He'sRaldo
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2019
- Messages
- 3,202
I think there's not much between the three.
In the same way you can imagine how devastating Rashford would be under Klopp, you can also imagine how Haaland's numbers would change significantly under our team, given our creativity this season. Hence, it's logical to start with the premise that comparing pure numbers is a poor style of judging who is better. After all, the main point of scouts isn't just to show numbers but to apply the right context to them in order to evaluate potential success.
With that said, based on their attributes I think Rashford would be the biggest talent in the PL, because he has a very good mix of physicality, mentality, and technique. Haaland might struggle a bit technically (outside the box of course) while Sancho's physicality isn't top tier. Not to say that there's much difference though, since they're all top level talents.
As someone else said, the only way to know for sure is for them all to play for the same team under the same manager. Wouldn't be opposed to that myself
In the same way you can imagine how devastating Rashford would be under Klopp, you can also imagine how Haaland's numbers would change significantly under our team, given our creativity this season. Hence, it's logical to start with the premise that comparing pure numbers is a poor style of judging who is better. After all, the main point of scouts isn't just to show numbers but to apply the right context to them in order to evaluate potential success.
With that said, based on their attributes I think Rashford would be the biggest talent in the PL, because he has a very good mix of physicality, mentality, and technique. Haaland might struggle a bit technically (outside the box of course) while Sancho's physicality isn't top tier. Not to say that there's much difference though, since they're all top level talents.
As someone else said, the only way to know for sure is for them all to play for the same team under the same manager. Wouldn't be opposed to that myself