There’s definitely an argument. The fact he hasn’t done it under certain circumstances that someone like Ferguson did will be held against him, but there’s also something to be said for taking the jobs where success is expected, there’s a pressure in that as well and meeting those expectations. People often make the point that Guardiola couldn’t do what Klopp did at Liverpool, which I think is probably true, but I think the reverse is true as well, not many managers would have had the league domination Guardiola has had even with all the advantages granted to him. I don’t think either manager will have been as good as prime Allardyce at rescuing clubs destined for relegation, horses for courses and all that. If you have financial superiority and you’re going to pick any one manager to guarantee you the league, you’ll pick Guardiola. I also think his work at Barcelona gets underrated in these discussions, people will point to the amazing players he inherited, but Guardiola made a lot of bold at the time, he had a clear innovative vision of how he wanted his team to play, shifted some legends of the game and put faith in some untested and unproven youngsters and massively lifted the game of others, and constructed arguably the greatest club side of all time all as a rookie manager. No other manager would have achieved what he did that season. So while it’s fair to say Guardiola couldn’t do the jobs that other managers have, and people will point to Mourinho’s inter and situations like it, it’s only fair to say that 07/08 Barcelona could have only have happened under him.
When people talk Messi and Ronaldo, and someone says “I don’t see the point in comparing them”, I never really understood that. Two players who played at the same time and were positionally comparable enough to make comparisons, why wouldn’t someone have an opinion on who’s better? But with Ferguson and Guardiola I get it, two GOAT managers who had different strengths and suited different jobs. I’d still go for Ferguson, but I can easily see the argument for either.