I dispair...giggzy said:
The lack of aprecciation of some of our best players on here is frightening!
Paul Scholes
- Thread starter Davo
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
The lack of aprecciation of some of our best players on here is frightening!
Doubt any of them have actually been to OT.An Extremely Boring Man said:
It is Redcafe afterall.
Against the 'Milans' he got us the equiliser which secured our semi-final spot in 1999...Still thinking of a name said:
oh dear, some of you moaners here about every players who are getting old must be sold is pathetic.bazalini said:
I believe it was a measure to ensure some objective opinion comes onto the forum, instead of all the rose tinted glasses posts about our players and how great they all are, even if they are not.giggzy said:
Its called a debate. You need more than 1 argument for this, we can't all agree.
IMO, if we get Scholes back in midfield he will improve but we do need to sign a world class creative midfielder. I think fergie has totally gone OTT on DM's and defenders, we also need either a right or left sided midfielder so Ronaldo can play on the opposite side and a least put Giggs under some pressure for his place in the team.
You're talking rubbish thoughStill thinking of a name said:
Great. So we can count on bringing on Paul Scholes 1999 if we need a goal against Milan.An Extremely Boring Man said:
I'm stating my opinion - Its up to you to disprove it, which you have done very well. I still don't believe he has ever "done it" at the top level, however.An Extremely Boring Man said:
giggzy said:
I'm fed up hearing this. Sick in the teeth in fact. I live in Ireland and a regular fan at Man Utd. I do not adhere to the lets get behind everyone because it is the norm, but if I see someone play shit I let them know.
In Madrid or Milan or Munich fans can critise players and who is more successful. Even Liverpool fans are quick to turn against players. A players loyalty or skill level is not based on what has being produced in recent years but in recent matches.
Now in my view for Man Utd to win anything this season we need to look beyond Scholes who failed to deliver for Man Utd last season.
Personally, I'd just bring on Paul Scholes, the player who's been great for us for the last decade.Still thinking of a name said:
gone fishin' be back in a few.
He's argued his point.Still thinking of a name said:
Proved you wrong, about Scholes against the bigger European clubs.
Get over it.
You lot are too sentimental..
And too biased
And too biased
Still thinking of a name said:
Has played well against some of the best teams in Europe for almost a decade. The CL is the highest level of football there is.
I don't give a feck.bazalini said:
You only give a feck if a fan is critical and not when a player is shit.giggzy said:
I support 11 players and a team, not a fecking circus of fans.
sell Owen and Gerrard then.Davo said:
bazalini said:
Scholes was out injured for half the season, and stuck on the left wing for half the games he actually played - and he still managed to score 15 goals!Look at the Scholes from the 2002/03 season. IMO his best season ever for us. He was sensational!
No no - I suggest you "get over it". Read my response to him - I said he's proved my points wrong, but I still don't feel his tipped the top of the tree. Thats my opinion of which I am entitled to.giggzy said:
And you are too much of a wind upDavo said:
or
clueless
Is there any United players that is actually worthy of playing for us?bazalini said:
They're both young and have years of football ahead of them...soccerbest said:sell Owen and Gerrard then.
Totally different from the aging Scholes...if you're going to debate, do it sensibly
Which players have "tipped the top of the tree"?Still thinking of a name said:
Davo said:
The whole team bar Ronaldo were underpar last season.An Extremely Boring Man said:
Look at the Scholes from the 2002/03 season. IMO his best season ever for us. He was sensational!
Reckon we sell the lot them.
Being objective afterall.
You're a bit simple when it comes to Man Utd. You think they'll win the league every year...that they've got all the best players blah blahAn Extremely Boring Man said:
You can't see the obvious failings of someone like Scholes...it limits your ability to understand the game
Nobody wants Owen.....soccerbest said:sell Owen and Gerrard then.
So they can't get rid of him.
And Gerrard'll leave sooner than later.
I honestly think I have a greater understanding of the game than you.Davo said:
You're on an obvious wind-up here.
I obviously don't think we've got all the best players, but in Scholes I believe we've got a great player.
In the case of Inter - yesStill thinking of a name said:
giggzy said:
That is the spirit Giggzy. However Saha, Keane, Silvestre, Carroll, Howard, RVN, Giggs, Fortune, O'Shea, even Phil Neville produced the stuff I would expect from them.
Scholes did not and does not look like he will, given we have stronger players in his positions.
Sell him and move on
Keane, Saha, Giggs, Fortune, O'Shea and Phil Neville were no better than Scholes last season.bazalini said:
Gary Neville was, Silvestre was, Rio was, Ronaldo was and Ruud possible was.
Agreed, except Ruud definitely was!An Extremely Boring Man said:
Davo said:
scholes = better than any player at liverpool FC.Nahh your understanding is limited to "Man Utd are the best"An Extremely Boring Man said:
Like I say, you're a bit simple when it comes to things Man Utd. You're probably more rational discussing Chelsea, or Spurs or something...
Look at you here with Scholes...you're making a fool of yourself
last season goal-scoring stat of our players. 
Top scorers:
Ruud van Nistelrooy: 30
Paul Scholes: 14
Ryan Giggs: 8
Diego Forlan: 8
Louis Saha: 7
Top scorers:
Ruud van Nistelrooy: 30
Paul Scholes: 14
Ryan Giggs: 8
Diego Forlan: 8
Louis Saha: 7
You are just simple full stop.Davo said:
Back to the play ground were you belong.
I thought I told you in my first post of this thread.Davo said:
Feck off.
Mind you, he could be a useful sub to bring in...
Like a fatter David Fairclough
Like a fatter David Fairclough
I second Weastie