Because left footers have this tendency to be weaker with their secondary foot than right footers, but equally tend to make things look sublime with their left, there's something majestic about a pure lefty, I don't know why.
Malcom
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
- Status
Only selling clubs? That's what we did under Fergies time, or have you forgotten? United have always bought promising young players who are ready to play and turned them into stars. I'd much rather that then wait another season for him to be worth 100m and lose him to barca/madrid/psg or city now.
He was an absolute beast in FM2016. Sign him up. 
Agree, that Jeremy Corbyn does have something
Yes, no, maybe. I don't know. Can you repeat the question?.......
From what I can tell and that's not much. Malcom creates chances while Memphis is at the end of them but I wouldn't consider that Malcom is a creator either, to me he is to some extent a polished version of Memphis.
Do we really want another Martial, someone who is so inconsistent and can only muster 1 good in every 5?
I would prefer Mahrez, a proven PL player who can make a consistent contribution in all aspect of our attacking play.
I would prefer Mahrez, a proven PL player who can make a consistent contribution in all aspect of our attacking play.
Cheers. Always felt Memphis was a talent waiting to shine. Shame it didn't happen here
Yes
I think it's you. It's got nothing to do with being predominantly left or right footed. Players that are very one-footed do that that weird thing where if the ball is on the wrong foot and they only have to complete a simple 5m pass, they will use the outside of their good foot instead of the inside of their bad foot.
Valencia for example has been called out many times down the years for being extremely right footed. I remember jokes "Q: Why does Valencia drive an automatic? A: Because he doesn't trust his left foot to step on the clutch pedal"
So no, I don't agree with there being a bias against left footed players.
What is the base of that affirmation, most right footers are absolutely rubbish with their left foot. The reality is that only players that you would consider good to very good technicians are good with both feet and even then, most aren't, they have a serviceable left foot that they try to use as little as possible.
Malcom is much cheaper
I remember when we signed Martial and everyone was complaining about how he looked in the scout nation compilation.
The modern football fan.....
Just the base of eyes from watching football for 30 years, left footers make things look stylish but tend to be useless with their right, where the right footers are not as one footed, I really don't know why, it's my perception from years of viewing.
Yes. How else would you make an opinion of a player you have only seen on YouTube?Are people genuinely judging players they don't know, through youtube?
Watching him since the U-17 and knowing his personality i really doubt he will go to some club to provide crosses..is not that kind of player.
I'm pretty sure he would rather to shot and try to score than cross.
And i dont think he will accept to sign to be a rotation player too
We should look elsewhere, hes not a Mourinho player.
He will not be in the defense all the time, hes an attacking minded player.
Yeah that's true. But saying that, being able to cross with his weaker foot is something he can train. Notice how in the last 2 seasons Valencia has used his left foot a lot more. Also, with a proper overlapping right back, his reliance on cutting in won't be as big a problem. I also really like Pulisic, but just not as an out and out right winger (which we really need).
Martial was also a very offensive player, but he's performed very well this season, so I don't see the whole narrative that Mourinho only wants defensive minded wingers as a problem.
Only a substitute for Bordeaux today.
Is it because he is ready to go?
Carrying a slight knock, wasn't even in the squad last week.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Well Malcom isn't an out and out right winger either and I personally don't want to see us sign an old fashioned type of winger, that role is for the fullbacks now, get on the overlap for the crossing and use the wide right and left players as inside forwards, which Pulisic and Malcom both are.
I know Pulisic does occasionally play on the right as Philipp and Reus (when fit) are preferred on the left, but I feel like he's more limited playing there. In that sense, Malcom is more of an out and out right winger and at the very least is more of a goal threat cutting in and shooting. If we bought Pulisic to play on the right, we'd have similar problems to when Miki plays there, as we'd be reliant on the right back to get forward to cause a threat on that side. That's not necessarily the case with Malcom. Also, there's no guarantee we'll even sign a new offensive minded right back.
Malcom could be great player for us when we struggle against a team that park the bus, he has the ability to unlock the defence and can score a goal from the outbox. Arsenal, City and Liverpool do that, they committed many shots from long range and we don't have kind of player like that except Pogba and perhaps Young. Just need more attacking dimension in games
I have been impressed with Pulisic on either side of the attack, he's very two footed so unlike Malcom he can cut in from either side and link, or go on the oustide and cross if required, Malcom isn't going to offer us anything Pulisic can't and will be as relaint on an attacking RB to help him with width, even more so as he can barely use his right foot. I think Jose is planning to use attacking fullbacks as he's used Young and Valencia as first choice as opposed to more defensive options like Blind and Darmian.
I agree with you and I prefer Pulisic over Malcom overall as a player as well. But I'm thinking very specifically as a right winger and I think Malcom is more direct and more of a goal threat compared to Pulisic. If we bought Pulisic to play on the right, I reckon we'd have similar problems as to when Miki plays there.
I hope his highlight reel is better than Perišić's.
I know what you mean
What a scandolous post. Martial has the same output as Mahrez this season and you call one a consistent contributer and the other not.
He can cross a ball . Sign him up
Him or Leon bailey
Never seen him play but he seems to play in a position that we're a bit short staffed.
I think he’s Mourinho player if I ever saw one. Very direct and seems to have a cross in him. Obv Pulisic is the better talent but imo I think Mourinho would prefer Malcom over him.
Tbh, unless we learn to play quicker as a unit - it won’t make a difference whether we bring in Malcom, Sterling or Sane. We play way too slowly to get our wingers isolated against full-backs. Our central midfield is generally all done at walking pace, and transition is sluggish.
Yeah, we need another progressive passer centrally as if Pogba isn't on the ball everyone else tends to go sideways, Matic stepped up yesterday and I'd like to see him taking on more playmaking as he has the passing for it.
Very good point. Thats why we are not seeing the best of Martial
Martial has 9 goals and 5 assists in 1066 minutes according to who scored, mahrez has 6 goals 4 assists in 1440 minutes. Pretty clear who is anti martial, since nobody can say anything about his productivity this season, as it's been excellent this season.
Apart from the fact he sort of looks like he can play football?
Excited about the prospect of having a player suited to RW as we desperately need one, but not sure another guy that has to cut back onto his stronger foot to deliver a cross is what we need. It always slows the play down and allows the oppo defence more time to get set. Lukaku has shown he is very good at heading the ball. If we can get someone that can get to the byline and consistently deliver quality crosses Lukaku will bury them. Getting crosses in early is key to increasing that output.
- Status