JohnnyKills
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2016
- Messages
- 7,099
???You're acting like you're a board member it doesn't matter what route you wanted to go down.
???You're acting like you're a board member it doesn't matter what route you wanted to go down.
Speak for yourself palWhat a bizarre post. Nothing we say on here actually matters babe, we all know that.
Think it we had Pep we would win, because him and his staff would have brought in the right players and to keep Pep you have to spend. Not sure even Ed would want to pick a fight with as talented a coach as Pep. Ole is the perfect manager for him, will try to do his best with what he has. I just wish we had got him before Jose. He would have brought Dias in.Nobody is close to Pep in my opinion. But it's stupid to say things like we would have definitely won with him in charge.
I was talking about this game and people talking in certainties.Think it we had Pep we would win, because him and his staff would have brought in the right players and to keep Pep you have to spend. Not sure even Ed would want to pick a fight with as talented a coach as Pep. Ole is the perfect manager for him, will try to do his best with what he has. I just wish we had got him before Jose. He would have brought Dias in.
See what you mean. No chance while Pep is at City.I was talking about this game and people talking in certainties.
We'd win the league with Pep but we're unlikely to challenge City while he's there with an unlimited cheque book.
Pep is probably in the top 5 of greatest managers of all time. Ole, well isn't. I don't think it would be too much of an exaggeration to think if Pep was managing us we'd be playing well on a much more consistent basis due to the difference in coaching. Every City player knows their role in the team, how to triangulate, how to make space for themselves, how to attack/defend as a team, when to press, when to let the opponent have the ball while we're still too dependent on individual players pulling us out of the fire. When Ole/the team get it right we can be a joy to watch but finding that level of consistency is the difference between good managers and great ones.Nobody is close to Pep in my opinion. But it's stupid to say things like we would have definitely won with him in charge.
Which for me is a big mistake. Ole is one of our own but comparing him to managers such as Pep, Klopp or SAF is setting him up to fail.Don’t people compare Ole with those guys all the time? It’s fine to compare him with them to put him down but not to defend him. Is how it looks to me.
I'd question the timing but I think it would be a step in the right direction overallThis game has summed up all my issues with the coaching team. No clear pattern of play, odd team selections, subs being made far too late into the game.
Also, we have been far too patchy under Ole, it's rather worrying.
Because you need time. As a manger you need time. People in here love to put Klopp to the clouds but don't mention that he needed 4-5 (!) years to bring some trophy to Liverpool. Managers need time. 2 season making a team in ManUtd and 3rd season showing full capacity.Why next season and not the 2.5 years that has gone? What do you expect him to do differently that he has not done for the past two years? So going by your standards we should have given the likes of Moyes 4 years as well before we can start expecting something?
Then you don't need to worry yet. We are 2nd and we will be top 4. I predicted top 3.Title? Feck, I am talking about top 4.
ThisWe aren’t an awfully coached team at all. The team on the pitch is the result of our awful recruitment and contracts. Why are we stuck playing 3 strikers as an attack? Why don’t we even have one creative player in the front line, Why are we relying on Cavani when we already had 4/500k a week worth of supposed top quality strikers at our disposal? Why was martial made untouchable when Jose wanted him gone? It’s the owners leaving a weird squad and never fully following through to fix our glaring weaknesses. They’ll stop martial from being sold but they won’t sign a right winger or a proper young striker. What even is that? It’ll no doubt be more of the same this summer.
That sums it up in a nutshell. What other big team would do this? A novice manager at the top level could survive with proper experienced coaches around him. An experienced manager at the top level could survive blooding in inexperienced coaches, but a novice manager and novice coaches are bound to fail at the top level, admittedly we do have Phelan. We already tried going down this route after Fergie and we all know how that ended.You see players making the same moves, passes and mistakes in every game, this has to be down to coaching levels or the players are either not capable of understanding what is required or do not have the required skill level to execute what the coaches expect of them.
Looking at the squad I would say it is clearly down to the coaching staff, as I have said before our coaches do not have the level of experience to develop a team or playing systems to take us to the next level.
At this level you cannot have coaches learning on the job as we have in Carrick and Fletcher, plus I believe that we have a manager who has taken the team as far as he can, however, I cannot see him leaving anytime soon and if that is the case then we need to improve the quality of our coaching staff to work with him.
As I said Fred and Scottie are the proverbial water carriers, hard working and lots of energy, who should be doing the donkey work for a magician in midfield. Trouble with that is you really only need one of them along with that magician and a quality DM. Ole is convinced he can turn them into the ultimate DM's.This
We don't have a single winger in the team and play with 3 strikers. We need players with craft and guile in the team and that includes the midfield where we're seeing Fred and McTominay playing games and both are average on the ball. Our CB pairing is also a issue.
For our team to function consistently, we need players like Grealish in the team to add to the likes of Fernandes and Pogba who are both our best players imo. Goals and assists will come as long as the build up phase is of a high level. But sadly our transitions are not of the requisite level and some players are performing very poorly but get credited due to getting a number of G/A's but those same players are contributing very poorly in the build up phase hence we look clueless against teams who defend in numbers. How can we play attacking football consistently when some of our players regularly fail in the build up phase. I'll be honest, the only player I enjoy watching play at the club is Hannibal Mejbri and that's in the 23s.
Solskjaer's doing fine right now and is on course to finish in the top 4, which is what I expected at the start of the season.
The most prolific front 3 in the league last season? With an additional world-class striker? Do you think all 4 have collectively decided to be shit this season, just for the heck of it?It’s weird how everyone universally acknowledges that 2 or 3 real quality signings is what got Liverpool over the line from challenging to dominating. Our recruitment has been way off for years and Ole has us close(ish) while going into the season with Rashford Martial Greenwood and Cavani as our strikers/wingers. Not an ounce of creativity there and it should have been addressed last summer but it never is
Crowd Bruno out and sit deep and it makes our team look like Fergie’s teams of old when we were desperately chasing at the end of games.we just keep pumping it direct and throw on as many attackers as possible to try and knick it but we are almost doing this from the start of games now and taking creativity from the midfield to compensate. endlessly going through the motions with 3 strikers and Bruno all cancelling each other out, standing around waiting for Bruno to bail us out. We created the worse chances of the 2 teams today despite all our pressure. We don’t really have gears to go up or you would have seen them today. We had them penned back for the whole game and then nothing...This
We don't have a single winger in the team and play with 3 strikers. We need players with craft and guile in the team and that includes the midfield where we're seeing Fred and McTominay playing games and both are average on the ball. Our CB pairing is also a issue.
For our team to function consistently, we need players like Grealish in the team to add to the likes of Fernandes and Pogba who are both our best players imo. Goals and assists will come as long as the build up phase is of a high level. But sadly our transitions are not of the requisite level and some players are performing very poorly but get credited due to getting a number of G/A's but those same players are contributing very poorly in the build up phase hence we look clueless against teams who defend in numbers. How can we play attacking football consistently when some of our players regularly fail in the build up phase. I'll be honest, the only player I enjoy watching play at the club is Hannibal Mejbri and that's in the 23s.
Solskjaer's doing fine right now and is on course to finish in the top 4, which is what I expected at the start of the season.
The guys had the perfect managerial seat and he’s five seasons in, has 2 PL and an FA cup plus some Coca Cola cups. He’s hardly dominated the league. Pep is clearly a top manager but Conte and Klopp have both shown two very different styles which were good enough to win the league.I was talking about this game and people talking in certainties.
We'd win the league with Pep but we're unlikely to challenge City while he's there with an unlimited cheque book.
honestly I feel like that end to the season was an anomaly. Who did we play that was a tricky opponent? Spurs- draw. Leicester, scrappy game with Kasper mistake sealing it. We choked and played well within ourselves through out most of the run in and if we were actually that good we should have beat Sevilla and destroyed Copenhagen. I’d say they couldn’t believe their luck at what showed up. They were way overhyped on the back of that scrappy run. Where would Ole, Rashford or Martial be if Bruno hadn’t come in or Greenwood hadn’t stepped up. Fine fine margins. The sloppy play at the end of the season just continued into this season and we haven’t been able to kick on and Cavani was never going to enough. We are lucky he’s even done as well as he has. Seems like the owners thought we were good enough to rest on our laurels anyway...The most prolific front 3 in the league last season? With an additional world-class striker? Do you think all 4 have collectively decided to be shit this season, just for the heck of it?
If Bruno has come in we wouldn't have been anywhere near Top 4.honestly I feel like that end to the season was an anomaly. Who did we play that was a tricky opponent? Spurs- draw. Leicester, scrappy game with Kasper mistake sealing it. Where would Ole, Rashford or Martial be if Bruno hadn’t come in or Greenwood hadn’t stepped up. Fine fine margins.
This is his 5th season, about to win his 3rd PL, didn't win it in his first and took a freak season from Liverpool to beat them last.The guys had the perfect managerial seat and he’s five seasons in, has 2 PL and an FA cup plus some Coca Cola cups. He’s hardly dominated the league. Pep is clearly a top manager but Conte and Klopp have both shown two very different styles which were good enough to win the league.
Pep will always have a competitive advantage but talented coaches will be able to compete. We’ve just hired awfully from a managerial perspective and a personnel perspective. Our issue is not Peps brilliance it is our own repeated mistakes.
Agree we are too slow moving the ball, so defensive sides can easily get back into shape.I was curious about attacking patterns, and I suppose this is the right thread for that. I don't watch the games, but I see the goals on here. Like these from the last few weeks:
Man Utd 1:0 Everton - Cavani (24')
Man Utd 2:0 Everton - Bruno (45')
West Brom 1:1 Man Utd - Bruno (44')
Like in these videos, what often strikes me is that United's possession play seems pretty passive. (NB: I am talking about regular possession, not the initial counter attack or free kicks.) People pass a ball and stand still, waiting to see what happens next. There isn't much interchange happening elsewhere either - until someone decides to make a move and play takes off again. That doesn't seem very strong to me. Is this just a very poor sample that happens to lead to goals, or is this common? Cause yeah, this sort of passivity would make it difficult to break down defensive teams.
I sound like a broken record but apart from Fred the scapegoat we have absolutely zero tempo in the middle. It becomes pedestrian and overly direct at the same time. We still have too many players trying to be the hero and playing for themselves.I was curious about attacking patterns, and I suppose this is the right thread for that. I don't watch the games, but I see the goals on here. Like these from the last few weeks:
Man Utd 1:0 Everton - Cavani (24')
Man Utd 2:0 Everton - Bruno (45')
West Brom 1:1 Man Utd - Bruno (44')
Like in these videos, what often strikes me is that United's possession play seems pretty passive. (NB: I am talking about regular possession, not the initial counter attack or free kicks.) People pass a ball and stand still, waiting to see what happens next. There isn't much interchange happening elsewhere either - until someone decides to make a move and play takes off again. That doesn't seem very strong to me. Is this just a very poor sample that happens to lead to goals, or is this common? Cause yeah, this sort of passivity would make it difficult to break down defensive teams.
No one in your midfield can actually progress the ball when Pogba is out. All game you were relying on Maguire to lumber forward down the left channel so he could draw a defender towards him before playing a 5 yard sideways layoff pass. When's the last time anyone who wasn't Bruno even attempted a penetrative pass?I sound like a broken record but apart from Fred the scapegoat we have absolutely zero tempo in the middle. It becomes pedestrian and overly direct at the same time. We still have too many players trying to be the hero and playing for themselves.
Definitely agree with that. Too many want to score The Goal of the Season. Too many don't bother looking up to see if there is anybody in a better position.I sound like a broken record but apart from Fred the scapegoat we have absolutely zero tempo in the middle. It becomes pedestrian and overly direct at the same time. We still have too many players trying to be the hero and playing for themselves.
Of course - he will always have a competitive advantage because he doesn't really have to care if his transfers work out or not but why should any manager do well to get close to him? Klopp spent less and won a PL and a CL all in the time he's been here. Conte won a PL and FA cup. Very different styles of football. The league is as weak as I can remember it right now, this is when longer term planning and having the right coach in place is key. We have a really good squad, some genuinely class players but we are severely behind tactically - that's on United as a football club.This is his 5th season, about to win his 3rd PL, didn't win it in his first and took a freak season from Liverpool to beat them last.
They will start next season as odds on favourites, probably with a new striker. Any manager we employ will do well to even get close to them.
When we played Red Bull, i was really impressed with how they (Red Bull) moved. It is subtle, like the difference between a good lager and an average one.I was curious about attacking patterns, and I suppose this is the right thread for that. I don't watch the games, but I see the goals on here. Like these from the last few weeks:
Man Utd 1:0 Everton - Cavani (24')
Man Utd 2:0 Everton - Bruno (45')
West Brom 1:1 Man Utd - Bruno (44')
Like in these videos, what often strikes me is that United's possession play seems pretty passive. (NB: I am talking about regular possession, not the initial counter attack or free kicks.) People pass a ball and stand still, waiting to see what happens next. There isn't much interchange happening elsewhere either - until someone decides to make a move and play takes off again. That doesn't seem very strong to me. Is this just a very poor sample that happens to lead to goals, or is this common? Cause yeah, this sort of passivity would make it difficult to break down defensive teams.
Hmm.. City is not the current league holder. Liverpool and Leicester have proved that you don't need to overspend others to win.See what you mean. No chance while Pep is at City.
This right here..to often we rely on a moment of brilliance, mainly from BrunoWith Bayern, Red Bull, City, Liverpool last year, Ajax, maybe there is more, it is all methodical in how they create chances. There is method to it.
With us, it is down to individual brilliance. Either through the assister or the scorer himself.
And going by his celebration i think he is getting fed up with having to bail us out all the time.This right here..to often we rely on a moment of brilliance, mainly from Bruno
He was definitely very frustrated all game. Seen on twitter he was meant to have had a blowout with ole as wellAnd going by his celebration i think he is getting fed up with having to bail us out all the time.
This is my main gripe with our play as well. I don't know if it is tactical (sudden speed change?) or lackadaisical, but I believe our players should be more on the front foot, making themselves useful and tearing defenses apart by diagonal, curved or even lateral runs between opponents lines. I get a sense it is something which is being worked on without bearing full fruits so far.I was curious about attacking patterns, and I suppose this is the right thread for that. I don't watch the games, but I see the goals on here. Like these from the last few weeks:
Man Utd 1:0 Everton - Cavani (24')
Man Utd 2:0 Everton - Bruno (45')
West Brom 1:1 Man Utd - Bruno (44')
Like in these videos, what often strikes me is that United's possession play seems pretty passive. (NB: I am talking about regular possession, not the initial counter attack or free kicks.) People pass a ball and stand still, waiting to see what happens next. There isn't much interchange happening elsewhere either - until someone decides to make a move and play takes off again. That doesn't seem very strong to me. Is this just a very poor sample that happens to lead to goals, or is this common? Cause yeah, this sort of passivity would make it difficult to break down defensive teams.
Ole is not in the same league as Klopp and never will be and this comparison of their respective times at Utd & Liverpool really needs to stop before gullible people start actually believing itBecause you need time. As a manger you need time. People in here love to put Klopp to the clouds but don't mention that he needed 4-5 (!) years to bring some trophy to Liverpool. Managers need time. 2 season making a team in ManUtd and 3rd season showing full capacity.
I would have let Moyes have time IF he hadn't changed whole backroom staff. He did the worst thing he could do and that is changing a title winning staff for Everton people. That alone should have been sackable offence.
Then you don't need to worry yet. We are 2nd and we will be top 4. I predicted top 3.
We are showing progress and if we can manage to be 2nd we would have come 3rd, 2nd with Solskjaer. Next stop? You know what it is.
I was saying this in another thread a while back. We have been set up like Real Madrid lite over the last few years. We assumed because we are paying world class wages we’d get a world class return. Whether we take the next step is purely based on what we go and do in the market. If are decisive then I think the team is very close to being a top team again. I have the worst feeling our owners will just continue to play it safe while we are qualifying for the CL. They love monitoring a situation to be fair!With Bayern, Red Bull, City, Liverpool last year, Ajax, maybe there is more, it is all methodical in how they create chances. There is method to it.
With us, it is down to individual brilliance. Either through the assister or the scorer himself.
It wasn't just the results, it was the football too. The goals were being scored by forwards who aren't scoring now, but they were at the end of moves and passes and movement which are also missing. For me that shows the difference is more than poor form for the forwards.honestly I feel like that end to the season was an anomaly. Who did we play that was a tricky opponent? Spurs- draw. Leicester, scrappy game with Kasper mistake sealing it. We choked and played well within ourselves through out most of the run in and if we were actually that good we should have beat Sevilla and destroyed Copenhagen. I’d say they couldn’t believe their luck at what showed up. They were way overhyped on the back of that scrappy run. Where would Ole, Rashford or Martial be if Bruno hadn’t come in or Greenwood hadn’t stepped up. Fine fine margins. The sloppy play at the end of the season just continued into this season and we haven’t been able to kick on and Cavani was never going to enough. We are lucky he’s even done as well as he has. Seems like the owners thought we were good enough to rest on our laurels anyway...