Yeah a few people really overrate Danny's overall game while underrate sturridge's. Welbeck is just 'good' on the ball. Not excellent or whatever, he's not a great passer, just average. He's big, strong and fast, but he really has no idea how to use his body, and gets outmuscled easily and seems to run pretty slowly when it looks like a chance is on. He has terrible shooting technique, but he's got a pretty good touch. Those things just aren't enough really, he doesn't get you out of your seat when he has the ball, thinking he can do something. He doesn't have the ability really to beat players, or at least he doesn't really try to dribble past them very often (sort of like kagawa with this, always does a safe pass first).
I've always said we should've sent him on loan the minute we signed van Persie, because although he played a lot that season, it was all on the wing where he is useless because Rooney, Hernandez and van Persie were all clearly ahead of him as a striker. I don't think he'll ever fully develop at united because he's not good enough to take over as a main striker right now, and at united we always use world class forwards over the years, so when rvp and Rooney are past it, we'll probably look to buy a top class forward to replace them as I don't see us continuing to use 2 strikers consistently. He's a good player, but I think a team like Tottenham or Everton is his future level, not a title challenging team.