Frenkie de Jong | The last muppeting lap

Frenkie to United?


  • Total voters
    2,033
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
I speaking in terms of how the poster worded it.

Meaning if he doesn't.

Personally I'm very much leaning towards the lad flat out doesn't want to leave Barca.

If he does leave, it'll be him leaving a club unhappy and us getting a player not focused... eg Di Maria.



Yes, two separate amounts.

They've received a fair chunk of wonga in recent weeks to assist in the short term at least.


De Jong cant publicly announce that he wants out because he wants his loyalty bonus. Why would Ten Hag chase him if he did not tell him privately that he wants to come?
 
We should be not looking at lesser alternative players such as Tielemans and Neves etc, we should be looking at players on a par or even better than Frenkie. The question is then, if available, who are these players ?
 
I speaking in terms of how the poster worded it.

Meaning if he doesn't.

Personally I'm very much leaning towards the lad flat out doesn't want to leave Barca.

If he does leave, it'll be him leaving a club unhappy and us getting a player not focused... eg Di Maria.



Yes, two separate amounts.

They've received a fair chunk of wonga in recent weeks to assist in the short term at least.

That's numberwang.
 
They haven't. They have only got 200 odd million from selling 10% of TV rights.

They have approval of selling rights etc... but they haven't agreed deals with anyone for those. The 650m is what they want to raise.

They sold more TV rights.

First lever and then Second.

Not sure of the actual amounts but I reckon ball park 450-500m possibly.

Hard to know really.
 
De Jong cant publicly announce that he wants out because he wants his loyalty bonus. Why would Ten Hag chase him if he did not tell him privately that he wants to come?
He can say publicly he wants to stay though, something he hasn't done amongst all the speculation and pressure.
 
De Jong cant publicly announce that he wants out because he wants his loyalty bonus. Why would Ten Hag chase him if he did not tell him privately that he wants to come?

Simply cause Barca *ideally* need him off the books.

I don't believe FDJ wants to leave though.

FDJ doesn't have to leave, Barca can't force him either though so we continue on arguing like muppets.
 
It seems the UK press are saying one thing and the Spanish another. Who's playing them off against each other?

I mean ita clear that Sport talks crap and shouldn't be believed at all, but still.

UK media says that Frenkie is open to join Unite, but there has been nothing to suggest this.

We have heard this for 2 months that he is "open" but is it a lie?

United have had a fee agreed which means, all Frenkie has to do is agree personal terms with United, the fact that it seems we are not even negotiating this shows he does not want to come.

its been a week since the fee is agreed, 3 weeks since a principle deal was agreed. The player clearly does not want to come.
 
That wasn't aimed at you, more people who claim definitively that he doesn't want to be here despite knowing feck all. The same people who post "walk away" etc.

I know you are pretty rational.
Oh I know don't worry, I was referring to us using guesswork and the sorts. We get our info from what's fed to the media, mostly what the club/players want you to hear.

What's actually said will always likely be secret, unless things went to crap and club/player had a war of words
 
They do not 'owe' him anything in the traditional sense, they got him to sign a new contract during covid which reduced his wages for the 1st 2 years of the contract with the following 4 years showing a higher basic wage, i am guessing his argument would be i wouldnt have signed the deal if i knew you were going to sell me before i could recoup the reduced wages in the following years of my contract where the rest of the money is 'owed'.

Ah ok so this is where the 'we need you to take a pay cut comes in then' so when do Barca need him to agree to a pay cut by? Before the transfer window closes or can they afford to pay him his 'true' wage for a couple of months while they continue to negotiate?
 
He can say publicly he wants to stay though, something he hasn't done amongst all the speculation and pressure.

Well that's not true.

He has quite a few times.

“I prefer to stay at Barcelona, I’ve said that before. Barça is the club of my dreams since I was a kid. If other clubs come calling I’ll take the call, of course; it’s something you always do.

“I don’t want to talk about rumours anymore. I feel good at Barcelona. There is no agreement [with other clubs] or anything official.”

Just one of at least 4 or 5 examples from about April onward where he stated his happiness at Barca and not wanting to leave.
 
UK media says that Frenkie is open to join Unite, but there has been nothing to suggest this.

We have heard this for 2 months that he is "open" but is it a lie?

United have had a fee agreed which means, all Frenkie has to do is agree personal terms with United, the fact that it seems we are not even negotiating this shows he does not want to come.

its been a week since the fee is agreed, 3 weeks since a principle deal was agreed. The player clearly does not want to come.
If the wage issue is that much of a problem, and if Frenkie says he wants to leave means that he's forfeiting his right to what he's owed, including any bonuses, couldn't agreeing terms with another club be construed as agreeing to leave, meaning he's all but forfeited what he's owed.

As I say there is a lot more to this than we know
 
course that would only make you more motivated to prove them wrong wouldn’t it once you got over it…I’d be worried if he was a Barca academy product but he’s not…coming to his ex manager…it might hurt ok but not as much as going anywhere else on many levels
Also coming to FA Cup and Europa League winners 2023!! :drool:
 
Well that's not true.

He has quite a few times.



Just one of at least 4 or 5 examples from about April onward where he stated his happiness at Barca and not wanting to leave.
Two months ago.

He also said this



Since then we have had a bid accepted and he has stayed silent.
 
If the wage issue is that much of a problem, and if Frenkie says he wants to leave means that he's forfeiting his right to what he's owed, including any bonuses, couldn't agreeing terms with another club be construed as agreeing to leave, meaning he's all but forfeited what he's owed.

As I say there is a lot more to this than we know

Well, its about the defered wage, he is not leaving until he is paid what he is owed, which is the correct stance. If the club wanted to leave so badly, they would try work it out right?

Instead they are saying, on current wage, we cant afford you so leave or reduce your wage and stay.

Barca have the upper hand here. He can stay and Xavi will keep him and play him or leave and it wont make a big difference because they have so much midfield talent.
 
Well, its about the defered wage, he is not leaving until he is paid what he is owed, which is the correct stance. If the club wanted to leave so badly, they would try work it out right?

Instead they are saying, on current wage, we cant afford you so leave or reduce your wage and stay.

Barca have the upper hand here. He can stay and Xavi will keep him and play him or leave and it wont make a big difference because they have so much midfield talent.
He can stay, on his current contract and completely destroy Barcas wage budget as he won't take a pay cut again, or he can work out a settlement with Barca and leave, which would be much more beneficial for the club.

The only way he's staying is on his current contract from what I can gather
 
That's just gonna reduce their future earnings. Probably worsening the problem.
They feel as if they are successful now they will get a bump in revenue which would cover the sale or at least a part of it.

They are really putting all their eggs in one basket because if their plan doesn't work in two-three seasons they could be relegation fodder.
 
Two months ago.

He also said this



Since then we have had a bid accepted and he has stayed silent.


Even in June when we were openly negotiating a transfer, still the same sentiments.

https://www.90min.com/posts/frenkie...n-utd-interest-but-insists-happy-at-barcelona

It's been the same message before and during.

If Barca manage somehow to force him out, we are investing heavily in a player who won't be focused and dedicated to the club and I'm absolutely convinced of it.
 
Look I get Barca’s financial situation and I buy that they really need him off the wage books. However if that is true then I can’t explain why Barca aren’t trying to freeze him out.

I know the optimists here keep going on about “he’s Barca’s player” and “they have every right to take him on tour” and they’re right, but it looks like the onus is on Barca to force him out of the club.

If they are serious about doing so. They have to take harsh measures like leaving him off the tour like they did Brathwaite and the likes, they have to threaten to not let him train with the first team all year.

In short - they have to act like there’s no future for FdJ at Barca. The fact that they’re not doing that makes me a bit less confident in this happening. Makes me think they might find a way to come to some sort of resolution without selling FdJ - maybe sell other players, maybe get some wage cuts across the board or do some other financial feckery to make it work.

I wish this happens, I really do, but I think people are putting too much faith in “assurances” that might just be hints and backup options rather than a proper desire to join. And I also think some people are putting ETH on a bit of a pedestal. Maybe he’s just a bit blinded by the faint possibility of FdJ joining that he doesn’t wanna give it up. Or maybe he’s being a bit pigheaded too - top level coaches are known to be that at times like Jose and Pep as well.

Also wish Barca were more forceful with forcing him out like other clubs have been towards players in the past. It’s on them to force him out, he’s clearly not gonna go willingly.
You have a point for sure, but it’s all about the optics. Laporta has left it to Xavi to deal direct with FDJ so he isn’t seen as the bad guy. In the same way they want to paint Frenkie as the bad guy for choosing wages and money over helping Barca hence all the ‘he’s not for sale‘ stuff despite clearly negotiating a fee with United. It’s all politics to keep the socios happy so Laporta can keep his job.
 
Maybe Timber really wanted to come and was very open to the idea, but after van Gaal warned him that his world Cup place was in jeopardy if he didn't play week in and week out, he would be dropped.

Maybe he looked at who we already had and didn't see much opportunity to be a regular starter so decided against the idea. I really don't know but by all accounts he was very open to coming

Either way, if Timber told 'porkies' and/or Erik hasn't sold the idea well enough, he ain't coming. Maybe we will go back again for him after the WC? At the moment if a player or a club we are trying to deal with tells us to stick our fingers up our a**e and whistle 'dixe'... we'd probably have to think about it!!!
 
Even in June when we were openly negotiating a transfer, still the same sentiments.

https://www.90min.com/posts/frenkie...n-utd-interest-but-insists-happy-at-barcelona

It's been the same message before and during.

If Barca manage somehow to force him out, we are investing heavily in a player who won't be focused and dedicated to the club and I'm absolutely convinced of it.
Point still stands.

We agreed a fee with Barcelona. Since then he hasn't said a word despite according to many he is 'desperate to stay'

If he was so desperate he can come out right now and effectively turn us down himself, ending all speculation.

His silence speaks volumes.
 
Is there any logical explanation/assumption or at least a good theory why De Jong and his agency need to say that they want to remain at Barcelona, even if he really wants to leave?

I do not get how this supposedly strong stance is going to bring benefits in the wages owed. If his camp let the journalists know that if he gets fully paid the deferred wages he is going to leave to United, otherwise he is happily sitting on the current agreed contract in Barcelona, wouldn't that be better for everyone who doesn't have a clue what is going on and try to assume things? I believe that then the media would pressure Barcelona even more about the wages thing (providing that this is the case).
Sorry newbie, it’s all been talked to death in here but if you don’t get it by now no amount of explaining will help you. :wenger:
 
Look I get Barca’s financial situation and I buy that they really need him off the wage books. However if that is true then I can’t explain why Barca aren’t trying to freeze him out.
.

Constructive dismissal if they acted like such obvious tosspots, they’d have no legal argument that they aren’t essentially dismissing him.

https://www.farrer.co.uk/news-and-i...ight-an-athlete-claim-constructive-dismissal/

If Spanish employment law is anything like UK law here, doing such a thing could utterly feck them worse than any other solution to this wage problem.
Better to take him, and give him very few minutes, make out he’s just not preferred by the manager.
 
Look I get Barca’s financial situation and I buy that they really need him off the wage books. However if that is true then I can’t explain why Barca aren’t trying to freeze him out.

I know the optimists here keep going on about “he’s Barca’s player” and “they have every right to take him on tour” and they’re right, but it looks like the onus is on Barca to force him out of the club.

If they are serious about doing so. They have to take harsh measures like leaving him off the tour like they did Brathwaite and the likes, they have to threaten to not let him train with the first team all year.

In short - they have to act like there’s no future for FdJ at Barca. The fact that they’re not doing that makes me a bit less confident in this happening. Makes me think they might find a way to come to some sort of resolution without selling FdJ - maybe sell other players, maybe get some wage cuts across the board or do some other financial feckery to make it work.

I wish this happens, I really do, but I think people are putting too much faith in “assurances” that might just be hints and backup options rather than a proper desire to join. And I also think some people are putting ETH on a bit of a pedestal. Maybe he’s just a bit blinded by the faint possibility of FdJ joining that he doesn’t wanna give it up. Or maybe he’s being a bit pigheaded too - top level coaches are known to be that at times like Jose and Pep as well.

Also wish Barca were more forceful with forcing him out like other clubs have been towards players in the past. It’s on them to force him out, he’s clearly not gonna go willingly.

Nailed it!

There's so many options open for Barca to keep him. They could easily raise further funds through a 3rd lever. Perhaps more sponsors, who knows.
 
That's just gonna reduce their future earnings. Probably worsening the problem.

They are basically mortgaging their future for success now in the hope increased success leads to increased revenue.

I believe Laporta is really Bartomeu in a different dress with some of the decisions they have made especially in the market and the levers all they have done is kicked the can down the road they'll still need to deal with the money issues and if TV money collapses for them they are really in the mire in a big bad way.
 
Point still stands.

We agreed a fee with Barcelona. Since then he hasn't said a word despite according to many he is 'desperate to stay'

If he was so desperate he can come out right now and effectively turn us down himself, ending all speculation.

His silence speaks volumes.
I completely agree with that. Surely he could end this at any point and just say:

"I'm flattered by the Manchester United links, but I have no intention of leaving Barcelona and I'm open to working with the club to come to a conclusion where I may remain"

That's not happened. The rumours keep swirling and the same crap from a month ago is repeated. For all intents and purposes, de Jong has been silent since agreeing a fee
 
Point still stands.

We agreed a fee with Barcelona. Since then he hasn't said a word despite according to many he is 'desperate to stay'

If he was so desperate he can come out right now and effectively turn us down himself, ending all speculation.

His silence speaks volumes.

It does indeed, but not like you think.

Martinez and Malacia push for transfer, done deals.

FDJ silent, stays put. :wenger:
 
He can stay, on his current contract and completely destroy Barcas wage budget as he won't take a pay cut again, or he can work out a settlement with Barca and leave, which would be much more beneficial for the club.

The only way he's staying is on his current contract from what I can gather

What we see from this is Barca have absolutely done a number on him. He didn't take a pay cut, he defered his wage.

From what I have read, they reduced his salary to help during covid and the £17m owed was to be paid from this season until the end of his contract through his salary.

Which is why, his salary is reported to be 300k plus this season and even more next season. Obviously, barca cannot afford that which is why they want to sell him but they don't owe him money because he signed the deal.

Now he wants Barca to pay the money he feels he is owed and Barca just want to sell him so they dont need to pay those high wages.

I cannot see how this is resolved.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.