What do people think? No Ronaldo on the list and not sure why Ward Prowse is on there. Saka is also an interesting choice and no Chelsea player on the list.
PL player of the season
- Thread starter TheGame
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have two new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting for the new Premier League season.
A new Premier League Predictions competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
A new Last Man Standing competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
For Last Man Standing you have until the 16th August to submit your predictions. Submissions will be open for the next 20 days, 17 hours, 30 minutes, 46 seconds, and will close on Aug 16, 2024 at 20:00.
Bonus: for fans of Odds or Evens, the thread will be going up mid-August with a deadline for after the transfer window shuts.
Can't really think of a standout candidate.
KDB.
Tricky.
Would have said Salah earlier in the season but he's dropped off a bit recently.
And though KDB seems to be the popular choice among City fans in terms of their nominees, he's missed or played minimal minutes in about 12 league games so far, which is a fair chunk.
Would have said Salah earlier in the season but he's dropped off a bit recently.
And though KDB seems to be the popular choice among City fans in terms of their nominees, he's missed or played minimal minutes in about 12 league games so far, which is a fair chunk.
Last edited:
What about Mahrez?
I’d probably say Salah.
I’d probably say Salah.
What's with the Saka emoji? A chili? Shouldn't it be a gun or a cannon?
Missed or was a sub in 23 of their league games so far. Was used a lot more in the CL.
Do Saka and JWP really deserve a nomination?
Some of those over Ronaldo is mental
Salah has the most assists and the most goals of anyone in the league. Kevin de Bruyne has been the driving force behind a likely title win.
Everybody else on the list is just making up the numbers.
Everybody else on the list is just making up the numbers.
If you were picking from City then really it should probably be Bernardo Silva. He doesn't have KDB's profile though.
De Gea is the Redcafe POTY (so far) based on the ratings.
Has he been that good or is it more like everyone else being muck?
Has he been that good or is it more like everyone else being muck?
Cancelo for me, he’s been consistently excellent all season. They’ll probably give it to Salah or KDB but Salah has been awful since losing Afcon and KDB has been hit and miss, especially first half of the season.
I’d go with
1. Salah
2. KDB
3. Son\Trent
None of the others have a real claim. JWP and Saka are questionable nominees.
1. Salah
2. KDB
3. Son\Trent
None of the others have a real claim. JWP and Saka are questionable nominees.
Salah is burnt out now, but it’s definitely him. Most goals and most assists and no other player has been consistently good enough over the season to make a case based on performances.
The latter.
The latter.
Joao Cancelo for consistency.
Salah phenomenal for 2/3 of the season, but has dropped off since March.
Salah phenomenal for 2/3 of the season, but has dropped off since March.
No I mean Ronaldo
Strange
Nothing strange about it. De Gea is an incredibly overrated goalkeeper.
Yeah i think it's between Cancelo, Salah and Son in terms of merit. It'll be either Salah or KDB winning it though. Who are the voters again?
Still our best player this season, easily
People saying De Gea 
Only 5 prem teams have conceded more goals than Utd… ffs
Only 5 prem teams have conceded more goals than Utd… ffs
Not for me.
Strange
Salah's not been at is best since coming back from AFCON. KDB is my shout.
Not really. He's not had many bad games. Ronaldo has had plenty.
Also we've scored tonsPeople saying De Gea
Only 5 prem teams have conceded more goals than Utd… ffs
1) De Bruyne
2) Salah
3) Alexander-Arnold
2) Salah
3) Alexander-Arnold
Hard to say - as mentioned no real standout candidate. Would have been Salah but he's really tailed off the last few months of the season.
Might have to go KDB.
Feel Bernardo Silva has been hard done by not making this list. Ward-Prowse is an odd addition, and as good as they've been I think Bowen and Saka are slightly fortunate too.
Might have to go KDB.
Feel Bernardo Silva has been hard done by not making this list. Ward-Prowse is an odd addition, and as good as they've been I think Bowen and Saka are slightly fortunate too.
Ronaldo has had a good season for his age, but, i don't think he quite makes it to the nominations.
Strong start and finish to the season, but a rather bad spell in the middle ruins it for him.
Second most saves in the leaguePeople saying De Gea
Only 5 prem teams have conceded more goals than Utd… ffs
I think it has to be Salah, although he dropped off the gas, but his start was really outstanding. Best player from City team performance wise actually I think Silva has been something else, it is just that stats dont show everything, although ofcourse, Kevin de Bruyne on his day is still the best player in EPL.
They’re English so of course they do.
I would probably go for Trent.
I don't think he should necessarily be nominated either but he has more right to be there than Saka or JWP
Not in my opinion. Good games here and there but not stood out during the season.