You’re imagining it. When they play well, I’m happy but that doesn’t change my mind on their ability.
Just because someone is in good form doesn’t mean they don’t need replacing. We would benefit more from replacing Shaw, Smalling, Jones and getting a proper winger in for the left hand side. One that can actually deliver crosses and isn’t a natural striker.
If being realistic is “negative”, then so be it. I want us to be back amongst the elite. We won’t do that with midtable players.
Alex Sandro would improve us massively. Perisic would improve us massively.
All top level players would improve us massively, but we aren't City or PSG with unlimited money. You have to be strategic and have a long term plan when trying to build an excellent squad. What we struggle with is depth and consistency in our attacking play. The likes of Lingard, Mata, Martial, Mkhi, Rashford are all central players which is why our offense looks so clunky with spacing, ball movement. We just don't have natural width. Martial is the most effective wide player we currently have & he's not lighting the world on fire. To be more dynamic we should bring in at least 1 player who is a natural winger, and 1 superstar attacker (Dybala, Griezmann, Bale, Sanchez) to upgrade over Mata, Lingard, Mkhi & preferrably divest two of those players (Mata/Mkhi).
Martial & Shaw are actually two of our bright prospects who are delivering when given opportunities. Probably cost a team 200m to acquire talent at their level right now, so "replacing" them would be a highly idiotic move. If we are talking about replacing Rashford has been particularly poor, and Lukaku is under performing just a tad bit. Here's what i'd do:
Loan - Rashford (got massive potential but is too raw currently), Axel
Sell - Mata, Mkhi, Fellaini, Blind, Darmian
Recall - TFM & Pereira
Buy - Superstar Forward, Natural Winger, Midfielder, Young RB
Shouldn't cost more than 150m net. We are in excellent shape as long as our manager players them properly in a 4-3-3 or a 3-5-2
ST - Lukaku, Martial
LW - Martial, Winger, Lingard
RW - Superstar Forward, Lingard, Winger
CM (Left of 3) - Pogba, Lingard, Pereira
CM (Right of 3) - Matic, New CM
DM (ball winning) - Herrera, TFM
CD - Bailly, Rojo, Jones, Smalling, Lindelof, TFM
LB - Shaw, Young, Mitchell
RB - Valencia, Young RWB, TFM
GK - DeGea, Romero
If we struggle with injuries recall Rashford or Axel.