Amir
Full Member
Liverpool and Chelsea would consider this a pretty crap season in the league for themselves, very much below par. Finishing above them is better than finishing below them... But it's not some massive success.
There would be room to spend more if we didn't have so much interest to pay annually on the debt (let alone paying it off).There is not really any room to spend more. The only place we can save money is if the Glazer's stop taking dividends, which amounts to $20m per year. That comes to 2% of our total outgoings. The rest is unavoidable.
To add to the list of the other poster, we are actually first in terms of net spend since Solskjaer took charge.
So having a squad that finished second with above 80 points and everyone wanted half a new team it's called a rebuild, but having a squad that finishes second with 70 points and everyone wants half a team is called "upgrading" the team. Sorry mate but you are just changing the narrative.Now we are talking about upgrading the team which is completely normal for every manager. Even Fergie had people complaining about his midfield and wingers at one stage!
I think Ole deserves to have in place what he has asked for and given another year to see if we move forward. Btw I don’t consider it blind faith, I have seen enough to suggest he’s slowly turning this thing around. Our fans need to have patience. Good job social media wasn’t around when fergie was starting, we’d never have known 20 years of success!
You do realize the shit he was left with after Lvg and Jose broke everyone?[
So having a squad that finished second with above 80 points and everyone wanted half a new team it's called a rebuild, but having a squad that finishes second with 70 points and everyone wants half a team is called "upgrading" the team. Sorry mate but you are just changing the narrative.
Every manager wants to improve their squad, and every manager brings and sells players but only Ole has been given this "rebuild" narrative which is basically a excuse to freeze all the titles demands. I just don't buy it.
I agree we don't have specially dominant players in the air besides Maguire, but we are not talking about being an average side. We are talking about being the worst side in the whole league I mean surely there something really wrong with out coaching in that regard it's can't all be on the players.Regarding set pieces the problem is complicated.
De Gea has never been good at coming of his line and dealing with set pieces (i dont really know about Hendo) and outside of Maguire whos fantastic in the air, none of our other players are really that great at it. Pogba, Cavani and McTomminay are decent, but other than that i cant think of many players that are particularly dominant in the air. Another problem is that we play zonal marking and way to often we see players losing focus and leave their zone completely open. This is 100% a coaching issue imo
I don't think that one is that easy to solve at all, bringing a new CM press resistant or whatever won't magically make our defense know how to move in blocks how to isolate the pressure, it will still be the same improvised playing out from.the back that as soon as it's countered with a high pressing team we crumble.Playing from the back is also mostly a player issue imo. Fred and McTomminay are good/decent at breaking up play and screening the defense, but none of them are great passers. Considering Bruno is man marked by everyone these days it cuts of the supply completely when we try to build through the middle and we end up going wide instead. Pogba does solve that in some way, but as we know playing him as CM brings a lot of other problems. If Matic was 5 years younger we would have been golden, but sadly he isnt. A press resistant CM with some ability on the ball and some passing skills would make a world of difference imo
That's one way to look at it, but scoring lots of goals is not necessarily an indication about how good a team is breaking down a side. Since the only goal that break the defense is the first one you score. The way I look at it is we had 7 0-0 draws in the league, we definitely need to improve on that. This team can score the 2nd, 3rd and 4th goal after breaking up the defense with ease that not the problem. The problem is scoring that first goal which is the hardest.I said it before in this thread, but if all it took to defeat a parked bus was a good system, then no one would bother with it. We have gotten better at it though. This season in the league we won 21 games and scored the 2nd amount of goals behind City so its not like we are completely hapless. Room for improvement? Definitely, but imo we are not as clueless as many on here think we ar
I agree we do look like a team with potential, but we should be more than that by now. Still you talk about 3-4 new players, just like it was before Ole came. Nobody matter who comes, we will always ask for a new player. No team sudden says "well this is it, now I'm complete we don't need nobody else" it's constant changing and while we definitely have specific positions that are way below the requirements I think that we also have crucial coaching problems that won't be magically solved just by bringing players.Another bit of progress that often gets overlooked is how nicely the squad is shaping up. We have a very decent core of starters now, and loads of players in the squad we can sell/release without it weakening us significantly
Romero, DDG, Baily, Dalot, Jones, Mata, Pereira, Lindgard, Matic, Martial and Chong are all surplus to requirements and players we realistically can sell/release this summer without it affecting us too much. Not saying its realistic, but if all of those left it would lighten the wage bill considerably, and probably bring in around 100 million £
In the completely unrealistic scenario that all of those leave this summer we are left with
----------------------------Hendo(24)--------------------------------
AWB(23)---Maguire(28)--Lindelof--(26)---Shaw(25)
---------------------Fred(28)---McTomminay(24)-----------
-----------------------------Bruno(26)--------------------------------
Greenwood(19)------Cavani(34)-------Rashford(23)
Subs: Telles, Williams, Tuanzebe, Mengi, James, Diallo, Pellestri, VdB, Garner, Mejbri, Pogba, Elanga, Shoretire
If we add Sancho, Pau Torres and Rice (personally not that convinced about the latter) and sell someone of the ones i listed above, we are looking at a net spend of around 100-150 million maximum which should not be impossible
The average age of that lineup is just 25,4 years, swap out Cavani with someone like Sancho and it goes down to 24,2. Considering most teams peak when their average age is around 26-28 is tells you this is a line up with plenty of potential and room to grow. Oles transfer strategy might not have brought instant success, but it puts down some solid foundations and it means we are going to reap the benefits for years to come
This narrative has been going on here for some time now, I don't agree with it at all. I think it's a narrative to ease up the pressure on Ole. "Sure he must deliver, but even if he doesn't it's not failure because he's building something for a future manager". Like I said I think it's just a narrative to lower the expectations bar so Ole doesn't fail.Just to be clear, Ole and his staff needs to show improvement next season as well for them to keep their jobs. A decent league challenge, 80+ points at least in the league and some sort of trophy is the bare minimum imo
Losing the final in that manner was gutting, but honestly i think the future looks bright. Even if Ole fails to deliver next season and gets the sack, i think hes done well in rebuilding the squad and whoever comes in next is going to have a exciting young team to work with
broke everyone? what does that even mean? players fall appart with managers all the time. Chelsea went through the same shit with Mourinho, Conte went there and won. No one was crying about a whole 3 year rebuild that was needed because "Mourinho broke everyone".You do realize the shit he was left with after Lvg and Jose broke everyone?
The squad isn't anywhere near City, Liverpool and Chelsea when they are injury free and managed correctly. It's still 250m worth of players behind them to challenge them seriously for a title. Conte or Zidane might get closer but they aren't winning.broke everyone? what does that even mean? players fall appart with managers all the time. Chelsea went through the same shit with Mourinho, Conte went there and won. No one was crying about a whole 3 year rebuild that was needed because "Mourinho broke everyone".
That excuse cant be used anymore, not after 2 and a half seasons.
The squad is far from City, but were on par with Liverpool and Chelsea. I agree even with a top manager it would be hard to match City, thats why its critical to get one. Like saying we shouldnt get a better driver because the car isnt fast enough. Well I see it all the way around, we should get the best manager possible to try to close the gap between the squads.The squad isn't anywhere near City, Liverpool and Chelsea when they are injury free and managed correctly. It's still 250m worth of players behind them to challenge them seriously for a title. Conte or Zidane might get closer but they aren't winning.
Except it is. Does anyone remember the progress we made in the late 80's ? If not for 1989 fa cup giving more time to fergie we might have gone into oblivion.It is really not
Its not. Look it up bro. Progress is not about the finale results like winning silverware. Winning silverware is a result of working hard and steady (progress).Except it is. Does anyone remember the progress we made in the late 80's ? If not for 1989 fa cup giving more time to fergie we might have gone into oblivion.
Football is about two things, challenging and winning. Currently were doing neither.
Do the dippers look back fondly 15 years ago when they finished second to us ? Do they feck, that was a failure and anything else is a lie.
Progress in itself means nothing if it doesn't lead to silverware. Look at spurs and there progress in the previous half a decade. Does anyone give a flying feck ? Have you seen spurs fans being over the moon with there progress (which has runs its course, now a new cycle of progress needs to start for them because they're back to square one). There star player who himself is a fan is leaving them because of a lack of silverware.Its not. Look it up bro. Progress is not about the finale results like winning silverware. Winning silverware is a result of working hard and steady (progress).
It's a perfectly justifiable excuse. Is there another team in world football who have had a fixture list as congested as United over the last 18 months.There are people on this forum still excusing the loss vs Villareal because of our depth.
It's maddening to read.
Ole is an excellent motivator. It's his best attribute. His subs (or lack thereof) in the final were really poor though. You can't argue with the criticism there.This is all plausible but if you look back and assess our final performance alongside various semi final performances it does suggest a manager at the helm who isn’t a great motivator. He also bought James and VDB I believe who he didn’t rate to use on the night and many nights. Now his transfer record for me holds up, just unfortunate with our budget and chasing down better squads, we couldn’t really afford another 50m wasted...he needed instead a great bench option. The summer will decide his fate now and strangely he’s not really the decider on how that pans out. Zero credit in the bank now amongst the majority it feels.
What when he keeps saying we didn't turn up? Doesn't sound like an excellent motivator to meOle is an excellent motivator. It's his best attribute. His subs (or lack thereof) in the final were really poor though. You can't argue with the criticism there.
He's made mistakes but, where United currently are, he's the ideal coach. Nobody is perfect and, with Ole, the pros significantly outweigh the cons.
He doesn't have any credit in the bank among fans because unfortunately, most are idiots who think what the media tells them to think, convinced it's their own opinion.
The same fans who will celebrate the success of the protests will criticise Ole for losing games after being put in an impossible situation due to those protests.
Precisely.The progress we made under Fergie was having one of the best young managers in the game with a stellar track record who had been working to transform the club from the bottom up and whose outstanding record in management before he got here earned him the patience and support from the board you wouldn’t expect for most others.
Maybe it's just relative.What when he keeps saying we didn't turn up? Doesn't sound like an excellent motivator to me
I agree with you on your first point but I cannot escape the feeling that the biggest hindrance to our success at this juncture is our management/coaching structure. Watching the match on Wednesday night, did you genuinely look at what was unfolding and say to yourself, “You know what this team is missing? A Sancho or a Kane.” I certainly didn’t. Signing those players is all well and good but I don’t see them propelling us to a title. They will be ‘moments’ players for us in the same vein our other attacking options are.The club needs to be more proactive in signing players
...
It’s just poor planning and our biggest hindrance to success.
The Ole-In crowd is really getting desperate.Precisely.
The ‘You would’ve sacked Ferguson after three years’ arguments are as immaterial as they are lazy. Even a cursory comparison of contexts between 1986-1990 and 2018-2021 indicates this but some folk continue to spout the same inane nonsense.
What Ferguson achieved in Scotland is among the most impressive in club football history yet we have folk we pretended we found him wandering around Salford Precinct and stuck him in the dugout for a laugh. He got a considerable amount of time and patience because he had earned that right, not because of some romantic, PR-wet dream notion of a popular ex-player leading us to the promised land once more.
Can you show me any poster who claimed Ole is as good as Sir Alex?The Ole-In crowd is really getting desperate.
"Ole is as good as SAF!" "Well, Ole is better than Mourinho!" "Tuchel lost a game, see we knew Ole was better!" "Pfft, Zidane doesn't know what it's like to manage at a club like Man Utd! So what if he won 3 UCLs in a row, that's not the United Way!".
Just some of the strawman arguments we hear everyday here to protect Ole just because he scored a tap-in in 99. It is sad how some people would rather die on that hill than have an ounce of rationality.
That's exactly what I thought when Rashford wasted yet another excellent attacking opportunity and looked like he'd be the least mobile player in my O35s team. I was hoping Ole would replace him with Mata. If they had Sancho, he'd have been a great option.I agree with you on your first point but I cannot escape the feeling that the biggest hindrance to our success at this juncture is our management/coaching structure. Watching the match on Wednesday night, did you genuinely look at what was unfolding and say to yourself, “You know what this team is missing? A Sancho or a Kane.” I certainly didn’t. Signing those players is all well and good but I don’t see them propelling us to a title. They will be ‘moments’ players for us in the same vein our other attacking options are.
I long for the day we are a side that is greater than the sum of our individual parts (if that ever happens we’ll be some team as we have some brilliant players) and not a side who plays like a crowd of strangers. The easiest way to rectify that is to upgrade on our management/coaching structure, IMO. The Bayerns, the Madrids, the Citys, the Liverpools, the PSGs etc. all never hesitate to get the best man in if they are any question marks over their current manager whilst we dawdle. That is our biggest hindrance and until it is remedied, we will have plenty of false dawns with inevitable failure, ultimately.
Jesus. It’s really no one that believes they are on the same levelThe Ole-In crowd is really getting desperate.
"Ole is as good as SAF!" "Well, Ole is better than Mourinho!" "Tuchel lost a game, see we knew Ole was better!" "Pfft, Zidane doesn't know what it's like to manage at a club like Man Utd! So what if he won 3 UCLs in a row, that's not the United Way!".
Just some of the strawman arguments we hear everyday here to protect Ole just because he scored a tap-in in 99. It is sad how some people would rather die on that hill than have an ounce of rationality.
Why would anybody be feeling desperate as a supporter of Ole? It seems highly likely that he is going to be getting a new contract this summer and besides nobody really has any doubts that he will lead the team into next season. His position is as secure as it has ever been.The Ole-In crowd is really getting desperate.
"Ole is as good as SAF!" "Well, Ole is better than Mourinho!" "Tuchel lost a game, see we knew Ole was better!" "Pfft, Zidane doesn't know what it's like to manage at a club like Man Utd! So what if he won 3 UCLs in a row, that's not the United Way!".
Just some of the strawman arguments we hear everyday here to protect Ole just because he scored a tap-in in 99. It is sad how some people would rather die on that hill than have an ounce of rationality.
I’d actually say him and his coaching staff are terrible motivators. A well motivated team does not play like we do in most first halfs. Slow ponderous play with players looking half arsed is not a sign of a motivated team.What when he keeps saying we didn't turn up? Doesn't sound like an excellent motivator to me
Yup! He was hardly backed last season with players he needed/wanted too. Got to hope he gets his choice of RW/CDM/CB. If he goes backwards next season after being backed then he should probably leave.Don’t have too much faith in him but 6th 3rd 2nd is progress so he deserves another year
No Manchester United fan has an agenda against Ole for god’s sake! The agenda is against the club seemingly accepting mediocrity.Why would anybody be feeling desperate as a supporter of Ole? It seems highly likely that he is going to be getting a new contract this summer and besides nobody really has any doubts that he will lead the team into next season. His position is as secure as it has ever been.
On the other hand we have a large portion of this forum that clearly have agendas against him and have spent two years arguing about why he should be fired, going to ever increasing lengths to justify your opinions, clearly in many cases delighting over any setbacks so you can come back and rage, and yet you're stuck with him. It sounds like the sort of scenario that would generate feelings of desperation within the moaning community, and the posting always very clearly reflects that desperation.
I forgive his deficiencies because his strengths and what he is doing for the club outweigh them, and no manager is perfect.No Manchester United fan has an agenda against Ole for god’s sake! The agenda is against the club seemingly accepting mediocrity.
it’s blatantly obvious that Solskjaer will never be the manager to return this club to winning PL titles and CL’s.
Would you be this loyal to Roy Hodgson if he was manager and had an identical record to Solskjaer? Or do you forgive Ole’s major deficiencies because he’s a playing legend?
This is exactly how I feel. If you watched us with LVG you could see the plan - here is a coach with a set system and the ability to coach it. It didn’t work but I could very easily see this is where we were and this is where we are now. That’s all we should demand from any coach: implement a style, give them a transfer window and assess.I don’t see the foundations being laid on the field. I think I’d be more on board if I could see what he was trying to do even if he was failing to do it or even if I didn’t like it. I hated LVG approach but I backed him because even though I didn’t like it it was at least a direction. Two and a half years is enough time to build some kind of tactical identity. We’re completely undefinable as a unit. That’s what worries me.
I can’t look at this team and how we play and think we’re signing or two away from kicking on because I honestly do not think we’ve got past the starting blocks.
We should have an identity that we build towards mastering but were among the most tactically nondescript teams around.
So if Hodgson or Moyes was in charge with an identical record you’d be happy to forgive their deficiencies too would you? I don’t think you would.I forgive his deficiencies because his strengths and what he is doing for the club outweigh them, and no manager is perfect.
You saying that it is blatantly obvious he'll never win here IS an agenda. You've made up your mind already. Its unfair to write off a manager and a team that have made progress and doing so is evidence of an agenda I'm afraid.
I'm not sure why you keep mentioning Hodgson in this. I really dont see relevance or point. The evaluation has to be about what Ole has done and where we are compared to where we were, not about who he is. Ole was never my favourite player. There's no reason at all why his history here should have any bearing on anything.So if Hodgson or Moyes was in charge with an identical record you’d be happy to forgive their deficiencies too would you? I don’t think you would.
I'm sick to death of this “agenda” bollocks. I’m quite good at Tennis, but can categorically state that I’ll never be good enough to become a professional. Do I have I have an agenda against myself or am I just accepting reality based on experience?
Solskjaer has shown absolutely nothing in the last 2.5 years to indicate that he’s the man to get us winning titles and Champions Leagues.
He’s come in, steadied the ship and taken us as far as he can. Now it’s time for an elite manager to take us to the next level. In the words of Michael Corleone, it’s not personal, it’s strictly business.
yupYup! He was hardly backed last season with players he needed/wanted too. Got to hope he gets his choice of RW/CDM/CB. If he goes backwards next season after being backed then he should probably leave.
Jury is still out on some of his tactics and style, but one more year to prove something is the least he deserves after the mess we were in after Jose.
I’m mentioning Hodgson as a manager of similar ability level to Solskjaer for comparison.I'm not sure why you keep mentioning Hodgson in this. I really dont see relevance or point. The evaluation has to be about what Ole has done and where we are compared to where we were, not about who he is. Ole was never my favourite player. There's no reason at all why his history here should have any bearing on anything.
You say he has shown absolutely nothing. I think that's unfair and frankly a little ridiculous.