Basically the whole situation is, and always has been, a land dispute; a battle over territory. And, as much as it depresses me to say so, battles over territory generally end messily and with a victor.
As much as we'd love the two sides to be viable neighbours, it looks further away than ever. I think the eventual solution may take some really unpopular, difficult and morally questionable decisions to be made.
Unfortunately you are probably correct.
WW2 for example did not end in a negotiated settlement. A negotiated settlement in 1942 would have been a very different affair.
Likewise the American Civil War might have had a very different negotiated settlement in 1863 but in 1865 ended in total victory/defeat.
There is something inevitable (maybe people believe its even prophetic) about no good ending here.
What the extremists on BOTH sides have managed to do is alienate the middle ground. Which is of course exactly what they want.
As this thread shows any attempt to make any kind of point will get a reply beginning
"What about????".
While I understand the feelings of people actually LIVING there (I am from Belfast after all) and also sympathetic to the wider ethnic/religious solidarities I cant and wont buy into a scenario that says one side is "better" than the other.
Repugnant as that thought is ...to people so blinded by their own victimhood and backed by the
twisted and fundamentalist version of two of the worlds great religions....I wont back either side.
Although not backing a side 100% will label me a Zionist or an anti semite by fundamentalists.
I cant win....especially on Internet Message Boards where nuanced approaches are not appreciated.
So Mike is probably right..........it will all end in a victor and a vanquished.
But a divided Arab world (Iran and Saudi Arabia) is unlikely to ride to the rescue of brother Arabs. Too much to lose.
And the reality of post Cold War Politics is that USA is unlikely to ride to the rescue of Israel. Too much to lose.
Frankly the maniacs in that part of the world would rather see the earth scorched than the other side win. They deserve each other.
Best we can hope for is that the whole planet is not scorched and the effects are localised.