Doubt it. Pep didnt come in to first year at City and win the trophies did he?- they were not even retaining possesion the way they are this season. Considering under LVG we had a team that had retained possesion across the whole league but primarily struggled to break down defences - this would be primarily what Pep would have needed to target both tactically and during his transfer windows. It was more likely that Jose would taken longer to build something from what LVG left than Pep would have - even ideologically both LVG & Pep run through branches of ajax/Barcelona's philosophy.
Did you read the post ?
Pep's style has never been like the shite show LVG was doing here, keeping aimless possession, sideways and backpassing nonstop for no purpose. Pep's style is about retaining the ball
but in the opposition's third. The ball must move quickly from the defense forward and past the central line for the midfielders and wingers to push the opposition defense in their last third and run circles around them till a gap appears. LVG style was about passing sideways and backwards aimlessly to prevent the opposition from attacking our fragile defense. LVG used his boring possession for the sake of defending, while Pep uses possession for the sake of attacking and pushing teams back. To see that since we possess the ball well under LVG we would have played well under Pep just shows you know nothing of Pep's style.
Pep has been inspired by Cruyff. I don't know when the claims of LVG being his inspiration ever comes. Seems something only invented by LVG fanboys.
To assume that Pep would have needed a longer time to produce something than Jose is just delusional - especially when our manager has yet to do it himself.
I dont even particularly like Pep- I just find it a bit annoying that we went from one maximum of a philosphy under LVG where things like possession and positioning around a team was important - to know where we are under a manager who promotes individuality, strength/ hoofing, counterattacking football.
To me, it has been a longer procedure that has yet to prove to be significantly beneficial ( maybe next season). The other option was take what LVG had done things like the team retaining 60+ % possesion in games against both the best and worst teams in the league - find a way to produce the goods and break down the teams that chose to park the bus against us. This was possibly the plan/ the next step for the next manager at the time who was Giggs - so whilst United might not be good as City currently if Pep was the manager- to assume we would be worse under him than what we have been currently being seen under Jose is a bias and is wrong.
Sorry but you're the one delusional here. Look at the current City team. Pep spent half a billion and guess what, he only changed the back row, GK and a winger (Sane). Fernandinho, KDB, Silva, Sterling and Aguero were all present when he got the team and are all now fundamentals in this unstoppable team.
Can you see that with the squad LVG left ? The squad that its 2 best players were 2 inconsistent youngsters, has no striker, has no midfielders but instead shoehorning Rooney in the midfield and plays aimless possession in our own third for the sake of preventing the opposition from attacking our fragile defense ? You really think both are comparable ? Don't make me laugh.
Pep would have needed to spend far, far more than what he spent with City. He would have got a full new back row, maybe keeping Shaw only or something. He would have got 3 full new midfielders including 2 top class attacking ones to play his 4-3-3. He would have got a top striker and another top winger to partner Martial. That's only the startling lineup, not to mention signings for the bench. Adds to that time to install his play style in the players minds and making a coherent team. You think that won't have taken longer time ? Then think again. Pep's style demands from his players far more than any other top manager's does.
At City he got Fernandinho, KDB, Silva and Aguero, so he didn't need any signings in midfield, so instead focused the money in improving the only weak spot (back row and GKs), and getting some good talents to add to the versatile players he already had, so got Jesus, Sane and B.Silva. He didn't build a new team. He improved the weak points in the squad, and he needed to spent half a billion for that. Now imagine this with our terrible squad LVG left and you'll know how much he would have taken to have such a similar team as current City.