Signing Di Maria last season was a HUGE success in terms of signing IMO. It didn't work out if he is going (if he would stay it still can) but at the time it happened it was one of our biggest signings. Woodward cannot be blamed for the success of the players. The coach, the other players and the english climate can.
Di Maria replacement if he decides to leave
- Thread starter Someone
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
To be fair I can't see how we can use Fellaini at the moment and what advantage he would give us at the moment. He has a lot of players in front of him in the pecking order and given that he had a good season last year it would make sense to sell him now.
Young I see there is no contract offered yet and his current one expires next summer I can see him being offloaded until the end of the window to a prem side.
Wilson IMO should be loaned out to a side that will play him regularly (I know that loan deals never work out for us but at the moment he's not ready for the first team).
Januzaj we should keep but be a squad player in light of current form.
Pereira is not ready yet, but can feature in CC and FA cups.
Mata should play centrally most of the time. Schneiderlin, Schweinsteiger,Mata, Herrera, Carrick, Blind - again 6 players that can rotate for 3 positions. In addition to that Blind can fill in the defence and Mata can fill on the wing given all 6 of them are fit to play.
Add to that the 9 defenders we currently have + additional one and 2-3 goalkeepers we will have a 25 man squad which is about what we need for all fronts this year.
I believe next month we will see some players leave.
At the moment we have Nani, RvP, Falcao out
Bastian,Morgan,Darmian, Depay in.
Rafael will most likely leave, so will Evans if we buy another CB. With AdM leaving and for sake of camparison us buying 2 forwards + 1 CB, and one of Young/Fellaini leaving we will have the same number of senior players like the last year without CL.
I said in hindsight. I'm not blaming anybody. He was, however, signed because he was a world class player and on the market, not because he'd fit into our style of play or because we needed that particular type of player. Same with Falcao. It was a risk - it could've worked if they had adapted to the conditions in the club and league. It didn't work, which is why now we're following a more practical approach. I don't think we'll sign a player just because he's very good and is available but rather go for someone whose qualities are best suited to our needs.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/33666730
If the BBC are talking about it in such a matter of fact way, it looks pretty likely he's off.
Massive waste. I mean, how often does a player break a national transfer record then only stay one season?
If the BBC are talking about it in such a matter of fact way, it looks pretty likely he's off.
Massive waste. I mean, how often does a player break a national transfer record then only stay one season?
Also, I wonder if he'll finally get on the plane and join the tour now.
...for PSG.
...for PSG.
Rumours were he got on a plane to where PSG are
Imagine he lined up against us on Wednesday, now that would be something. Then Jones tackles him and puts him out for the season.
No chance he'd get played against us in this friendly.
Good riddance.
It's got to be Reus to replace him.
Depay and Reus flanking a striker with Herrera in behind
It's got to be Reus to replace him.
Depay and Reus flanking a striker with Herrera in behind
Poor attitude from him. It's now obvious that his problem was getting out of Real - he never really wanted us in the first place. I hate these Argie players - they are all the same. I hope he fails like all of his mates and fecks off to his homeland.
Its going to be PedroGood riddance.
It's got to be Reus to replace him.
Depay and Reus flanking a striker with Herrera in behind
I cant see us not bringing a Striker in - regardless of Pedro possibly coming.
But in saying that, i dont want us bringing any run-of-the-mill Striker in just for the sake of it either, so i'd settle with just having Pedro as the last forward addition.
The center-back situation is becoming somewhat frustrating & confusing also. Are we really after Otamendi, or is he just plan B if we cant get Ramos?!
The links seem to be strong with both players - so much so, that it's like we're looking to obtain both of them, which would be an amazing window for us & we'd be so solid at the back & have so many options in the event of nailed-on injuries to our CB's.
I think the only one affected would be Lingard.
The other concern with Reus is that he seems like he doesn't really fancy the PL. Feikir on the other hand is built for the PL IMO but of course has less top level experience.
The ones who fit perfectly in our need for a player, footballing wise and stardom wise:
Bale, Hazard, Sanchez, Ronaldo, Reus, Griezmann
There is zero chance of getting any of these players
Some other attackers who are big talented stars:
Isco, Draxler, James Rodriguez, Goetze, Muller, David Silva, Coutinho
I don't think these players fit, footballing wise. They are either too central or/and not pacey enough. Plus some are just out of reach.
I believe that two are kinda gettable and will help us a little bit: Moura and Pedro.
These might not be enough, but just realistic.
Bale, Hazard, Sanchez, Ronaldo, Reus, Griezmann
There is zero chance of getting any of these players
Some other attackers who are big talented stars:
Isco, Draxler, James Rodriguez, Goetze, Muller, David Silva, Coutinho
I don't think these players fit, footballing wise. They are either too central or/and not pacey enough. Plus some are just out of reach.
I believe that two are kinda gettable and will help us a little bit: Moura and Pedro.
These might not be enough, but just realistic.
Are you angry at Tevez?
Out of those I would have Moura and Goetze. These 2 could be attainable and would add a new dimension to the team and strengthen the areas which need it most. Moura out on the wing with his pace and skill and then Goteze as a forward in place of Rooney when injured, banned or off form.
Griezemann would be possible as he has a release clause, whether or not he wants to leave is another thing.
I'd take Pedro AND Felipe Anderson
I was, but not that angry anymore tbh. What's your point, though?
Only really Robinho at City and Ibrahimovich for Barca come to mind. Although Ibra wasn't a transfer record it was still a lot, and i think Robinho stayed for 10 or so games into the next season. It's a pretty unique thing we're seeing with Di Maria.
No point. Just curious.
I think Tevez was just bitter. I think he wanted to stay with us but was not allowed to for a various of circumstances. No one who was not bitter would wear the RIP Fergie t-shirt IMO.
I'm well and truly on the Felipe Anderson boat now that he's a reported target. I love the guy and he'd be perfect. Pedro is actually pretty great too though so I'd be happy with him. Both would be better
When did this come about - today?I'm well and truly on the Felipe Anderson boat now that he's a reported target. I love the guy and he'd be perfect. Pedro is actually pretty great too though so I'd be happy with him. Both would be better
I missed this..
I can't see us getting Anderson AND Pedro. It would be great for squad depth but we may be overstocked with players up there which may lead to unhappy ones. Given that Memphis, Young, Pereira, Januzaj, Mata and maybe to a lesser extent Valencia are all fighting for those 2 wing slots of the 4-3-3, adding another two may be a little tricky to keep everyone happy. I haven't watched Anderson enough to make a judgement so I'd naturally want Pedro. Wouldn't be against Anderson though - heard good things about him. Seems to have a lot of pace about him.
We were linked with him before we signed Depay
It would have to be a top proven player or nobody, because we have young players who are waiting in the wings for the chance to prove themselves. Signing an unproven player to replace ADM would really knock the confidence of Januzaij and the like, whilst it would be easier to justify signing a world class player as replacement.
Bale is EPL and Europe proven, Reus and Gotze are proven in Europe.
Pedro is good, but i doubt he will make a big impact.
Bale is EPL and Europe proven, Reus and Gotze are proven in Europe.
Pedro is good, but i doubt he will make a big impact.
Seeing Muller, Rodriguez and Silva (especially Muller) below anyone there bar Ronaldo, makes me feel sad.
I think that there isn't a player right there who fits us more than Muller.
What is doing Draxler with those names?
Absolutely. I was gutted we didn't sign him up, but he simply came across as a bitter tw*t afterward, so it was hard to like him. But ya, his case is a bit different from that of Veron's, Heinze's and AdM's.
Very slow news day so far. Wish something would happen, maybe a couple of signings to wear the new kit.
Imagine if we'd gotten another 5 years of service from Tevez.
I agree. He acted like a baby.
Was it that bad with Veron? I don't remember but thought he was forced out as well
That's very old news - thought it was a new link. That one's been dead as a door-nail for ages..
Zabaleta seems like a pretty decent guy, as does Aguero. I'd have either on United. Messi also comes across quite well. I don't think we should let the behaviour of Di Maria and Tevez colour our perception of Argentines, any more than we should allow the likes of Robinho and Anderson to turn us off Brazilians.
Apparently he wanted to stay, but Fergie, despite having defended him throughout his spell here, was ready to let him go.
Yes but I did not remember that he acted like Tevez after his departure?
True he didn't, so, yes his case was totally different from Tevez's (or Heinze's for that matter) - it was merely a case of a potentially great signing not working out for us rather than them bitching their way out.
not really, Aguero for example keeps saying how he loves playing at City etc etc, even came out with this himself when all the Real Madrid rumours started going on. Too bad for us honestly, as Aguero is a cut above any other Argentinian that ever played in Manchester, and is playing for the wrong side.
- Status