Good stuff in this thread! I agree with everything said. But there is no real scenario that worries me.
1. There is no guarantee that he will like it here, that is true, but if he for example don’t hit it off with ETH — what are the odds that we would want to keep him?
2. I am not worried that he would be out of this world great. I think he got potential, sure he could have like a 4 assist game or whatever, but over the long run he would definitely have his ups and downs. The PL is a tough league, we aren’t dominant, it will take time for him to develop chemistry with all his teammates. I remember Henry’s first season for Arsenal, it’s a long time ago but as far as I recall he was a down right disappointment. Just like he had been in Italy. Sure there are exceptions, but over 5 months I can’t imagine that he will be like Player of the Month or something like that at any point. Player of the week, sure. But not POTM if you get what I mean, requires a different kind of consistency.
3. Look, the atmosphere around the team is really good right now. We will have ups and downs, but we have some great characters on the roster. Even if we tackle off and finish 5-6, there will be optimism about the future. Anyone that comes here and does well will get really appreciated, and anyone that is appreciated by us really loves it.
He won’t want to go to Chelsea or PSG. Solid season here, cautiously optimistic about him being able to take another 2-3 steps to the next level. He would be ours for a fair rate. Atleti needs all the money they can get. They aren’t doing well and must tinker some with that squad. Getting rid of Josi’s wages and getting good return is crucial for them. Do they want to wait to the last day of the summer transfer window?? Nah, I like the position this puts us in.