Chelsea's scattergun approach to the summer transfer window concluded with a pair of failed bids totaling well over €100million. Chastened by dropping eight points in their first four fixtures, the Premier League champions attempted to prevent Anthony Martial from leaving AS Monaco for Manchester United, and to extract Marquinhos from Paris Saint-Germain.
PSG refused to sell their young Brazil center back to a Champions League rival, regardless of the €35m Chelsea were prepared to pay for Marquinhos. Monaco stonewalled Roman Abramovich's attempt to intervene in their surprise sale of teenage forward Martial to Old Trafford.
United reset a series of transfer records by agreeing an initial fee of €50m for Martial, bolstered by a further €30m of “easy” performance-related variables. According to a source involved in the deal, the final transfer fee for the 19-year-old could reach €90m if the forward triggers further bonus payments. Chelsea, who had approached Monaco earlier in the summer with a view to recruiting Martial for the 2016-17 season, offered to match United's bid.
Such high-stake, final-week moves for the two Ligue 1 youngsters, coupled with Chelsea's belated inquiries into Paul Pogba's availability contrast markedly with the carefully prepared and executed strategy of one summer before. Ahead of a start to the Premier League campaign in which Jose Mourinho's side went 14 matches unbeaten, Chelsea made four of their five first-team signings before the end of July.
The pre-planned, and most expensive, acquisitions of Diego Costa, Cesc Fabregas and Filipe Luis were all formally completed by mid-July, allowing Mourinho to integrate the trio into preseason training as early as possible in a World Cup year. Loic Remy, who had been headed to Liverpool until the Merseyside club reneged on a salary package, was the only player added after the season had begun.
This year, it was July 13 before backup goalkeeper Asmir Begovic arrived from Stoke City. A long negotiation with Augbsurg over Abdul Baba Rahman's fee concluded on August 17, two matches, and five dropped points, into Chelsea's title defense. The club gazumped Manchester United's drawn-out negotiations with Barcelona for Pedro the same week, and ended the window by signing two defenders operating at level far separated from the Champions League.
Jamaica center back Michael Hector was bought from, then immediately loaned back to, Reading. Senegal international Papy Djilobodji joined from Nantes on deadline day – only to be excluded from his new employers' Champions League squad less than 48 hours later. Unless injuries dictate otherwise, Djilobodji is not expected to be granted many starting opportunities in his debut season.
Intent on improving his tactical options against stronger opponents, Mourinho had identified central defense as the priority area to reinforce for a campaign in which he was expected to both retain the Premier League title and challenge for the Champions League. John Terry's discomfort when asked to operate in a high block and Gary Cahill's shortcomings as a man marker typically force Chelsea to defend deep against better teams, particularly in European matches. The decision to allow Filipe Luis to return to Atletico Madrid after a year in which the Brazil left back failed to adapt to life in England amplified Mourinho's need for new recruits.
Chelsea's board eventually resolved to pursue John Stones, a 21-year-old England defender who's initially been penciled in as a recruit for the 2016-17 campaign. Informed that Everton's hierarchy would sell Stones at £30m, Chelsea attempted to land him at what they considered a more realistic price. This provoked protests amongst Everton's support, eventually forcing chairman Bill Kenwright to publicly rule out a sale.
By that point, Chelsea's early-summer reluctance to fund Mourinho's reinforcement requests had transformed into the quick-fire decision to meet Barcelona's asking price for Pedro; a move that resulted in Juan Cuadrado being sent to Juventus for an embarrassingly low loan fee.
Finally came the nine-figure sum put forward for Martial and Marquinhos as the window drew to a close; an amount more than sufficient to reinforce all Mourinho's areas of concern had it been made available as early as funds were in 2014. Famous for his attention to detail, the manager's view of such shotgun shopping is not hard to decipher.
"I don't like that,” said Mourinho when asked one week ago about the possibility of a late spend. “I gave my club the season's projection report on April 24th. I don't think it's now, on August 29th or 30th to say 'I want this and that or I want to try this and that'. We have to gel.”
In this last transfer window, the board's ideas conspicuously failed to gel with those of their manager.