Do you reckon Aleix Vidal will come back strongly from his injury? He seemed to improve a lot before his long term absence if memory serves. When is he scheduled to come back? Semedo and Vidal could be two great options at right-back
I never liked his acquisition either as I saw him, like Turan, an election ploy signing. That being said, he was a mixed bag - better than Sergi Roberto in some aspects (Mostly in attack) but a particularly poor defender. I like his character and how hard he works but he's not Barca level at RB, for me. At best, he's a serviceable backup for us.
Valverde expects a lot defensively so we'll see how that impacts both Semedo & Vidal but the Catalan doesn't seem to have the requisite instincts of a defender. Like Bellerin, I get the impression he relies too much on his pace to bail him out of gambling for an interception or tackle. Neither seem to anticipate well enough while Semedo actually seems to be better in that department
Also, Vidal is already back as he was back for the Copa Del Rey Final - only two absences from first training today, Rafinha & Deulofeu