldo (20m)
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50 - Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 08:52 - P McGrath- MJJ- 70m
18/02 - 09:45 - A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m
18/02 - 09:51 - B. Moore - willHimannv - 100m
18/02 - 12:07 - Dani Alves - Don Enigma - 50m
 
@Ecstatic your Van Basten bid is not valid until you sell someone.. The Platini bid already takes you over budget
 
18/02 - 08:00 - PR Falcao - 2muGio - 70m
18/02 - 08:01 - Tostao - Zlatan7 - 50m
18/02 - 08:50 - Platini - Ecstatic - 120m
18/02 - 08:52 - P McGrath- MJJ- 70m
18/02 - 09:45 - A.Nesta - Zlatan7 - 120m
18/02 - 09:51 - B. Moore - willHimannv - 100m
18/02 - 12:07 - Dani Alves - Don Enigma - 50m
18/02 - 15:47 - M. Bossis - EAP - 50m
 
MJJ said:
Sell lerby for 10m, get 50m =60m?
Click to expand...

Yes and you bid for a 70m player.. So you can’t bid anymore unless you sell someone

For ecstatic the Platini bid takes him over his budget.. So Van Basten is invalid
 
Indnyc said:
Yes and you bid for a 70m player.. So you can’t bid anymore unless you sell someone

For ecstatic the Platini bid takes him over his budget.. So Van Basten is invalid
Click to expand...

I think what he means is once that bid is won he will have a squad ten mil over budget. Even if he does have the option of selling someone to get back within budget. He should make that sale before the bid.

I may be totally wrong, this draft stuff is confusing as hell haha
 
It's quite simple, sell your players and make sure you have the funds before bidding.
 
Zlatan 7 said:
I think what he means is once that bid is won he will have a squad ten mil over budget. Even if he does have the option of selling someone to get back within budget. He should make that sale before the bid.

I may be totally wrong, this draft stuff is confusing as hell haha
Click to expand...

Correct.. At that point in time he needs to sell someone from his team.. The team is only complete when you have met the budget criteria
 
You must log in or register to reply here.