Oh I agree that they will probably sign Mbappe but I just can't see him displacing Vini on the left so they'll have to find a way to make him happy playing the #9 - which is something he did not want at PSG and wanted a more free role.
Kylian Mbappe
- Thread starter bosskeano
- Start date
I'd love to see that.
Haaland hasn't done anything particularly great for weeks. Didn't score a single goal in either the FA Cup or CL semis or finals. Mbappe has a World Cup hatrick this season in case you'd forgotten.
City have about 6 or 7 players who were more crucial than Haaland in winning the last two competitions. They were doing pretty well without him the past couple of seasons too. The difference is that Pep tightened them up at the back, not that they've been scoring more goals.
Why does Mbappe want to leave psg? Did he fall out with the manager, Mbappe?
Perhaps he should have a word with the club's president, Mbappe, before deciding to leave.
Perhaps he should have a word with the club's president, Mbappe, before deciding to leave.
Come on Jassim!
Not too many players I'd consider if it meant Rashford leaving. In fact there's exactly one player, and that's Mbappe.
I don't see the two things being linked, however.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
PSG want to sell Mbappe this summer but absolutely not to Real Madrid. Interesting...
Engage muppet overdrive.
There's roaming around, and there's "I want to be where I want when I want", which is pretty much what Mbappé asks, hence the "pivot gang" drama at the begining of the season. That's not what ETH did with Tadic, Haller or Dolberg.
Mbappé really needs a team where he'll be coached the hard way because no matter how talended he is, he needs to be given a role. Otherwise his stats will hide poor team performances. He could potentially fit as a 9 in a transition team like Liverpool a couple of years ago but he doesn't work hard enough off the ball.
He's a extremely talented player that needs a coach who will remind him that he is what he is, and will never be Neymar, Messi or any kind of real playmaker for exemple. PSG coaches rarely had the guts to force him to do what he does best : traumatize full backs on the left side and score a sh*tload of goals on top of a significant amount of assists.
Watch it end up being fecking City.
Mbappe - Haaland
Grealish - KdB - Bernardo
Stones - Rodri
Ake - Dias - Akanji
Ederson
Grealish - KdB - Bernardo
Stones - Rodri
Ake - Dias - Akanji
Ederson
Can’t believe City haven’t been mentioned
Not sure they sell to an oil rival or the fact they would be selling to their own competition if they take us over
If he moves to Utd he has the chance to prove he's better than Haaland. Just sayin...
I think Haaland winning the Treble would have made Mbappe even more certain of his desire to leave.
Bring him home.
If he’s about to go to city or Madrid they will do everything to get him to go to united for obvious reasons and welcome to true twin city football future!
He’s a fecking circus, but a great player. I don’t see him going anywhere else but Madrid or city though.
Qatar ain’t going to sell him to an oil rival
Its very simple. PSG promised him a CF before get extended and went back on that promise. Not even in Jan did they correct it. He had made it clear repeatedly he prefers operating on the flanks off a cf than up against two center backs
I think his desire to leave comes (in my opinion) primarily from the fact that PSG is a mess and that we're going downhill with our new recruits. We don't have a coach, all the players Campos signed last season sucked, Galtier sucked, MBappé probably doesn't see the point of staying an extra year since the targets so far seem to be Ugarte, Asensio, Zaha and Marcus Thuram. Who would blame him?
Love how some people here think Qatar will manage United far better than Ineos. They just don't know what they're doing.
Rashford and the bap together would be an exciting prospect. Seems like a total knob but I think I could live with it if he wanted to come and help us win the league.
Imagine if Real had the same mentality? There is a reason why they are adored by everyone and it's not down to the city or country.And again I ask, and then what?
Break our wage structure and create a potential vacuum of players wanting to be paid a hell of a lot more
Foist a player onto the manager who may not be part of his plans
Move the likes of Rashford into an unnatural position and stunt the development of Garnacho
Potential forexcessive player power and interference from above who may tell ETH he has to take Mbappe or he has to play Mbappe
Regardless if Qatar takeover we have a budget this summer due to FFP, spend all of that on Mbappe and then what? Same midfield, same shit GK, same problems but we have a shiny new toy, gee sounds a little like Woodward that
Guy's begging for Real Madrid and had to be convinced with like a 1million a week wage just to not sign for them, absolutely ridiculous, he'll go to them within 4 years regardless because it's his dream
You'll argue well it was Ronaldo's dream too, yes but we didn't have to spend hundreds of millions to get him and hundreds of thousands of wages a week to keep him here
It isn't as simple as "Turning our noses on generational talents" The time to get Mbappe the generational talent was as he was leaving Monaco, we are nowhere near in the position to take him now and I don't believe it would help the team in any way in the long run
You don't say No to Mbappe . Yes, the Financials has to be right but not other reasons that you have mentioned.
Real can afford him but he doesnt want play cf. Its either left or right flank for him. So unless they get a benzema replacement, He isn't going there. I believe City has the best chance and us if we get new owners because Radhford can play cf.
Imagine him and Haaland playing together feck me. Don't think Pep could make them work together in his system though.
Well in theory they're not the same Qataris...
Even if the funding is the same, the actual owner making the decisions for United and PSG would be different, so it's not the same as judging SJR's clubs where he himself was making terrible decisions. Btw, regardless of whether or not PSG hasn't been run as well as it should have been, it's still been run far better than Nice under Ratcliffe. When they took over PSG hadn't won a league since the early 90s and most didn't know anything about the club other than Ronaldinho played for them at one stage.
Well that'll be Grealish fecked though if it happened
Not exactly an apples to apples comparison, is it ? For comparison purpose, I would rather take the Saudi or Abu Dhabi way of doing things in England than a Qatar way of doing in French league.
More over, it wasn't just about signings about Qatar. It included the debt clearance and infra development too.
Hey I'm happy with City's leftovers, bring Alvarez to old trafford!
Well if Madrid can't / don't move for him now there is a liklihood he goes to City.
Real and Barcelona are the biggest team in the big footballing nations; Spain, Italy, France, Portugal and the South American countries. Kids there grow up idolising their stars and seeing them as the place to be if you want to win European Cups and Balon d'Ors because that's what they've been providing the past 70 years. Of course they have to cough up the money too but so do we and other English clubs now, yet when there is a potential Balon d'Or winner type of player, most of the time it's Real or Barcelona.
If he is coming under same wages, no thanks, I don't want wage structure to go to hell because of him.
Praying he goes to Madrid. If he ended up at City why should the rest bother. This league is already verging on being as one sided as the German and French league as it is.
I mean he is 16, it’s not unreasonable for him to be out of form.
But I agree on the Mbappe situation, better to just get 200 million for him and reinvest it.
If there's any chance of getting him, you break the bank for him.
Tbf he is the best player in the world. The rest of the squad would probably understand he's an exception. Our wage structure is already screwed up anyway. Sancho's on over £350k per week
We can't afford him, imagine how much he'd cost and we're already on the cusp with FFP by the sounds of it. He'll want City or Real anyway. The latter needs a striker right now so the stage is set for it really.
Obviously, he could turn out real good, but for a player that young there's like 75% chances he doesn't live up to the expectations. I just mean that there's absolutely no guarantee he'll ever reach the highest level, it's a huge gamble.
Perhaps we could get a friendly Qatari discount
Your club was barely top 4 quality (in France) before Qatar. Your club peaked at being a good European club years ago but Qatar wants more and so they try to artificially push you higher with all these super star signings.
Man utd is very different. Unlike your club, Man utd requires much less help to reach the top. Plus the club is not going to be held back by the league.