Thisistheone
Full Member
- Joined
- Oct 1, 2010
- Messages
- 7,904
Good news.
To be fair, Young has been in the form of his life this season.Jose has been talking about Shaw like this for a while now but still benched him for two games as soon as Young came back, I don't understand it.
Young is more reliable right now, and has performed better this season, but he’s not the future. I think Jose is right to reintroduce Shaw slowly. If you throw him in to a big game and he makes a mistake that costs us, it’ll set him back.Jose has been talking about Shaw like this for a while now but still benched him for two games as soon as Young came back, I don't understand it.
I mean he benched Pogba too, we're hardly getting rid of him.Jose has been talking about Shaw like this for a while now but still benched him for two games as soon as Young came back, I don't understand it.
At this moment in time, Young is a better LWB.Jose has been talking about Shaw like this for a while now but still benched him for two games as soon as Young came back, I don't understand it.
His crossing could use some work but in terms of pure link up play I think he edges Young with the benefit of still having time on his side. Shaw's biggest strength is his defending, I think that could be why Mourinho might choose to settle on him, the tools are there for his attacking game but they definitely need some polishing.I just can't decide what to think about him. He is solid player, better than the most full backs in league and deserves to be in the squad but i can't say that he proved to me that he is united first 11 material. His attacking game bugs me. Young has so much bigger impact in attack than him.
But again, spending 50-60 mil on another left back while having shaw seems pointless. Except we can get some top top class. But who? For me only sandro is that kind of a player
Agreed.His crossing could use some work but in terms of pure link up play I think he edges Young with the benefit of still having time on his side. Shaw's biggest strength is his defending, I think that could be why Mourinho might choose to settle on him, the tools are there for his attacking game but they definitely need some polishing.
I agree Young has been great this season but I think we need to see the bigger picture now.To be fair, Young has been in the form of his life this season.
It's as if there is this group of people with agenda wanting to portray and kept on believing Mourinho is this kind of sadistic merciless manager.So let's see...
Jose can't stand Mata but Mata has remained a regular first team player.
Jose had issues with Lukaku but he went to buy him for almost a hundred million and plays him regularly.
He wants to kill Martial'a mecurial talent but the kid is one of the first names in his team sheet.
Rashford can do no wrong with Jose but Marcus has been playing from the bench for many weeks now.
Jose never benches Pogba even when he plays rubbish but he did just a few days ago.
He publicly criticized Shaw and wanted to kill his morale but now says Shaw will get a new contract and will be with United for many years.
No, it’s just Jose’s agenda to make people with agendas look like they have an agenda.It's as if there is this group of people with agenda wanting to portray and kept on believing Mourinho is this kind of sadistic merciless manager.
Probably the best he's been for us since his first season were he was very good for us. Definitely not the form of his career though IMO because he used to be top class for Villa on the wing and in the hole. Worms in holes, treat them.To be fair, Young has been in the form of his life this season.
You'll just have to trust Jose's judgement on this oneI'm not convinced by Shaw, he still needs much much work to progress. It will be wrong not to consider buying a consistent L.B.
That would be awesome. And Young for when a more experienced hand is required. I'd love for us to not sign any fullbacks, but just bring TFM and Mitchell into the fold to replace the presumably outgoing Darmian and Blind.I'm getting pretty sure that Mitchell can provide backup to Shaw next season or the one after.
Why is Rojo certain to leave??Still think Mourinho will look to bring another left-back in this Summer despite what he said at the presser on Friday, whether he'll be an experienced pro, or another kid with potential i'm not sure. If Darmian, Rojo and Blind leave, and it looks likely they all will we wouldn't want to be going into next season with only Young and Shaw for the left-back position, Mitchell by all accounts is doing very well, but the difference between the Scottish Premiership and the Premier League is day and night, and it might be a season too early for him.
He's gone off the boil a bit lately so I'd be surprised if he started over Shaw, Mourinho'll probably want Shaw to prove that he earned his contract with a good performance.Will frustrate me if I see Young starting today.
Have I missed something-where does Rojo leaving come from? I genuinely we never looked stronger last year then when Rojo and Bailey were the centre back pair.Still think Mourinho will look to bring another left-back in this Summer despite what he said at the presser on Friday, whether he'll be an experienced pro, or another kid with potential i'm not sure. If Darmian, Rojo and Blind leave, and it looks likely they all will we wouldn't want to be going into next season with only Young and Shaw for the left-back position, Mitchell by all accounts is doing very well, but the difference between the Scottish Premiership and the Premier League is day and night, and it might be a season too early for him.
Mourinho is a student of Fergie's school of psychology and man management; moreseo now he's at united.Jose has been talking about Shaw like this for a while now but still benched him for two games as soon as Young came back, I don't understand it.
I was originally only going to mention Darmian and Blind leaving(think they're both certs), but thought(nearly always a mistake on a forum)somebody would probably reply saying Rojo can always fill in at left-back if needed, which in turn would probably have resulted in numerous posts saying Rojo is the worst left-back in the history of left-backs ending up derailing the thread.Why is Rojo certain to leave??
Just tried to explain to @Traub above, and probably failed miserablyHave I missed something-where does Rojo leaving come from? I genuinely we never looked stronger last year then when Rojo and Bailey were the centre back pair.