Brutally honest at times and it makes good viewing....
Is Roy Keane actually a good pundit
- Thread starter padzilla
- Start date
It's always interesting to see what he has to say.
When it comes to United there aren't many in a better position to comment than Keane.
When it comes to United there aren't many in a better position to comment than Keane.
Kloop has won nothing.
Pep has failed in Europe and given the resources he has will be considered a failure if City fail to win the CL in his time.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
He’s bang on tonight.
Facts
Isn't he supposed to be coaching Nottingham Forrest now?
Imagine him and Pogba in the same dressing room. There would be blood.
Only Pogba’s
He just went ballistic on Pogba out of nowhere. Crazy fecker.
He’s being brutally honest about the club and the players.
Totally agree with everything he has said.
How I wish we still had a leader like him in our team.
Totally agree with everything he has said.
How I wish we still had a leader like him in our team.
Can they get him on every week? He was having none of that Pogba bollocks.
Sky only have one pro Liverpool pundit tonight too. Refreshing change.
Sky only have one pro Liverpool pundit tonight too. Refreshing change.
Yeah Keane's right. Pogba has to make his team mates better. On Sunday he should've put a chance on a plate for Rashford to get us into the game.
And he does have to deliver himself as well. He should try being our top scorer with 13 assists as well.
Pogba's mentality needs to be questioned but then Keane says stupid stuff like they were throwing hair gel at each other on Sunday in the dressing room.
And he does have to deliver himself as well. He should try being our top scorer with 13 assists as well.
Pogba's mentality needs to be questioned but then Keane says stupid stuff like they were throwing hair gel at each other on Sunday in the dressing room.
I don't know if he's a good pundit, but I love listening to him. He's spot on about our team right now. None of them are fit to wear the shirt. I'd love to feck them all off in the summer.
agree with him or not Roy is always honest in his thoughts.
The club needs more of that.
The club needs more of that.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
He is brilliant.
This is the sort of situation where Keane comes into his own as a pundit. No need for any real insight and a free reign to be as critical as he wants of the players without anyone really being inclined to disagree.
Someone should sit him down and ask him his opinion of each and every player in our current squad, just for fun.
Someone should sit him down and ask him his opinion of each and every player in our current squad, just for fun.
It's a shame his mentality and fight doesn't mix with modern teenage millionaires otherwise he'd be a great manager.
Don't think Keane has ever been too far away from the truth even at his most miserable. The issue is seemingly people believing his has the tools himself to come in and fix things if given the chance. Not much evidence of it.
He'd probably be better on the fecking board in truth. Setting standards from above rather than actually working with the players.
He'd probably be better on the fecking board in truth. Setting standards from above rather than actually working with the players.
Absolutely brutal from Keano there but he’s spot on I reckon.
I actually thought he was quite reserved there. If we lose, I expect him.to go in with studs up.
It didn't mix with grown adults at times back when he was playing. Don't think we can put the blame on modern players to be honest, although it is probably a worse fit now yeah.
He’s right. If there’s one thing he definitely knows a bit about it’s playing CM for United. Worth listening to him on Pogba.
I agree with Keanes comments on Pogba, however...
Players these days don’t necessarily love the clubs they play for. Take for example, Ronaldo at Juventus, I doubt he loves the Italian heritage and Juventus history, he wants to break records and win leagues... same for Neymar, does he care about the French and PSG’s history etc..? It’s just a wage to some players these days.
I’m sure people wouldn’t be as harsh on Pogba if he actually wanted to be here and said he did. Then the fans would accept his laid back style of play more.
Keane is very old fashioned and on this occasion it’s hard to disagree with him.
Paul Pogba wants to leave and I believe he will this summer to Madrid.
Players these days don’t necessarily love the clubs they play for. Take for example, Ronaldo at Juventus, I doubt he loves the Italian heritage and Juventus history, he wants to break records and win leagues... same for Neymar, does he care about the French and PSG’s history etc..? It’s just a wage to some players these days.
I’m sure people wouldn’t be as harsh on Pogba if he actually wanted to be here and said he did. Then the fans would accept his laid back style of play more.
Keane is very old fashioned and on this occasion it’s hard to disagree with him.
Paul Pogba wants to leave and I believe he will this summer to Madrid.
He talks bollocks and has a history of it. The way he criticised Queiroz, Ronaldo and Fletcher was a disgrace in the past. It was refreshing to see all three have the last laugh.
Do remember Keane was a Leeds fan. Sterling in his interview confirmed he was a United fan.
So Pogba doesn't track back...
Did Ronaldo?
Is Pogba being told to track back? If he's not doing what he's told, why isn't the manager being criticized for not subbing him.
Pogba is obviously the easy target for these bitter pundits for whatever reason.
He's come out and held his hands up after the game and that's unprofessional and bitchy from Keane.
He's literally been our best player this season ffs. It's laughable,
Did Ronaldo?
Is Pogba being told to track back? If he's not doing what he's told, why isn't the manager being criticized for not subbing him.
Pogba is obviously the easy target for these bitter pundits for whatever reason.
He's come out and held his hands up after the game and that's unprofessional and bitchy from Keane.
He's literally been our best player this season ffs. It's laughable,
Are you seriously comparing a midfielder with a wide-forward/striker?
He’s boring as feck. Tearing apart Pogba, who’s been put forward by the club to spout the lines the club wants the fans to hear.
Might have been interesting if he had dug out Rashford, Mata, Matic, Jones et al with the same force.
There’s a reason why he’s stuck with O’Neill and will never get a managerial job again. These guys know all from a position of no pressure.
Might have been interesting if he had dug out Rashford, Mata, Matic, Jones et al with the same force.
There’s a reason why he’s stuck with O’Neill and will never get a managerial job again. These guys know all from a position of no pressure.
The good players that turn into good manager always seem to be the ones who think about all the little details in Football. Keane does not seem to be like that at all.
Souness and Neville loving it
Ronaldo scores 40+ goals a season
Ronaldo is a forward
Please stop embarrassing yourself
Was Keane not a Spurs fan?
He's even comparing Ronaldo with Pogba.
One is worth indulging, the other not so much.
I'm asking why the manager isn't subbing him if he's not doing his role on the pitch.
Why he's not being screamed at.
Could it be that he's been told to roam and been given a free-role?
People will trash on anyone and everyone to defend Pogba 
A CM that has a free role and can roam. Pogba really is a special player, can play 3 positions at once
Neville should be ashamed that he has now regressed to Souness and Keane's level as a pundit.
Wind your neck in lad.
If you're not capable of understanding my point, it's not my fault.
So what's his manager doing not subbing him?A CM that has a free role and can roam. Pogba really is a special player, can play 3 positions at once
Why's he not being screamed at?
You seem to think he's operating as some sort of rogue force and Ole can't control him - when in truth he could, and would sub him off if he wasn't doing as asked.