DJ_21
Evens winner of 'Odds or Evens 2022/2023'
Who’s gonna vote to keep it then? VAR isn’t the problem. It’s the people using it. Works fine in other countries. We need extra training for our refs.
Don’t you think that the majority of the controversial incidents are subjective fouls? I’m not really sure how it’s possible to give better training and expect everyone to be happy.People will be up in arms the second an obvious decision goes against them.
It’s a good system used poorly by refs. It’s that that needs the reform, not scrapping VAR.
This 100%People will be up in arms the second an obvious decision goes against them.
It’s a good system used poorly by refs. It’s that that needs the reform, not scrapping VAR.
What people continually fail to realise that VAR is literally just a ref watching tv. You can’t say that VAR is not a problem, it’s the refs. They’re one and the same thing.VAR was never suitable to football and I’ve said that from minute one. People still double down on the whole “it’s the people behind it” they are part of the issue, but the bigger issue is that VAR doesn’t and never will fit in a game as free flowing as football especially with so many subjective calls. I hope to the lord above that they scrap it once and for all and we will bd one step closer to having the game I fell in love with back. City will be one club that won’t agree though as they get so many calls. I hope Utd vote the right way, it’s been absolutely nightmarish for us.
Be careful what you wish for.Hopefully get rid.
You could give them 5 years of training and they would still be absolutely rubbish. Wolves are even more stupid to think this is the solution.There's nothing wrong with the tech, it's the referees. I wouldn't mind scrapping it for a year though, get them properly trained with the systems and then bringing it back in a better state.
Automatic offsides are coming to the PL in December i think.Just limit it to offsides and make the offside rule more distinct and obvious - eg. one boot clear of the defender
Sure but the whole point is if the refs are crap (which they are) then VAR just adds to the issue. VAR fundamentally changes the game, slows down decisions, stops celebrations, over analyses situations and if they can’t even reach the correct decision then what’s the point in accepting all of that. What people have always failed to realise though is that VAR was never going to fix enough issues to be worth those trade offs. There’s too many subjective calls and I’d far rather get some wrong decisions in real time than getting them after all this garbage slow down analysis. At least you can accept real time human error.What people continually fail to realise that VAR is literally just a ref watching tv. You can’t say that VAR is not a problem, it’s the refs. They’re one and the same thing.
Life was fine without itBe careful what you wish for.
Emmm constant moaning about decisions on here and on every single football show, when the replay showed something other than what the ref called, says different.Life was fine without it
A lot of them are yeah. I still think it is very useful for big offsides or fouls missed when goals are scored.Don’t you think that the majority of the controversial incidents are subjective fouls? I’m not really sure how it’s possible to give better training and expect everyone to be happy.
It’s worth trying manager challenges. Each team gets one per game. It can only be used on offsides or fouls in the box. The referee has to go over to the monitor and look himself and doesn’t get any advice from VAR on whether it’s a foul or not.
Do people actually sit there refusing to celebrate just in case VAR intervenes?Feck VAR. It's destroying a lot of what i enjoy about football. So what if we get the occasional decision against us? These days you can barely celebrate a goal before seeing if it will be allowed or not. Fecking bullshit, get out.
We already know how that feels with that Drogba goal.A lot of them are yeah. I still think it is very useful for big offsides or fouls missed when goals are scored.
Imagine we scrap it and we lose a game due to a blatantly offside goal next season. Knowing with VAR we’d have not let that goal in would be very frustrating.
Who said refuse? I always celebrate but there's always the thought in the back of my mind thinking i hope it stands.Do people actually sit there refusing to celebrate just in case VAR intervenes?
We still have that happening now. The only difference is it takes the refs 3 minutes to get to the wrong decision.Emmm constant moaning about decisions on here and on every single football show, when the replay showed something other than what the ref called, says different.
The way people give out about it's like they can't bring themselves to celebrate. I honestly don't even think about it unless they signal it's going to be reviewed or clearly looks dodgy.Who said refuse? I always celebrate but there's always the thought in the back of my mind thinking i hope it stands.
So life wasn't fine without it then? Which was the point.We still have that happening now. The only difference is it takes the refs 3 minutes to get to the wrong decision.
Managers, fans, and pundits won't do that.Scrap it. Keep hawk eye and develop a technology which can see whether or not there’s an offside in real time (I think UEFA are trialling this but could be wrong).
We need to stop trying to create the ‘perfect’ game where all decisions are made correctly. Just let there be an understanding that referees will make mistakes, sometimes terrible ones, but they’re human and just trying to do a job.
Life was less shit without it.So life wasn't fine without it then? Which was the point.
Life? Come on nowLife was less shit without it.