Enigma_87
You know who
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2008
- Messages
- 27,967
Agree with Joga and Annah, have said most of what I would have. The ability on the ball of the likes of Breitner, Beckenbauer and Andrade combined with their versatility and willingness to be present in midfield will be really vital and I can't see many 'hard working' midfields coping with that, really. I agree with Enigma that he has more pure work rate and tenacity in there but that wouldn't tell the complete story on who will dominate the middle there as the quality on the ball from all areas goes in favour of downcast and in general both Hristo in 94 and Boniek in 82 would themselves be a lot happier in a ruthless counter attacking setup while not being the ideal choices in terms of getting swift combinations going in midfield. That is quite a big factor for me, the game otherwise is immensely tight as you would expect but I think I prefer Downcast tactically here and while Muller is obviously a bigger name than Fontaine for example but in terms of WC peaks there's hardly much between him and Fontaine. Similarly Kopa is right up there and there's that famous quote when Santiago Bernabeu asked his scout to bring him the best player from the 1958 World Cup and he got the reply that the player is already at the club!
In short, Makelele as I already mentioned is not someone I am fond of in that team especially given who is up against and while both of Enigma's wingers individually have great credentials, I find it tough to envisage their playing styles blending well with the 1970 Pele and the tactics he played in where wide players were expected more to contribute in attack and in terms of individual as well as team's offensive skill than being industrious, all action impact players like the two Eastern Europeans here. You normally associate Pele's playing culture with the likes of Garrincha and Jairzinho who are absolutely a different school of playing style than the likes of Zibi Boniek.
I think it's overstated a bit to be honest. Andrade and Breitner will be stretched while the in the center we will have a lot of players back saturating the space and leaving no space behind for DC forwards/midfielders. Our full backs IMO provide a better support going forward(especially Amoros who is the best on the pitch in that sense), while in the same time centrally we have Figueroa and Moore who can fend off DC attackers and are our last line of defence.
In terms of match ups I'd also give us the advantage as to me Makelele and Zito are comparable in terms of quality and whilst Kopa and Pele had great tournament peaks but simply Pele is the better player and could provide bigger impact. Same can be said about Muller and on top of that I'd say Figueroa/Schnellinger against Muller/Fontaine we have advantage there as well in terms of peak at CB.
Nitpicking a bit but Schnellinger in 1966 was a defensive left full back for both club and country. He played centrally in 1970 as a sweeper, so the combo in Figueroa/Moore in defensive sense I think is another advantage for our side.