You and I are simply jokers on the internet. The only man that had to be right was the linesman. No one can prove beyond doubt he was wrong. Not even VAR.
FA Cup Third Round
- Thread starter PoTMS
- Start date
Didn't watch the game. Who scored the 2 offside goals?
Salah scored a goal where he benefitted from being in an offside position, but it was given anyway.
Wolves had a goal ruled out for an offside that didn't exist because VAR didn't have the right camera angle to see that it didn't exist.
its irrevelant surely whether or not the wolves defender plays the ball? Salah is offside on the cross, so offside and free kick no matter what happens after.
There is enough information to show the Nunes was onside as the top of his head is in view a milli second after last wolves player heads it so unless he moves faster than superman he couldn't be called offside , watch the match day footage. Anyhow, out of 1000's of decisions made by var the one time it doesn't work the linesman gets it wrong and says more about who we have to referee the match. Also the cameraman was right there covering the corner kick and even match of the day didn't revert to that .
Salah playing in anything but a liverpool shirt at anfield is offside ,period.
There is enough information to show the Nunes was onside as the top of his head is in view a milli second after last wolves player heads it so unless he moves faster than superman he couldn't be called offside , watch the match day footage. Anyhow, out of 1000's of decisions made by var the one time it doesn't work the linesman gets it wrong and says more about who we have to referee the match. Also the cameraman was right there covering the corner kick and even match of the day didn't revert to that .
@Dumbstar
You are really at first laughing that there are still "people that don't get who was actually offside" just to then say that the "fan footage can't prove 100% if he was offside or not".
Yep, true. And of course VAR can't use fan footage. But the fan footage looks quite clear, and although nobody can prove it 100%, it really looks like Liverpool got lucky there as in this footage it looks quite clear.
2nd picture - quality is bad and angle not perfect, but for me it looks like 99% chance that VAR got it wrong as Nunes looks quite clearly onside. No conspiracy for Liverpool, just lucky.
You are really at first laughing that there are still "people that don't get who was actually offside" just to then say that the "fan footage can't prove 100% if he was offside or not".
Yep, true. And of course VAR can't use fan footage. But the fan footage looks quite clear, and although nobody can prove it 100%, it really looks like Liverpool got lucky there as in this footage it looks quite clear.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
2nd picture - quality is bad and angle not perfect, but for me it looks like 99% chance that VAR got it wrong as Nunes looks quite clearly onside. No conspiracy for Liverpool, just lucky.
We don't even know which header the lino was making his decision on.
If it was the first, then it wasn't a Wolves header.
His great view doesn't come with x-ray vision, does it?
If the linesman was so sure Nunes was offside why didn't he flag when the ball went out to him? He obviously wasn't sure thats why he waited till the goal went in. Yes the linesman had the best view but he still got it wrong. You say there's no angle to prove he was wrong but there's also no VAR angle to prove anyone was offside.
Would you be talking about Benzema disallowed goal in the CL final when the ball deflected off Fabinho
Of course it would be given, its Liverpool.
Dean Windass's son looks to have a good eye for a goal...
Na it was the group stages. All I kind find is the Spurs disallowed goal v Sporting which has polluted the search engine.
Edit I was wrong, it was Griezmann in the World Cup
https://youtube.com/shorts/pCLF6C8qq2Y?feature=share
I thought the ball had to be played forward for a player to be offside. I've not seen any footage showing that.
So it doesn't matter where the Wolves player was standing as he couldn't be offside!
Nope
@Dumbstar you can’t seriously be arguing those that offside goal was the correct decision? I mean there’s being partisan and then there is that.
I like you Dumbstar, you're a good guy, but even you can't seriously think that goal was onside?
This is also what the Norwegian studio was saying.
Cardiff take lead against Leeds against the run of play.
Cardiff looking more determined, Leeds probably want to avoid getting injured in the process.
Are Cardiff fans singing we all hate Leeds scum? 
Leeds now two down.
Wonderful Cardiff goal.
this feels like an all Championship tie
Any clue what formation Leeds are playing, they seem to have about six attackers in their team.
Yeah, it looks as though every player in front of their back 4 is a child, a striker, or both.
He was in the RAWK thread the day before acting like United being awarded some legitimate penalties was some sort of FA conspiracy that led to our poor results last season.
He appears to be somewhat disconnected from reality.
A losing one currently. But yeah, seems poor balanced with little in midfield.
That's one way of putting it. Was going to say Gnoto looks about 12 but think he's only about 18.
Could get used to weekends like this
On the contrary he’s usually a sensible poster whose opinion I generally respect while accepting that it’s going to have some bias towards the team he supports but this is a step too far imo.
Cardiff playing motorheads triple h wwf entrance
Rodrigo pulls a goal back for Leeds.
The linesman is human and can make mistakes. But there is no proof. Bringing up fan cams will just be laughed out of court.
The linesman saw something that none of us could. He could be mistaken. But none of the fan cams can be used as a basis. The evidence has to be overwhelmingly scientific and not emotional.
Where's the proof anyone was offside?
Cardiff down to ten men and Leeds have a penalty.
What a save from the Cardiff defender .
.What a save by the Cardiff kid. Perfect DDG replacement
Penalty saved.
What scientific method did the Linesman use?
Shit pen