marktan
Full Member
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2017
- Messages
- 6,933
Scholes like, that pass. The way it speeds up and the suddenly drops.
Great record no doubt but that's because you have no other creative players so everything goes through him. He's more creative than any of your midfielders for a start. Scholes and Giggs were in more balanced sides.TAA is currently assisting at 1 assist every 3 games.
Giggs was 1 in 4, Gerrard was 1 in 5, Scholes was 1 in 9.
Wow!
More like Beckham.Is the closest replication of Dani Alves at Sevilla?
Yep. A great attacking fullback just adds a completely new dimension to any teams attack. I posted something in the AWB thread recently saying something along the lines of the attacking prowess of a fullback these days, is probably as important as his defensive ability (if not more!) at top clubs these days.Their full backs are ridiculous. That is the position that sets aside the top clubs imo. Full backs are the only position left that is defended 1 on1 so if they can capitalize on it, it really shows
Given that TAA is only ok defensively and still one of our best players, I'd say it's more important.Yep. A great attacking fullback just adds a completely new dimension to any teams attack. I posted something in the AWB thread recently saying something along the lines of the attacking prowess of a fullback these days, is probably as important as his defensive ability (if not more!) at top clubs these days.
Yeah, can’t disagree there. Seems a common theme at the clubs who are at the pinnacle of the European game - they have immensely talented attacking fullbacks.Given that TAA is only ok defensively and still one of our best players, I'd say it's more important.
I'd be curious to see how many crosses he puts into the box on average compared to Beckham in his heyday.
At Utd's height, you had Neville who was a phenomenal player. Having good full backs certainly isn't a new thing to help you win titles but the role of them has changed over the last few yearsYeah, can’t disagree there. Seems a common theme at the clubs who are at the pinnacle of the European game - they have immensely talented attacking fullbacks.
Yeah, agreed. I think there’s always been executional attacking fullbacks around - something the Brazilian NT has always been lauded for, as an example.At Utd's height, you had Neville who was a phenomenal player. Having good full backs certainly isn't a new thing to help you win titles but the role of them has changed over the last few years
Not sure it's right to say the general importance has increased. In my opinion, if a fullback is more effective offensively than most wingers that is to his credit only and doesn't change the importance of the role in it self. If you compare an attacking fullback to one who is not, their general importance will be decided by other factors like how they perform relevant to their team. You wouldn't devaluate a striker like Lewandowski due to his position because goalscoring wingers like Messi and Ronaldo are more important to their team. The expectation of the role role may be changing but regardless the value is only decided by what the player himself brings to the table. So to me anyway, it is often a moot point.Yeah, agreed. I think there’s always been executional attacking fullbacks around - something the Brazilian NT has always been lauded for, as an example.
So yeah, whilst it’s nothing new, I think maybe the importance has increased.
Has just become the most valuable defender in the world, according to transfermarkt.
1. Trent Alexander Arnold - 110M
2. Van Dijk - 100M
3. Robertson - 80M
4. De Ligt - 75M
5. Laporte - 75M
6. Koulibaly - 75M
7. Hernandez (Bayern Munich) - 70M
8. Gimenez (Atletico Madrid) - 70M
9. Kimmich - 70M
10. Varane - 70M
Not surprised in the slightest.Has just become the most valuable defender in the world, according to transfermarkt.
1. Trent Alexander Arnold - 110M
2. Van Dijk - 100M
3. Robertson - 80M
4. De Ligt - 75M
5. Laporte - 75M
6. Koulibaly - 75M
7. Hernandez (Bayern Munich) - 70M
8. Gimenez (Atletico Madrid) - 70M
9. Kimmich - 70M
10. Varane - 70M
Is the term ‘defender’ used in jest here?Has just become the most valuable defender in the world, according to transfermarkt.
1. Trent Alexander Arnold - 110M
Challenge acceptedThe best thing is he's a proper scouser. Nobody can buy him
Isn't he from Rainhill ?The best thing is he's a placky scouser. Nobody can buy him
A more accurate term nowadays, even for teams who play 4 at the back, would be wing back. Gary Neville, who was a very good full back in his day has said he couldn’t play the position in the modern game. At least as much emphasis on attacking as defending, and at the elite level, I would say attacking ability is more important - provided your defending isn’t at Titus Bramble level.Is the term ‘defender’ used in jest here?
surprised Pavard isn’t on that listHas just become the most valuable defender in the world, according to transfermarkt.
1. Trent Alexander Arnold - 110M
2. Van Dijk - 100M
3. Robertson - 80M
4. De Ligt - 75M
5. Laporte - 75M
6. Koulibaly - 75M
7. Hernandez (Bayern Munich) - 70M
8. Gimenez (Atletico Madrid) - 70M
9. Kimmich - 70M
10. Varane - 70M
Didn't SAF try to poach him when he was a kid?They're incredibly lucky that certain teams don't seem to be as big on poaching players like this any more. Surprised the likes of PSG aren't interested though?
I think what I meant was their general importance (wrt attacking qualities) seem to have increased. But I get what you’re saying.Not sure it's right to say the general importance has increased. In my opinion, if a fullback is more effective offensively than most wingers that is to his credit only and doesn't change the importance of the role in it self. If you compare an attacking fullback to one who is not, their general importance will be decided by other factors like how they perform relevant to their team. You wouldn't devaluate a striker like Lewandowski due to his position because goalscoring wingers like Messi and Ronaldo are more important to their team. The expectation of the role role may be changing but regardless the value is only decided by what the player himself brings to the table. So to me anyway, it is often a moot point.
On topic: He seems to have insane crossing abilities and composure out wide, huge talent but I didn't know he was rated as highly as he seems to be already.
Stevie Mcmanaman says hiThe best thing is he's a proper scouser. Nobody can buy him
I doubt TAA would even want to move to PSG.They're incredibly lucky that certain teams don't seem to be as big on poaching players like this any more. Surprised the likes of PSG aren't interested though?
Possibly not, but I’m sure there’s a few things that could be tempting about it.I doubt TAA would even want to move to PSG.
McMoneyman went for the payoff. Luckiky we're a much better run club these days and can give the likes of TAA the contracts he deserves.Stevie Mcmanaman says hi
Maybe they are, but they know he is unattainable.They're incredibly lucky that certain teams don't seem to be as big on poaching players like this any more. Surprised the likes of PSG aren't interested though?
He would be crazy to want to move at present.Maybe they are, but they know he is unattainable.
Particularly at Liverpool. Tactically, they rely on their fullbacks to be their creative outlet. The likes of Henderson, Wijnaldum, Fabinho etc are there to crowd the middle, suffocate teams and then get the ball out wide to the wingbacks who should have a bit of space.Yeah, agreed. I think there’s always been executional attacking fullbacks around - something the Brazilian NT has always been lauded for, as an example.
So yeah, whilst it’s nothing new, I think maybe the importance has increased.
Lots and lots of cash, living somewhere new and interesting, new challenge. Plenty of reasons he might. He seems pretty dedicated to Liverpool of course. A few might fancy something new if they win the league.Why would he want a backwards move to PSG?
100% this. And both their fullbacks have great deliveries into the box - with a clinical strikeforce. It makes the world of difference.Particularly at Liverpool. Tactically, they rely on their fullbacks to be their creative outlet. The likes of Henderson, Wijnaldum, Fabinho etc are there to crowd the middle, suffocate teams and then get the ball out wide to the wingbacks who should have a bit of space.
Unless he wants to cash out then only Real and Barca can offer him something Liverpool can't at the moment.Lots and lots of cash, living somewhere new and interesting, new challenge. Plenty of reasons he might. He seems pretty dedicated to Liverpool of course. A few might fancy something new if they win the league.
Yeah that's a decent shout. He's really important to Liverpool on the right so I don't buy the common pundit view that he's too good to play at full-back, which tends to be informed by how the game worked in the 1980s. But you can see the specific quality gap in the England midfield that is precisely what he could potentially bring to the table.I can see why he plays RB for Liverpool but England should really consider playing him in midfield. They’ve got a lot of options at RB but no-one in midfield who can pass like he can.