Is it still possible to have an excellent transfer window?

[Lee565]

Hard to see when we have already wasted 70 million on a back up left back and central defender that was not really needed compared to other bigger issues in the first 11 needed sorting and he is also getting targeted as a weak spot in the team already.

 

[Annihilate Now!]

I didn't think it was possible but our window has actually gotten worse now.

Every mum, dad, brother and uncle agent can ask for even more extortionate wages now, knowing what an absolute shit show we are on the pitch.

 

[Sandikan]

It can be salvaged. But even if it is, we still look incompetent and incredibly restrictive on who we look at.

If we get Rabiot, FDJ or SMS along with a decent forward who could develop and back up GK before the end of the window then we'd be alright.

But we also need to offload at least 3 more (Bailly, Tuanzebe and AWB preferably) in which case a RB would also be needed.

Under ETH we simply have to get scouts out wider than Europe, South and Central America etc and come Jan and next summer we need to be in early with a clear plan of ins and outs.

In fairness, Europe and the Americas should be plenty of a radar!

 

[led_scholes]

It's not only about the incomings.

Even if we bring FDJ and we somehow manage to find a gk and a 2 forwards, we still have to sell the losers asap.

 

[Judas]

The next two weeks should be the most busy and mental end to a transfer window in the history of the club. Should be. Will it? I doubt it, but its clearly needed.

 

[Bestietom]

Only if we can bring in 4/5 TOP players before deadline.

 

[redmanc]

The glazers are not going to pull 250m out of their back pockets to save the transfer window and our season, its probably Rabiot + potentially FDJ and thats it imo.

 

[Carl]

United fans need to stop turning their nose up at everyone we're linked with. If it's not some wonderkid everyone loses their shit.

Everyone should now realise we're in big trouble. We need all the help we can get.

 

[r0663664]

If Glazer doesn't want this ship to sink, we better buy a RB, 2CM and 1RW. There is no time to waste.

 

[Judas]

We must buy a RB, a couple of midfielders and striker.

In an ideal world we'd get a new goalkeeper to truly challenge (replace) De Gea too.

 

[Delano]

No. We're going to be fleeced across Europe and moan about the market being too expensive.

We've been set up for disaster by being infatuated on pipe dreams, providing clean slates, penny pinching and not identifying a range of talent.

 

[GazTheLegend]

If we got de Jong and Antony/a striker maybe it can be salvaged but the business looks pretty poor so far. We've gone so far backwards. Lost THREE midfielders in Matic, Pereira and Pogba, two AMs in Lingard and Mata, and our 2nd choice keeper. Where's the replacements for those? So much for youth and courage too.

 

[Lyng]

I highly doubt the leeches would be willing to spent the money needed.
We need two midfielders, a new goalkeeper, a right back and a striker.
Selling Maguire, AwB, Bailey, Rashford would help with funds.
Keep De Gea as second choice or tell him to find a new club. And hope Garnacho hits the ground running.

 

[Red Rash]

If we got de Jong and Antony/a striker maybe it can be salvaged but the business looks pretty poor so far. We've gone so far backwards. Lost THREE midfielders in Matic, Pereira and Pogba, two AMs in Lingard and Mata, and our 2nd choice keeper. Where's the replacements for those? So much for youth and courage too.

Yea we have done a pretty terrible job so far. It could be argued that Martinez and Malacia have been signed for some the lower priority positions while Eriksen has offered a replacement for the AM position.

The reality is we need at least two CMs, RW,, CF and RB before the window closes. Anything less is pretty unacceptable considering we knew what we needed at the end of last season and have freed up a lot of wages by losing Cavani, Pogba, Lingard, Mata, Matic, Pereira plus possibly Ronaldo, Bailly and one or two more.

 

[GaryLifo]

Given our level is currently bottom half of the table, there's many players at better teams who would be very good for us.

 

[croadyman]

United fans need to stop turning their nose up at everyone we're linked with. If it's not some wonderkid everyone loses their shit.

Everyone should now realise we're in big trouble. We need all the help we can get.

Yeah these unknowns might actually care which we certainly need in the squad right now

 

[croadyman]

I highly doubt the leeches would be willing to spent the money needed.
We need two midfielders, a new goalkeeper, a right back and a striker.
Selling Maguire, AwB, Bailey, Rashford would help with funds.
Keep De Gea as second choice or tell him to find a new club. And hope Garnacho hits the ground running.

Sell Maguire keep Bailly as ideal partner for Varane and put Martinez at CDM

 

[2 man midfield]

Yeah, it’s possible. But unlikely we’d do enough business to plug all the holes. We’d need something like:

In: De Jong, CM, CF, LW, RB
Out: Ronaldo, any number of hangers on we’ve still got

I’d consider that a belter tbh.

 

[croadyman]

It's not only about the incomings.

Even if we bring FDJ and we somehow manage to find a gk and a 2 forwards, we still have to sell the losers asap.

Yeah laziness fc just like Everton away in 2019

 

[Ralph1386]

Yeah, it’s possible. But unlikely we’d do enough business to plug all the holes. We’d need something like:

In: De Jong, CM, CF, LW, RB
Out: Ronaldo, any number of hangers on we’ve still got

I’d consider that a belter tbh.

That would only happen in a parallel universe where we weren’t owned by the Glazers and had a competent DOF.

 

[2 man midfield]

Think you mean RW

I’d take either. I thought Sancho was playing on the right this season? Granted I didn’t see the game yesterday

 

[r3idy]

Whatever they do know will always be seen as a knee jerk reaction, even if said players have been previously scouted and identified as having the right technique and mindset. If FdJ comes, that will only ramp up the pressure even more. How the Ronaldo saga has been left to fester is beyond ridiculous.

 

[croadyman]

I’d take either. I thought Sancho was playing on the right this season? Granted I didn’t see the game yesterday

He is struggling since Tony got injured

 

[croadyman]

The glazers are not going to pull 250m out of their back pockets to save the transfer window and our season, its probably Rabiot + potentially FDJ and thats it imo.

Well forget top half finish then you leeches

 

[Chairman Steve]

Yes but a lot of it will have to involve bargain hunting and good scouting on our part. Those two characteristics is something we have to get better at. Not everything has to be amazing youth prodigies or experienced, decorated veterans. Sometimes it can be that unfashionable player with modest stats or a late developer ready to explode in the right system.

 

[croadyman]

Yes but a lot of it will have to involve bargain hunting and good scouting on our part. Those two characteristics is something we have to get better at. Not everything has to be amazing youth prodigies or experienced, decorated veterans. Sometimes it can be that unfashionable player with modest stats or a late developer ready to explode in the right system.

So modest stats like this Cunha fella has

 

[Giggsy13]

The point was to get thru this window with tact and authority. Instead we look pathetic and limp like an impotent man at a brothel.

 

[NZT-One]

So modest stats like this Cunha fella has

Probably. Look at Firmino at Liverpool. Sometimes, a striker can operate in a system where he helps others shine. Could be the same thing here. 50 million is a lot, but I could imagine some people would be shocked what some sort of over-average workrate can result in. In fairness though, if you allow yourself a striker with great attributes but a limited scoring rate, you have to make sure that others will balance it out. These days at United, nothing is a given so this could become a problem... But you have to start at some point I guess.

 

[croadyman]

Probably. Look at Firmino at Liverpool. Sometimes, a striker can operate in a system where he helps others shine. Could be the same thing here. 50 million is a lot, but I could imagine some people would be shocked what some sort of over-average workrate can result in. In fairness though, if you allow yourself a striker with great attributes but a limited scoring rate, you have to make sure that others will balance it out. These days at United, nothing is a given so this could become a problem... But you have to start at some point I guess.

Agree with poster who said this only really works if Ronaldo stays and can provide the goals

 

[MyOnlySolskjaer]

Signing Casemiro makes this at least a 6/10 or higher window.

 

[hatchetmac]

Signing Casemiro makes this at least a 6/10 or higher window.

Don't say that Joel Glazer might be trolling the Redcafe and he would take 6/10

 

[avgp_1]

I don't know yet but Casemiro coming in makes it possible to sell our project better to further signings. We have had a couple of weeks of doom, this surely brings some positivity back

 

[Fahad Jawaid]

It is possible to have a good window (FDJ, Casemiro & Neto), but the question remains what did we do all summer, why did we waste 3 months on FDJ and that resulted in failure to bring any other targets. In fact, I would say this shambles of a window and all doom and gloom in around the club has already made us lose 6 points and with Liverpool up next it could be 9.

There is a reason why top teams get their business done early, integrate their new signings into the squad, try new tactics in preseason (like trying Eriksen, Fred in various positions). Whereas what did we do, we delayed signings of Martinez & Eriksen resulting in them hardly getting any preseason matches with the team and not really getting into tune with the lineup and setup at Utd. Thus, we go on to see Eriksen playing as a False 9 in one match and then a 6 in another. Similarly playing Fred as a 6 in one match then quickly realizing he needs to play as 8 in another match.

It reflects very poorly on ETH, because reportedly he was hell bent on FDJ signing and he was the only player in the world, who could play that role, now fast forward two weeks with inept level of performances from Mcfred, we are trying to sign anybody who has Midfielder on their profile.

If FDJ deal was so important to ETH, he should have tried to sign the likes of Casemiro, Kamara (free and low wages) at the start and then waited for FDJ, because not only this would have given us a solid platform and strong negotiation position, we would have at least picked up 4 points and not become a laughing stalk of Europe.

 

[Beachryan]

If the window closed before the season ended, and we all simply didn't pay attention til it ended, I think absolutely.

This strategy - even if we end up with some decent players by Sept 1st - basically writes off the beginning of the season. Now, if we save c. 50m on last minute deals, maybe that's worth it in the long run, but it's hard as fans.

 

[yamo123x]

Casemiro, whilst he is a brilliant workhorse and ball winner he isnt enough, we still need a technical player like De Jong too.

Still think we will spunk 70million on Antony on deadline day.

 

[croadyman]

I don't know yet but Casemiro coming in makes it possible to sell our project better to further signings. We have had a couple of weeks of doom, this surely brings some positivity back

Yeah hopefully brings that same influence to signings I thought we might get from De Jong

 

[croadyman]

Casemiro, whilst he is a brilliant workhorse and ball winner he isnt enough, we still need a technical player like De Jong too.

Still think we will spunk 70million on Antony on deadline day.

Yeah definitely still need that technical player

 

[BrilliantOrange]

If we still manage to get Frenkie now.. This window is amazing..

Definitely not ready after this window.. Will steeds need another right back, striker, winger (and goalkeeper..), to become really competitive but it would be a massive transformation already..

 

[TrustInJanuzaj]

I won’t be happy unless we can get a keeper to replace De Gea because without that we are going absolutely nowhere. Shame Sommer ruled himself out, that was a dream signing.

 

[VidaRed]

All this transfer activity should have happened before preseason.