Rashford or Martinez.
Sir Matt Busby Player of the Year 2022/2023
- Thread starter Desert Eagle
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Casemiro and Martinez have been the difference this season it should be one of them. But it will be Rashford.
I think it will be Rashford.
So refreshing to finally have a few worthy candidates to choose from rather than De Gea being the only one 
Rashford, Casemiro and Martinez are the most obvious ones but I would also add Eriksen as a honourable mention, he has been great and we have missed him a lot in the past few months. I think Rashford will win it.
Rashford, Casemiro and Martinez are the most obvious ones but I would also add Eriksen as a honourable mention, he has been great and we have missed him a lot in the past few months. I think Rashford will win it.I think I would go with Martinez, literally every game he’s been at least a 7/10 he’s been so consistent.
Rashford will and probably should win.
Nice to have a few candidates for once. Rashford, Martinez, Casemiro and Luke Shaw have all bee excellent. Bruno and Varane has also been great in spells.
Nice to have a few candidates for once. Rashford, Martinez, Casemiro and Luke Shaw have all bee excellent. Bruno and Varane has also been great in spells.
Like others have said, Rashford or Martinez. If there were a “most improved” prize, AWB.
Bruno Fernandes 
He plays game after game after game. He has created a ton of chances, probably one of the highest in the league.
With an able striker ahead of him, he would have been on crazy numbers and us too.
He plays game after game after game. He has created a ton of chances, probably one of the highest in the league.
With an able striker ahead of him, he would have been on crazy numbers and us too.
it's any one of Rashford, case and Martinez. With Bruno and Garnacho honourable mentions.
Finally a year that it`s not a easy choice with a solo candidate like De Gea or something.
Rashford, Shaw, Casemiro, Fernandes, Eriksen, Martinez deserves a mention but alot of players have stepped up this year.
Rashford, Shaw, Casemiro, Fernandes, Eriksen, Martinez deserves a mention but alot of players have stepped up this year.
Rashy, Casemiro or Licha for me
Isn't there a young player one or is it an academy one? I can remember he who must not be named winning it previously
Will be interesting who they pick for player's player - Case maybe?
Isn't there a young player one or is it an academy one? I can remember he who must not be named winning it previously
Will be interesting who they pick for player's player - Case maybe?
Rashford or Bruno for me. Both been absolutely key this season as they were the season before the CR7 show they proove to be again the season after the CR7 show.
Three absolutely outstanding candidates this season. The top three picks itself. It’s just the order to debate.
Personally I’d go
Rashford
Martinez
Casemiro
But could make an argument any way between the three.
Personally I’d go
Rashford
Martinez
Casemiro
But could make an argument any way between the three.
Casemiro, he can lift this team to another level
Rashford, best scorer
Rashford, best scorer
There’s still an important chunk of the season to go. From what we’ve seen so far:
- Casemiro
- Rashford
- Varane / Martínez
- Bruno
- Shaw
But you could probably mix that list into pretty much any order without much complaint from me.
- Casemiro
- Rashford
- Varane / Martínez
- Bruno
- Shaw
But you could probably mix that list into pretty much any order without much complaint from me.
Gotta be Rashford.
The polls will open today and the gala will be held at Old Trafford on 29 May.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Think it has to be Rashford for his goal contributions
I originally thought Rashford was a shoe in but the way we’ve struggled since Licha was injured shows how important he is to this team. Bruno another in the running. Shaw an outsider but deserves a mention.
Casemiro has fallen away due to suspensions and patchy recent form.
Casemiro has fallen away due to suspensions and patchy recent form.
I think it's gotta be Rashford really. I'd actually put Shaw second.
Then again I’d say we’ve also struggled in scoring goals even more than in defense, so without Rashford’s goals we’d probably be around where Chelsea are. If that.
Its refreshing to have a few players competing for this award. And none of them is out GK leading the golden glove standing.
Originally leant towards Cas but going for Licha. His absence in the team is obvious
Rashford will probably get it cause after the World Cup he has been a revelation. Casemiro was brilliant too but missed a few too many games. Martinez was a shoe in before injuries.
I honestly believe Shaw deserves it he has performed probably the most consistently all season whether it was centre back or left back and on many occasions was our best threat getting forward too when others had went of the boil.
I honestly believe Shaw deserves it he has performed probably the most consistently all season whether it was centre back or left back and on many occasions was our best threat getting forward too when others had went of the boil.
I want to vote for Wout because the caf is mean to him, but I'm not signing up. Sorry Wout.
Doubt they'll bother to become United members to get to vote. It's been done this way for a while and the winner's always been more or less the one who's deserved it.
If only Martinez wasn’t injured, he’d be my pick with RASHY a close second, Casemiro third.
My actual picks, Rashford, Casemiro and Shaw, Fernandes and Wan Bissaka 4th and 5th
My actual picks, Rashford, Casemiro and Shaw, Fernandes and Wan Bissaka 4th and 5th
Martinez I'm thinking will win it. Special mention to Shaw who's done well where ever he's played.
Rashford deserves it.
Martinez or Shaw for high level consistency.
Has to be Licha
Coudn't decide between Shaw and Martinez. Flipped a coin - so it's Licha.
Surely it would be Rashford
This is not a fan poll right?
Last edited:
Rashford will win but it should be Martinez. Only reason he won’t is because his injury is badly timed rather than anything else. Quite clearly been our most consistent player this year.
Bruno should be the automatic choice. Insane number of chances created.
Lisandro in my opinion. He's put everyone's predictions to shame and been both outstanding and our most consistent performer. I think he's been the best CB in the league.
Last edited: