I didn't say you were dumb. I said the comparison to Lukaku was dumb. Because it was.
Osimhen is stylistically different to Lukaku as a player, performing better in Serie A than Lukaku ever did and is an entirely different profile siging to Lukaku, who if anything is an example of the risk in believing someone is "PL proven" rather than the risk of signing someone from another league. Hell, stylistically Lukaku isn't even the United striker from the last few years Osimhen has the most in common with, with Cavani being a more natural comparison.
And again you assert that Kane's profile suits us better than Osimhen's, even though Kane certainly isn't any more in line with the style of striker ETH has preferred up to now. In fact the most recent report linking us to both players specifically noted that Osimhen was the better fit for what ETH wants.
But then again he played creative wide wingers like Tadic and Antony and ziyech at Ajax rather than proper goalscoring inverted forwards like Rashford.
Playing a striker that presses and headers does absolutely nothing for Rashford and Rashford’s doing nothing for them.
Rashford also playing centrally has a similar pressing, pace and now heading ability to Osihmen to go and spend 150 million on such a player.
If Osihmen gets bought and as you say he reminds you of an Ajax CF during ten Hag’s side then we have to play more of the Sancho and Antony playmakers from wide trying to play Osihmen behind on goal; which is the exactly thing Ten Hag played for most of the start of the season with Rashford on goal.
Kane on the other hand is the ultimate version of Martial & Weghorst - so we instantly improve on weaker players that are currently in our system whilst also having a lesser version of Osihmen centrally when Rashford’s playing as a striker - but when he plays left wing of Kane we have the most deadliest version of Son from Spurs. Even players like Sancho as a RW could turn to be the world class version of Lucas. Bruno would turn to the ultimate version of Delle Ali during Spurs CL season either scoring goals or playing in Kane on goal. Then we also have Eriksen as well.
Then we also get to see players like Antony & the unamed one - cutting in and getting played in on goal to start getting deadly finishes from the RW to give us the opposite side version of Rashford on the LW.
Consider the players we have -
- LW - Rashford, Sancho, Garanacho
- RW- Antony, Amad, the non nameable
- All Would get played in on goal by Kane whilst if we buy Osihmen only creative players like Antony, Sancho and Amad would play him on goal. All those players would still play Kane on goal as well because he isn’t just a creator - he is a deadly goal scorer too. We end up having some of the most best experienced players in Kane, Shaw, Casemiro, Bruno, Varane etc. They don’t need to learn anything - just do it and win the league. I wouldn’t cry if Osihmen came, he’s a good young player - but Kane fits us in a whole another realm in my opinion.