We are an awfully coached team

GueRed

Full Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
2,898
Location
London
The last two years under Ole have overall very been disappointing to say the least

A lot of performances the team looks like a bunch of strangers thrown together for the first time!

that comes down to the coaching.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,790
The last two years under Ole have overall very been disappointing to say the least

A lot of performances the team looks like a bunch of strangers thrown together for the first time!

that comes down to the coaching.
Yeah you have absolutely nailed it
 

elmo

Can never have too many Eevees
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
13,402
Location
AKA: Slapanut Goat Smuggla
RB Leipzig's players aren't nearly the same quality as ours and they look 50x the team. Please stop with this nonsense. The guy needs to go, but he won't cause there is enough support from fans who will go over the top in comeback wins against West Ham etc.

I've said it before, people need to really assess if any of these wins etc. are sustainable and actual signs of progress. We don't look any different or better a team since he came in.
You're telling this to people who thinks we've a lousier starting eleven than Leicester last season.
Ole fanboys are beyond hope, they only believe what they want to believe.

Apart from getting fitter and stronger, our players are basically the same or gotten worse since Ole took over.
 

Mingus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
159
You're telling this to people who thinks we've a lousier starting eleven than Leicester last season.
Leicester didn't have the Europa league draining their squad resources though.

Leipzig and Leicester's players (and managers) aren't under the same scrutiny as they would be at Utd.
 
Last edited:

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
I don't mind starting with defensive setup. But for ffs then defend and deny the opposition space.
Everyone knew that they have to score. Then why on Earth did he start with Greenwood?
Why on Earth did he get Greenwood and Rashford to press them early?
Just sit back and deny the space in our own half and let them play in their own half. A football game is won not only in the first half.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,790
I don't mind starting with defensive setup. But for ffs then defend and deny the opposition space.
Everyone knew that they have to score. Then why on Earth did he start with Greenwood?
Why on Earth did he get Greenwood and Rashford to press them early?
Just sit back and deny the space in our own half and let them play in their own half. A football game is won not only in the first half.
Yeah if we are going to start defensive then at least be looking to bring in a coach who understands how to defend properly
 

Fridge chutney

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
8,961
Could happen if Ole accepts the coaching around him is not up to the required standard
Yes fair. We also need more balance in midfield and on the right side of the pitch. I have faith and will reassess at the end of the season.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,790
Yes fair. We also need more balance in midfield and on the right side of the pitch. I have faith and will reassess at the end of the season.
He needs to be bringing them before the end of the season,think it's the only way we can actually stop conceding sloppy goals all the time
 

Guapa

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
733
Ole's out of his depth.Love the guy but it's past time to move on.
 

sunama

Baghdad Bob
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
16,839
Most points in the league in 2020. Hopefully we continue to improve.
That's because of Bruno - we basically bought arguably, the best player on the planet and he is single handedly forcing us to score goals.
When he gets marked out of the game, we lose.
Before Bruno joined us, in 2019, we were in the doldrums.
Ole should not be allowed to continue, just because he got lucky with Bruno. If Bruno gets injured, we'll stop scoring points and Ole will be sacked.
 

sunama

Baghdad Bob
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
16,839
what was it you were saying?
Trust in defence? There is none and thats why hes played 7 tonight
He tried to park the bus, but he sucked at that, too.
He relies purely on individual skill of players to score goals and his No.1 tactic: get the ball to Bruno and hope he can do something special.
 

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
He tried to park the bus, but he sucked at that, too.
He relies purely on individual skill of players to score goals and his No.1 tactic: get the ball to Bruno and hope he can do something special.
He tried to park the bus but forgot to put the brakes on.
 

Mingus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
159
That's because of Bruno - we basically bought arguably, the best player on the planet and he is single handedly forcing us to score goals.
When he gets marked out of the game, we lose.
Before Bruno joined us, in 2019, we were in the doldrums.
Ole should not be allowed to continue, just because he got lucky with Bruno. If Bruno gets injured, we'll stop scoring points and Ole will be sacked.
Yes Ole must be punished for securing an immediately effective creative midfielder to complement our previous ability to play counter attack effectively.

Most league points since Bruno joined? How can Ole be allowed to continue!!!??
 

Fridge chutney

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
8,961
That's because of Bruno - we basically bought arguably, the best player on the planet and he is single handedly forcing us to score goals.
When he gets marked out of the game, we lose.
Before Bruno joined us, in 2019, we were in the doldrums.
Ole should not be allowed to continue, just because he got lucky with Bruno. If Bruno gets injured, we'll stop scoring points and Ole will be sacked.
Yes, remove our best players and we get worse. Who would have thought.
 

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
4,038
Location
Kami's Lookout
Supports
Ralf Rangnick.
Yes, remove our best players and we get worse. Who would have thought.
How condescending.

Do you not remember the first leg with PSG 2018/19, or countless others pre Bruno?

At the highest level, we saw the exact same limitations in Ole's system, when we had Pogba playing the talisman role for us before Bruno.

Your whole system cannot be dependant on a single player, and if that one player is removed/nullified, your system then immediately falls apart.

That was why we bought Bruno and VDB to a lesser extent. To reduce the creative burden from Pogba. So teams couldn't beat us, just by man marking Pogba out of the game.

How can you not see the writing on the wall here?
 
Last edited:

el3mel

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
43,735
Location
Egypt
Yes, remove our best players and we get worse. Who would have thought.
If you collapse whenever your best player leaves the pitch, then you are either a terrible one man team or your manager can't adapt his style to work without this best player. All teams in the world lose their best players or have them in off form for some periods every season. No team plays the full season without at least one major injury. All managers have to adapt to that, really.
 

el3mel

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
43,735
Location
Egypt
Yes Ole must be punished for securing an immediately effective creative midfielder to complement our previous ability to play counter attack effectively.

Most league points since Bruno joined? How can Ole be allowed to continue!!!??
Is this some kind of trophy we won? Because it seems to be mentioned a lot lately.

I swear some things said here if they were said on RAWK, Blue moon, Arsenal Mania, or literally any other rival clubs forum, we would be laughing our arse off on them.
 

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
4,038
Location
Kami's Lookout
Supports
Ralf Rangnick.
If you collapse whenever your best player leaves the pitch, then you are either a terrible one man team or your manager can't adapt his style to work without this best player. All teams in the world lose their best players or have them in off form for some periods every season. No team plays the full season without at least one major injury. All managers have to adapt to that, really.
Ole hasn't changed anything in two years. All he's done is swap Pogba for Bruno, whilst retaining the exact same weaknesses/over reliance on one player.

Which we already know is found out at the highest level. Which was the whole point why we got Bruno & VDB in the first place.

We used to pray for Pogba to carry us every match. Now we pray for Bruno to be able to do the same.

Progress.
 
Last edited:

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,790
Ole hasn't changed anything in two years. All he's done is swap Pogba for Bruno, whilst retaining the exact same weaknesses/over reliance on one player.

Which we already know is found out at the highest level. Which was the whole point why we got Bruno & VDB in the first place.

We used to pray for Pogba to carry us every match. Now we pray for Bruno to be able to do the same.

Progress.
Yeah there is no doubt that we are far too reliant on Bruno and the only way that changes is by either bringing in another creator or just simply playing Donny regularly once Pogba has gone
 

Mingus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
159
Is this some kind of trophy we won? Because it seems to be mentioned a lot lately.

I swear some things said here if they were said on RAWK, Blue moon, Arsenal Mania, or literally any other rival clubs forum, we would be laughing our arse off on them.
Did you you seriously expect us to win trophies last season? A season we started off with inadequate signings and rescued from complete failure with the acquisition of Fernandes.

Most pundits thought that we were a few seasons away from being competitive and despite a poor start in the PL we were 2 points behind Liverpool until they won their extra game. At this stage last season we were 18 points behind Liverpool after 11 games. Is that not a sign of progress?

Knee jerk reactions after a CL exit from a group that had a semi finalist and a finalist from last season (both of who we beat once) are unrealistic. We were undone by the necessary gamble to rest players for the Istanbul game.

There's going to be setbacks until recruitment brings balance. Especially when the Covid circumstances mean a tight schedule with a small group of trusted players.
 

Greck

Full Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2016
Messages
7,099
Did you you seriously expect us to win trophies last season? A season we started off with inadequate signings and rescued from complete failure with the acquisition of Fernandes.

Most pundits thought that we were a few seasons away from being competitive and despite a poor start in the PL we were 2 points behind Liverpool until they won their extra game. At this stage last season we were 18 points behind Liverpool after 11 games. Is that not a sign of progress?

Knee jerk reactions after a CL exit from a group that had a semi finalist and a finalist from last season (both of who we beat once) are unrealistic. We were undone by the necessary gamble to rest players for the Istanbul game.

There's going to be setbacks until recruitment brings balance. Especially when the Covid circumstances mean a tight schedule with a small group of trusted players.
150m is inadequate to expect a domestic cup? Here's the thing, Ole is the only United manager that hasn't won a cup, not even a mickey mouse cup. Even Moyes won the community shield. Don't expect a title challenge Ole simply has to win the carabao cup or FA cup this season or he'll easily overtake Moyes as our worst manager. It's only december so it hasnt dawned on people Ole is about to become the first manager to see out consecutive trophyless seasons here since SAF
 

Mingus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
159
150m is inadequate to expect a domestic cup? Here's the thing, Ole is the only United manager that hasn't won a cup, not even a mickey mouse cup. Even Moyes won the community shield. Don't expect a title challenge Ole simply has to win the carabao cup or FA cup this season or he'll easily overtake Moyes as our worst manager. It's only december so it hasnt dawned on people Ole is about to become the first manager to see out consecutive trophyless seasons here since SAF
Sir Alex joined in 1986 and his first trophy was in 1990.
 

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
Sir Alex joined in 1986 and his first trophy was in 1990.
Sir Alex had already won the European Cup Winners Cup and also won the Scottish League a few times along with the Cups. This is not some Mickey mouse league in Scandinavia, especially those days when Scottish football was something.
 

Foxbatt

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2013
Messages
14,297
Wish we took this into account when we fired Moyes. Should have been given the full 5 years to become SAF MKII
That is still what he is claiming. He never thought he would be sacked after 9 months. He feels he would have been SAF MKII if he was given the 5 years. We would have become Everton if that has happened and now in danger of becoming Molde.
 

Josep Dowling

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
7,661
RB Leipzig's players aren't nearly the same quality as ours and they look 50x the team. Please stop with this nonsense. The guy needs to go, but he won't cause there is enough support from fans who will go over the top in comeback wins against West Ham etc.

I've said it before, people need to really assess if any of these wins etc. are sustainable and actual signs of progress. We don't look any different or better a team since he came in.
What about the fact the lost 5-0 in the reverse fixture to the terribly coached team? I don’t think Ole is a great manager but you can’t make comments like that when United hammered them at Old Trafford.
 

GiddyUp

Full Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2015
Messages
4,913
Sir Alex joined in 1986 and his first trophy was in 1990.
You do know United wasn't his first gig. SAF was afford time because of his previous exploits and he was also trying to eradicate a corrosive drinking culture within the squad, refresh a failing team and wake a sleeping giant. Totally different situations so please don't ever compare both managers. It's like comparing Sugar Ray Leonard to Jimmy Smith.
 

Lentwood

Full Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
6,840
Location
West Didsbury, Manchester
It would be interesting to have some kind of poll on Redcafe with the below options.

Utd have overachieved under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad

Utd have achieved par under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad

Utd have underachieved under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad.

I personally would vote for a) overachieved currently, based on last years’ league position and the average age/ability of the players who took the field for us.

This year, I would say par is 4th again, albeit would be nice if it was at least a comfortable 4th and not come down to the last game or two.

In addition, it would be interesting to see how posters would vote given the below options

Utd have a fantastic squad/poor manager

Utd have a good squad/poor manager

Utd have an average squad/poor manager

Utd have a poor squad/poor manager

Then rinse repeat but swap “poor manager” for “average manager”, “good manager” and “fantastic manager”

Again, personally I would vote for “good squad, good manager” if asked right now, based on last season’s 3rd place finish and our start to this season
 

monosierra

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
Messages
374
I would love to see a behind the scene walkthrough of our player development, drills, coaching, fitness training, tactical discussions - the daily grind that makes and breaks teams. We only really have a direct view of the end product and glimpses of training sessions. How does United's regime compare to other clubs that are playing better football? Are our coaching sessions more simplistic and less sophiscated in terms of technique and chemistry? How are we developing relatively raw players into polished diamonds? How are we improving the team's discipline, positioning, and link-ups?
 

Polar

Full Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2020
Messages
1,424
Sounds like it’s easy to establish a new system or some kind of new way to play football. Real Madrid, Barcelona, Ajax, Bayern have played the same forball for ages. They only recruit coaches, players who fit into the system, also on the younger teams.

Things were fine under Fergie, but the new coaches abandoned our identity and tried to create their own system, which probably wasn’t a strategy for the entire club.

A big part of our identity; way to play fotball (system) under Fergie, is gone because of seven years with negligence. Off course it takes time to repair and rebuild the system.
 

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
4,038
Location
Kami's Lookout
Supports
Ralf Rangnick.
Yeah there is no doubt that we are far too reliant on Bruno and the only way that changes is by either bringing in another creator or just simply playing Donny regularly once Pogba has gone
What's stopping him from playing DVB/Pogba alongside Bruno now? After 2 years, we're still the same team as the first day he walked in. He hasn't got a clue. There's no chance of anything changing under Ole sadly.
 

KcB32

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 14, 2016
Messages
43
What's stopping him from playing DVB/Pogba alongside Bruno now? After 2 years, we're still the same team as the first day he walked in. He hasn't got a clue. There's no chance of anything changing under Ole sadly.
This is what's so frustrating. Between Bruno, Pogba, and DVB, we should have the best midfield in the world, but our tactically inept manager simply cannot figure it out.
And it's not only the team selection, it's the way they're setup. We are constantly overrun in the middle third because Bruno is too high up the pitch and whoever is playing DM is nearly in line with the CBs.
 

Hugh Jass

Shave Dass
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
11,301
I am still leaning on keeping Ole, but i have been saying this for a while. We rely on individual brilliance rather than collective brilliance.

Especially through Bruno.
 

OleTheGreat

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2019
Messages
816
Location
Bangalore, India
This has not been the problem only with Ole, this is a problem because of the players that were accumulated by Moyes, LvG, and Jose. They bought players that suited their systems and every other manager had to adjust formations to suit the players but sadly the squad we have does not suit any single formation because of the lack of proper players for proper positions. We still don't have natural wingers or a proper number 9. I always thought Rashford was supposed to be a proper number 9 but he's played on the wing. Martial was a striker before he arrived and until recently under Ole, he's been played on the left. Mata is a number 10 but often played on the right. Greenwood is a striker but is played on the right. I understand that players these days can play anywhere in the frontline and adapt to it but they grow up playing in a certain position and the traits to that position will be instilled in them which will be disrupted when they have to go to another position and fill the void. The same applies to the midfield as well- Pogba, VDB, Fred, and Bruno are all forward-thinking midfielders who like to play in front of a strong defensive midfielder who can tackle, win the ball and play it to their feet but we play Pogba, Fred, and VDB in a double pivot. Matic is a number 6 who likes to be that guy who wins the ball and plays it to one of the number 8s. Mctominay can play the same role but instead, we play the double pivot to protect our defense. Our defensive players are shaky as it is because we don't press successfully in games involving Pogba, VDB, or McFred. The issues with De Gea are not just his fault because generally, United keepers have very little to do in the years under SAF.

One more thing I want to say, although this thought might not be welcomed by many. SAF had a few years before he started winning trophies. He had a topsy turvy first few years where he finished 2nd, 11th, 6th, and some sort. Do not fixate on those details because I'm not 100% sure how accurate they are but I'm somewhere close. All I'm trying to say is, Ole needs one or two more BACKED windows to actually sign players to play the system he wants. If we decide to change managers again, we'll have to wait for a long time for him to put together a team of his style.

Pep was completely backed and yet hasn't won the UCL with City yet which frankly is shocking. Klopp has done a wonderful job with Liverpool but even he had enough time to impose his style on the squad. If you actually check Klopp's team when he got to Liverpool, it had a lot of deadwood but he managed to get them out and get the players he wants. Ole has done the same, he has seen all that the fans have seen, he got rid of the deadwood in our squad (Fellaini, Blind, Darmian, Sanchez, Lukaku, Valencia, Young, Perriera) which is exactly what we wanted our manager to do. Now he needs the backing of the board to buy the players he wants in order to fit the system he wants them to play.

I for one understand the inconsistencies of this squad because it is a new formation every match and a new set of players every game which is hard. If you remember the end of last season after the lockdown, we were confident and consistent because we played the same team week in week out and they started learning each others' moves, and also we loved the addition of Bruno to the team. He's the type of player we should bring in every window. A confident leader in a position to ask more of the players around him. Ole is not the problem here, he needs time and no other manager can do more with this squad than he has. No amount of coaching will change this, we need better players for the system and stick with a manager, and only then will it work. I ask all United fan buddies to be patient with Ole but not with Ed or the owners because they are nothing but a bunch of money hogging idiots running the club to the ground.
 
Last edited:

OleTheGreat

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2019
Messages
816
Location
Bangalore, India
We have been the best coached under LVG
We had a clear pattern of play and every player had a job and knew what job it was. Should not be sacked after winning the FA cup.
You are kidding, right? LvG made us play the most awful football ever. We should've sacked him much earlier than we actually did.
 

jamesjimmybyrondean

Full Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2019
Messages
7,093
It would be interesting to have some kind of poll on Redcafe with the below options.

Utd have overachieved under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad

Utd have achieved par under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad

Utd have underachieved under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad.

I personally would vote for a) overachieved currently, based on last years’ league position and the average age/ability of the players who took the field for us.

This year, I would say par is 4th again, albeit would be nice if it was at least a comfortable 4th and not come down to the last game or two.

In addition, it would be interesting to see how posters would vote given the below options

Utd have a fantastic squad/poor manager

Utd have a good squad/poor manager

Utd have an average squad/poor manager

Utd have a poor squad/poor manager

Then rinse repeat but swap “poor manager” for “average manager”, “good manager” and “fantastic manager”

Again, personally I would vote for “good squad, good manager” if asked right now, based on last season’s 3rd place finish and our start to this season
I don't understand how you can say we overachieved last season. We can divide last season into pre Bruno and post Bruno. Before Bruno came the ability of the squad was questionable given we had some injuries at certain periods at that time. And what happened? We were absolute rubbish and during that time Ole was rumoured to be sacked on two separate occasions.

Then move on to post Bruno, that's when our season turned around. And during this period, the only tough opponents we faced that was better than us was City. I remember clearly post restart everybody looking at Leceister and United's fixtures and people saying we have the ability to turn things around. That's what happened. We didn't overachieve, we turned our season around.

Last season was the combination of a first half where we had an average team and performed shit and a second half where we had a strong team and performed on par. Maybe this has skewed some people's opinion that we over achieved
 
Last edited:

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
4,038
Location
Kami's Lookout
Supports
Ralf Rangnick.
Utd have overachieved under Ole, taking into account the ability of the squad

I personally would vote for a) overachieved currently, based on last years’ league position and the average age/ability of the players who took the field for us.
I don't know what season you watched. We spent the majority of last season threatening to break our all-time worst records:
  • Our start of 9 points from the first 7 league games was our lowest record for 30 years (since 1989-90 season).
  • By October 3rd 2019; Our run of 10 matches without an away win (D4 L6), was our longest run without an away win across all comps for 30 years. – We last went on a longer winless run on the road between February and September 1989 (run of 11).
  • By January 24th 2020; We was 5th on 34 pts., which was the same as Wolves in 7th. A return of 34 pts. from 24 games was our lowest again for 30 years since (1989-1990), when we ended up finishing 13th.
  • 34 pts after 24 matches, was six points fewer after the same number of games than we had under David Moyes in 2013-14 and Louis van Gaal in 2015-16.
  • At that point Solskjaer had the worst points-per-game ratio (1.64) than any of the others post-SAF, with Mourinho on 1.89, Van Gaal on 1.79 and Moyes on 1.68. Solskjaer had won 49.2% of games as United manager, which was the worst ratio of anyone in the Old Trafford dugout for 30 years since Dave Sexton (40.3) between August 1977 and April 1981.
  • Since GW6 (22nd September 2019), we were no higher than 5th in the league until GW 37.
  • Then Bruno came in and carried us on his back to top 4, but let's not act like it was a successful season.
  • We made Top 4 for the first time last season in GW 37 (22nd July).
  • We then confirmed it vs. Leicester on the final day of the season (26 July).
  • We finished on 66 points. That would not have been enough for Top 4 in the last 5/6 seasons. - We finished 6th on 69 points back in Mourinho's 1st season (16/17).
To compare Ole's PL record overall with Mourinho's, he is 1 loss away from totaling Mourinho's record in 24 fewer matches (16 in 69 vs. 17 in 93).
Overall Ole's points per game is lower than Mourinho's too (1.81 ppg in 69 vs. 1.89 ppg in 93).

If you're not being results orientated, how can you not say last season was anything other than shocking?
 
Last edited: