diarm
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2014
- Messages
- 16,981
Is Branthwaite not a LCB?I agree, despite being a Branthwaite fanboy I think this lad is the next VVD type rolls royce defender.
Is Branthwaite not a LCB?I agree, despite being a Branthwaite fanboy I think this lad is the next VVD type rolls royce defender.
Sorry, I was talking more in general of CB talents.Is Branthwaite not a LCB?
I do think that Branthwaite is currently more proven than Yoro, despite Yoro being more talented. Branthwaite is a very underrated defender and has been a beast for you lot, especially in the run in. I think the potential downside for Branthwaite is less than that of Yoro but the potential upside may not be as high so it depends on how you look at it, especially in terms of the pace of the PL.I agree, despite being a Branthwaite fanboy I think this lad is the next VVD type rolls royce defender.
Conflicting reports but seems like anything from 50-100m euros. Likely the mid range to upper end of that scale.What would his price be?
€60mWhat would his price be?
I’m a fan of Branthwaite too, but he is not much more developed than Yoro. And I don’t think he’s had an impressive run-in either, few mistakes and there are areas in his game that are costing chances, like committing too early. I think he can become a top PL centre half though, and he also has most attributes. Yoro is class though, the type that doesn’t come around too often.I do think that Branthwaite is currently more proven than Yoro, despite Yoro being more talented. Branthwaite is a very underrated defender and has been a beast for you lot, especially in the run in. I think the potential downside for Branthwaite is less than that of Yoro but the potential upside may not be as high so it depends on how you look at it, especially in terms of the pace of the PL.
I believe his contract is up next summer so there’s that. I think he will cost something like 65m euros personally.What would his price be?
Bargain if he's as good (potentially) as some say.I believe his contract is up next summer so there’s that. I think he will cost something like 65m euros personally.
I haven't seen much of Yoro I confess, I'd say I've watched a handful of Lille matches this season. I just see Branthwaites accomplishments this season as more impressive, especially considering the situation Everton were in and the pressure he was under due to that. Also the pace/level of the PL is different to the French League and I doubt Yoro would come straight in and look as impressive. Again, I don't doubt that Yoro is the bigger talent.I’m a fan of Branthwaite too, but he is not much more developed than Yoro. And I don’t think he’s had an impressive run-in either, few mistakes and there are areas in his game that are costing chances, like committing too early. I think he can become a top PL centre half though, and he also has most attributes. Yoro is class though, the type that doesn’t come around too often.
Scalvini and/ or Yoro would both be very wise investments.This is the exact type of obvious signing we've been missing out on. Rice was the most recent, I hope we don't miss out again.
He was really good for PSVIt's hard to judge Branthwaite. Dyche sets up a tight defence so despite where Everton are finishing, they've been pretty solid. It's hard to know how he'd do at a bigger club, playing a higher line and being more expansive. You'd think at the kind of money being talked about, he'd be a shoe in for England at the Euros, but I'd be surprised if he plays.
Tosin and him is perfect for the RCB spot. Brantwaite and Martinez for LCB. It’s a thing of beauty.I think trying to predict how a young CB will develop is really, really difficult. I would prefer someone more proven in our situation.
I also think Leny could need several years before he is ready for the PL. Bit like Saliba,
Branthwaite is the least exciting of that lot tbh, just strikes me as a young Maguire.. I’m sure we can do better, for far cheaper, Todibo instead and we’d be cookingTosin, Yoro, Branthwaite would be insane. I do worry about Branthwaite's agility in honesty, though.
He’s decent in the air, that’s about it, his positional play is very average, he doesn’t check his shoulder very often and he’s not great at playing out from the back, basically everything we don’t need as we’re already trying to move away from someone with the exact same skill set.It's hard to judge Branthwaite. Dyche sets up a tight defence so despite where Everton are finishing, they've been pretty solid. It's hard to know how he'd do at a bigger club, playing a higher line and being more expansive. You'd think at the kind of money being talked about, he'd be a shoe in for England at the Euros, but I'd be surprised if he plays.
It's like you watched that Howson video and just believed everything he said.He’s decent in the air, that’s about it, his positional play is very average, he doesn’t check his shoulder very often and he’s not great at playing out from the back, basically everything we don’t need as we’re already trying to move away from someone with the exact same skill set.
he’s overhyped like crazy
He's currently sewing badges onto his jacket, he'll get back to you a little later.It's like you watched that Howson video and just believed everything he said.
No, I imagine we just both have eyes, and I get to watch Everton a fair bit because one of my best friends is a big fan,It's like you watched that Howson video and just believed everything he said.
I disagree that his positional play is average. He just plays on the front foot and attempts to anticipate the play, something which he more often than not succeeds in, and when he doesn't, he has the pace and guile to get back and use his immense size to tackle the opponent with slide tackles etc. I disagree that he can't play from the back either, he showed at PSV that he can and at times for us he has too. Look at the goal we scored against West Ham or the goal McNeil scores against Forest at home for example. He's involved in the build up play. Dyche doesn't play with defenders from the back building up too often, they're generally tasked with lumping it to DCL for knock-downs. Additionally, he has also shown he has the ability to play those long balls though.No, I imagine we just both have eyes, and I get to watch Everton a fair bit because one of my best friends is a big fan,
I don’t really watch YouTubers anymore, (I am still partial to a statement Dave video though) has he done a “scouting report?”
Sounds like you think we’re both wrong though, so I look forward to seeing the stats to back up your opinion if so
Think everyone just waiting for next year if Lille don't lower their supposed £40m+ demands, he's out contract in just over a year.What would his price be?
If they only want £45 million for him we should snap their hands off at that price as I doubt he’d want a massive wage, let’s just say he wants £5 million a year that’s £10 million a year on the balance sheet over 5 years for arguably the biggest defensive talent in world football and who’s value will most likely double.Think everyone just waiting for next year if Lille don't lower their supposed £40m+ demands, he's out contract in just over a year.
You lost me at Pickford...Fix the GK and CB spine first.
- pickford
- braithwhite
- Yoro
We aspire to be Everton!Fix the GK and CB spine first.
- pickford
- braithwhite
- Yoro
Murtough still secretly working for us and continuing his work to turn us into Everton, was always a sleeper agent for Everton during his whole tenure here.We aspire to be Everton!