None of that means anything really.
Every PL player at a club like United having a season like we’re having is, by definition, an overpaid underachiever.
As for “pr machine fuelled” that’s pretty meaningless too. He’s used social media very effectively to drive an extremely noble cause. I don’t see that as reason for criticism.
The only thing I think you could criticise him for is being too engaged with social media. He seems to care too much about what is said online. It’s obviously messing with his head. IMO that’s an important factor in his shitty form. That would be the opposite of “pr fuelled” though. “PR hindered”, if anything.
I think this is a strange take to be honest. By this standard no player deserves any criticism, but if we get into specifics its nonsense really to say 'none of that means anything.'
On underachieving- hes arguably the biggest underachiever among a squad of them. His form for 18 months has without exaggeration been truly appalling. At times a disgrace, with even basic effort missing.
This leads into PR. I can remember few players, playing so poorly, having such a prominent media presence - forgetting about countless causes- but leaks and briefings about his unhappiness with his role, then game time, and then considering his future. Again today hes in the news trying to protect his good guy image. Its endless and nauseating and ever single emotion doesn't need to be peddled to fans as part of his teams imaging of him as this sensitive and emotionally deep modern man.
Every footballer is overpaid, yes. Rashford is absurdly so. As his pay has gone up his form has gone down and if he hadnt banked credit for the school meals, hed get similar disgust as other players on mind numbing figures.
So yes, if a caricature is an exaggerated version, rashford is all of those things to as extreme a level as any player I've known, and my feeling is that I'd love to see far far less of his teenage boy social media schtik. Or better, see him sold