There's no reason why they can't play in the same team if both are fit, with Amad at RWB.He’s a brilliant player and this could be similar to when Liverpool signed Mane imo.
My only concern would be how we fit Amad in. I don’t see him as a RWB and he’s too good not to play.
There's no reason why they can't play in the same team if both are fit, with Amad at RWB.
That's his best position anyway. He's going to get into better 1 vs 1 situations and overlap.
Mbeumo has to be at number 10 if he signs because he's ridiculously quick and also strong carrying the ball.
What about Walker-Peters on a free?Mbeumo and Amad are a bad combo.
Both left footed, both will want to cut inside. So where it your width and overlap coming from?
We need a right footed right wing back. Amad is not a long term fit there.
It's like saying we already have five central midfielders so why buy another. Casemiro, Bruno, Ugarte, Mainoo, Collyer. Or that we have four RWB already in Amad, Dalot, Mazraoui and Dorgu.We've surely got enough 10's with Cunha arriving.
A right wingback(it won't be Amad), striker, CM, goalkeeper must be a bigger priority.
Or it may have been due to Amad being the only remotely decent attacker we had so Amorim felt we needed him closer to goal. That may change once we get other players who can contribute to the attack, which seems to likely be the plan if the links to Mbeumo are real.Amorim hasn't played him there much has he? He did at first and that was pretty much the end of it. If he saw Adam as his RWB back going forwards you'd think he'd have played there all those season.
Amad at R10 and Antony at RWB worked well the few brief times we saw it. They interchanged quite a lot as they attacked and pulled the defenders around. I do think it's important that both players can go either way and cut inside or go wide, and that should be the case with Amad and Mbeumo.Mbeumo and Amad are a bad combo.
Both left footed, both will want to cut inside. So where it your width and overlap coming from?
We need a right footed right wing back. Amad is not a long term fit there.
I thought about this same point, but then remembered that at Sporting, Amorim had Quenda as RWB and Trincao as the right 10 (both left footed), and it worked well for them.Mbeumo and Amad are a bad combo.
Both left footed, both will want to cut inside. So where it your width and overlap coming from?
We need a right footed right wing back. Amad is not a long term fit there.
We play other players for the 1-4 games they're off, same as we would do with anyone who was unavailable for any other reason. If we're being honest, it isn't guaranteed that Amad is picked; Ivory Coast are pretty stacked.What happend when both him and Amad head off to AFCON?
We literally have only ONE left footed winger in the squad, Mbeumo would be a no brainer if attainable. They both can absolutely play in the same line-up, you clearly have no idea how Sporting played, almost always with lefties at RAM and RWB.Mbeumo and Amad are a bad combo.
Both left footed, both will want to cut inside. So where it your width and overlap coming from?
We need a right footed right wing back. Amad is not a long term fit there.
He wasn't cooling it down. He was confirming our interest. Of course other clubs are interested. Why wouldn't they be? Yes, we do need sales because we are also signing Cunha and a striker.So Romano cooled it down really, saying we do have interest, but not only us, and we're dependant on sales.
Nope. We absolutely are interested. However, we need sales and we need him to choose us. He's leaning towards Newcastle.I am calling it - this is bullshit story and never happening, for the simple reason that we clearly dont have money to fund this.
We obviously need to sign a striker and a goalkeeper before we would even entertain somebody in his position. And even for these higher priority positions we dont have money to sign somebody as expensive as him
Do the math. Fans are being played here with a non-story news
This is happening if Rashford, Antony, sancho and maybe Garnacho are leaving. We ain’t selling 4 attackers and only bringing in 1.I am calling it - this is bullshit story and never happening, for the simple reason that we clearly dont have money to fund this.
We obviously need to sign a striker and a goalkeeper before we would even entertain somebody in his position. And even for these higher priority positions we dont have money to sign somebody as expensive as him
Do the math. Fans are being played here with a non-story news
If the timing aligns. If we end up selling all of those, it'll likely take a while. There's every chance someone picked up Mbeumo before we manage to generate the fundsThis is happening if Rashford, Antony, sancho and maybe Garnacho are leaving. We ain’t selling 4 attackers and only bringing in 1.
Fair point. But we’ll still sign someone els then. Possibly 2 10a and a ST. We’re after a new front line.If the timing aligns. If we end up selling all of those, it'll likely take a while. There's every chance someone picked up Mbeumo before we manage to generate the funds
Were getting a striker. And we are selling Garnacho.I am calling it - this is bullshit story and never happening, for the simple reason that we clearly dont have money to fund this.
We obviously need to sign a striker and a goalkeeper before we would even entertain somebody in his position. And even for these higher priority positions we dont have money to sign somebody as expensive as him
Do the math. Fans are being played here with a non-story news
I can easily see this happenI think Garnacho will be a better but similar style player in 2 years so I'd be unexcited if this was his replacement
I think Garnacho will be a better but similar style player in 2 years so I'd be unexcited if this was his replacement
Maybe, maybe not. But I don't think we can afford to carry a young player as one of our main forwards who is so poor/inconsistent with his output for another 2 seasons on the chance he does make that level up. We're in dire straits, immediate change is needed.I think Garnacho will be a better but similar style player in 2 years so I'd be unexcited if this was his replacement
Maybe, maybe not. But I don't think we can afford to carry a young player as one of our main forwards who is so poor/inconsistent with his output for another 2 seasons on the chance he does make that level up. We're in dire straits, immediate change is needed.
Mbeumo right now is just a better player - stronger, better footwork, more efficient in front of goal. Makes sense to sell potential to get a reliable player at a good age like Mbeumo.
Garnacho should never be the main forward for a top club at this age. That is our mistake and since we have fecked up our finances so badly now, we need to sell a young winger with excellent potential for new signings.Maybe, maybe not. But I don't think we can afford to carry a young player as one of our main forwards who is so poor/inconsistent with his output for another 2 seasons on the chance he does make that level up. We're in dire straits, immediate change is needed.
Mbeumo right now is just a better player - stronger, better footwork, more efficient in front of goal. Makes sense to sell potential to get a reliable player at a good age like Mbeumo.
Agreed, and not only that but hyped as our starboy. It's not fair and he just isn't good enough yet. It also contributes to the brattish entitlement he's showing. Yet another example of our terrible squad management.Garnacho should never be the main forward for a top club at this age.
The issue is so many are fine with a young potential being sold because there is no other way to get our squad fixed. The current coach has fecked up our season so badly, that we have now had our hands tied behind our back.Agreed, and not only that but hyped as our starboy. It's not fair and he just isn't good enough yet. It also contributes to the brattish entitlement he's showing. Yet another example of our terrible squad management.
it is not a bad idea to have someone be more direct (Mbeumo) and someone be more creative (Cunha), we will still need directness and shots to be taken.Watch Cunha his passing and vision is better than Mbuemo, he looks like he can be more creative but he needs to work on his final ball. He overhits the through ball but hes actually created a lot of chances at Wolves this season. Mbuemo creates usually from his crosses.
Also I did say we keep Bruno
The issue is that we can't use Garnacho as anything other than a starter because him and 'his team' whinge when he doesn't play.The issue is so many are fine with a young potential being sold because there is no other way to get our squad fixed. The current coach has fecked up our season so badly, that we have now had our hands tied behind our back.
Not a long term fit there even though his best games have been there. Quenda at sporting was a left footed rwb who played very similar to Amad, people need to grasp how Amorim plays rather than what they want to happenMbeumo and Amad are a bad combo.
Both left footed, both will want to cut inside. So where it your width and overlap coming from?
We need a right footed right wing back. Amad is not a long term fit there.
Ye but one of thems willing to give us goals and assist right now. We can’t afford to wait 2 years to have a decent player who puts up the numbersI think Garnacho will be a better but similar style player in 2 years so I'd be unexcited if this was his replacement
Is Mbuemo also a terrible passer? Because Garnacho is only decent as an impact player and will be until he can develop his football brain, learn to play with others and pass the ball. Given he’s not suited to the formation either, I’m not sure it makes sense to wait.I think Garnacho will be a better but similar style player in 2 years so I'd be unexcited if this was his replacement
We have a lot of players leaving, set to leave and not in future plans. I'm guessing INEOS is trying to get players in early instead of waiting to complete sales first. The latter has always burnt us before. All the best teams finish their business early on, Liverpool being a prime example.I am calling it - this is bullshit story and never happening, for the simple reason that we clearly dont have money to fund this.
We obviously need to sign a striker and a goalkeeper before we would even entertain somebody in his position. And even for these higher priority positions we dont have money to sign somebody as expensive as him
Do the math. Fans are being played here with a non-story news
I think Cherki has a much higher ceiling, and is more talented among the two. But Mbuemo has proven to be so consistent over multiple seasons and is a hard worker off the ball too. Would be the "safer" signing.Is Mbuemo also a terrible passer? Because Garnacho is only decent as an impact player and will be until he can develop his football brain, learn to play with others and pass the ball. Given he’s not suited to the formation either, I’m not sure it makes sense to wait.
Ideally we’d get someone much better than this chap, I agree. At least someone with a higher ceiling but I also understand if Amorim thinks he’s tactically a good fit and ready to perform.
I bet a better man-manager could handle that much better. You would think Garnacho is the first young footballer who wants to start every game. If his tweets are the only reason, we are looking to sell then it’s worse than the financial aspect of it.The issue is that we can't use Garnacho as anything other than a starter because him and 'his team' whinge when he doesn't play.
Either you choose to hurt your side by consistently starting a sub-standard player or you sell him. There is no other way.
He's been given ample opportunity to play and has consistently underwhelmed. He really should have been humble, knuckled down and improved his game. Instead, we are subjected to an ego and entitlement without anything to back it up.I bet a better man-manager could handle that much better. You would think Garnacho is the first young footballer who wants to start every game. If his tweets are the only reason, we are looking to sell then it’s worse than the financial aspect of it.
Yeah that's nonsense. Also again the lazy trope, he's one of the hardest working players we have.He's been given ample opportunity to play and has consistently underwhelmed. He really should have been humble, knuckled down and improved his game. Instead, we are subjected to an ego and entitlement without anything to back it up.
You can blame the club for indulging these young players and giving them too much too soon. At United there is a culture that young players who fly from the academy to the first team are superstars. Luckily, Mainoo appears more grounded.
