What shirt number will Varane get?

Jacob

Full Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2005
Messages
25,577
Have you considered the fact that Varane may not want to take the number 4 from another player? If I was new in a club, and modest as Varane supposedly is, the last thing I'd do is kick doors in and cause upset.

Move on and accept that numbers maybe isn't that important to players as it is to you.
 

sparx99

Full Member
Joined
May 22, 2016
Messages
3,952
Have you considered the fact that Varane may not want to take the number 4 from another player? If I was new in a club, and modest as Varane supposedly is, the last thing I'd do is kick doors in and cause upset.

Move on and accept that numbers maybe isn't that important to players as it is to you.
This is true. But it does feel weird to have so many ‘wrong’ numbers. It seems nailed on that Cavani leaves next summer and Sancho will take 7. Bruno supposedly has his eye on 8 when Mata leaves and I imagine Varane will take 4 if we shift Jones.

I just don’t like having numbers 29, 25, 39 etc being prominent first team numbers. It shows how well the marketing of shirt numbers has worked!
 

Eugenius

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
3,933
Location
Behind You
There’s a human element knobheads.

Let’s send Phil Jones into depression cause we all like nice numbers.
Poor guy as well. Must be difficult enough with a long term injury, and being a figure of fun despite actually being a very talented / highly rated player before. But let's strip him of his squad number, because Varane *needs* it.
 

Red_toad

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2010
Messages
11,616
Location
DownUnder
Have you considered the fact that Varane may not want to take the number 4 from another player? If I was new in a club, and modest as Varane supposedly is, the last thing I'd do is kick doors in and cause upset.

Move on and accept that numbers maybe isn't that important to players as it is to you.
They are to some players, so it's a valid question!
 

The Cluck

Full Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2021
Messages
121
Location
Belfast, Northern Ireland
Van der Sar - #19 in his first season
Cole - #17 for his first season and a half
Keane - #16 for his entire career at United
Scholes - #24, #22, #18, #22 during his career at United
Vidic - #15 for his entire career at United
Yorke - #19 for his entire career at United
Van Persie - #20 for his entire career at United

Did it matter to any of them?

If getting a better squad number does indeed matter to him, I'm sure he'll get one in a season or two.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
22,931
Location
Somewhere out there
What an idiotic comment.
Seriously? I reckon Phil’s in a bad place right now, a figure of absolute ridicule all over the internet and amongst his own fans, a player who can’t seem to get a break with injuries, he certainly can’t be feeling great.
Telling him “you’re shite mate and don’t believe you’re ever coming back so we’re having your shirt” feels like a thing Ole (who has his own injury issues) would never in a million years consider doing to the poor sod.
 

Alemar

Full Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2017
Messages
7,617
There’s a human element knobheads.

Let’s send Phil Jones into depression cause we all like nice numbers.
But couldn’t it be an additional motivation for Jones to move elsewhere? Anything that helps getting rid of Jones is worth doing, given he doesn’t quit himself
 

Alemar

Full Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2017
Messages
7,617
Because that’s the problem. We can’t find a club who wants to sign Jones because he’s so attached to his shirt number at United.
Strip him off a number, don’t register him for any competitions and ban him from visiting first team training facilities. Maybe it would help him understand where things stand…
 

hellhunter

Eurofighter
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
18,056
Location
Stuttgart, Germany
Supports
Karlsruher SC
Strip him off a number, don’t register him for any competitions and ban him from visiting first team training facilities. Maybe it would help him understand where things stand…
And get sued for breach of contract nevermind acting as horrible employers to human beings.
 

Reapersoul20

Can Anderson score? No.
Joined
Aug 13, 2006
Messages
12,153
Location
Jog on
Strip him off a number, don’t register him for any competitions and ban him from visiting first team training facilities. Maybe it would help him understand where things stand…
I am glad you're not managing the club :lol:.
 

RedDevilQuebecois

Full Member
Joined
May 27, 2021
Messages
8,157
And get sued for breach of contract nevermind acting as horrible employers to human beings.
Contract buyouts are a thing in North America when a club both cannot trade/transfer a player away (because of a bloated contract) and yet want to get rid of that player out of the squad at all costs. Sure a specific percentage of what is left on wages to the contract is paid to the player according to CBA rules, so you can't get sued with that. I don't know if that is legal in Europe, but it's very much legal in all sports leagues in North America.
 

hellhunter

Eurofighter
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
18,056
Location
Stuttgart, Germany
Supports
Karlsruher SC
Contract buyouts are a thing in North America when a club both cannot trade/transfer a player away (because of a bloated contract) and yet want to get rid of that player out of the squad at all costs. Sure a specific percentage of what is left on wages to the contract is paid to the player according to CBA rules, so you can't get sued with that. I don't know if that is legal in Europe, but it's very much legal in all sports leagues in North America.
Not an expert either, but don't think buyouts work without the players consent here. Either way, it's a shitty way to treat a loyal human being who happens to be very prone to injuries. Not his fault he gets offered contract after contract.
 

Rolaholic

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Messages
11,163
Would hope it'd be 4 but it sounds like it might be 19

Would like to see something like 12 rather than a forward number if he can't get 4
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,593
Supports
Mejbri
Seriously? I reckon Phil’s in a bad place right now, a figure of absolute ridicule all over the internet and amongst his own fans, a player who can’t seem to get a break with injuries, he certainly can’t be feeling great.
Telling him “you’re shite mate and don’t believe you’re ever coming back so we’re having your shirt” feels like a thing Ole (who has his own injury issues) would never in a million years consider doing to the poor sod.
I was just cutting because of your post. I definitely think he's not feeling amazing about himself and I've got sympathy for him, and he's not worthy of ridicule. However, when a bigger player comes in to effectively take your place (in this case, take the place of the one who takes the place of the one who takes his place) I think it's absolutely fine and not huge embarrassment that you surrender your shirt number. It's happened a million times before between players closer in quality. If he's allowed his #4 without playing, I see that more as pity and not as sympathy. Or sympathy porn if you like.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
22,931
Location
Somewhere out there
I was just cutting because of your post. I definitely think he's not feeling amazing about himself and I've got sympathy for him, and he's not worthy of ridicule. However, when a bigger player comes in to effectively take your place (in this case, take the place of the one who takes the place of the one who takes his place) I think it's absolutely fine and not huge embarrassment that you surrender your shirt number. It's happened a million times before between players closer in quality. If he's allowed his #4 without playing, I see that more as pity and not as sympathy. Or sympathy porn if you like.
How often has it happened with a player who’s had that squad number for 10 years?

Would Fergie have asked Ole to give up his number during his injury struggles for example? Of course when you had a number for 10 years it would be a huge embarrassment to then have that taken off you, especially as you’re already one of the biggest ridicules in football, and a walking meme.

It’d be shitty thing to do to a guy who’s only ever tried his best and has had some horrendous luck in my opinion, after 10 years it’s his shirt until he’s no longer a United player.
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,593
Supports
Mejbri
How often has it happened with a player who’s had that squad number for 10 years?

Would Fergie have asked Ole to give up his number during his injury struggles for example? Of course when you had a number for 10 years it would be a huge embarrassment to then have that taken off you, especially as you’re already one of the biggest ridicules in football, and a walking meme.

It’d be shitty thing to do to a guy who’s only ever tried his best and has had some horrendous luck in my opinion, after 10 years it’s his shirt until he’s no longer a United player.
This is what I mean by sympathy porn "only ever tried his best". I've not implied that he hasn't. He's had a nightmare with injuries and besides that he's not good enough. He's earning more at United than he could dream of elsewhere. That he can finish out the next two years of contract here is winning the lottery. He's likely been offered moves by the club and said no thanks. I mean, he's nowhere near to being in even a slight favour.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
22,931
Location
Somewhere out there
This is what I mean by sympathy porn "only ever tried his best". I've not implied that he hasn't. He's had a nightmare with injuries and besides that he's not good enough. He's earning more at United than he could dream of elsewhere. That he can finish out the next two years of contract here is winning the lottery. He's likely been offered moves by the club and said no thanks. I mean, he's nowhere near to being in even a slight favour.
And we’re back to my original point.

Having money doesn’t a happy person make, Phil Jones must be in an absolute shambles mentally these past couple of years. The more he has injury woes, the biggger his meme becomes.

As I say, did Fergie ever strip a player of his number after 10 years service? Why the funk would Ole do it? Because feck Phil, some fans like nice numbers.
 

sp_107

New Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2012
Messages
2,367
Location
Yorkshire
This whole Varane thing is becoming a joke, for more than a month we couldnt tie him oown for various reasons and now finally about this shirt number.....so bad..

|Even i dont like to disrespect Jones by taking away 4 but i think Varane can handle taking any other availbalble number even it is 44 or 88///doesnt matter

No contract signed , no short number , not registered for Leeds match and struck in Manchester traffic :) welcome to Manchester Varane. I am sure you will get used to it
 

Tom Van Persie

No relation
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
24,575
Strip him off a number, don’t register him for any competitions and ban him from visiting first team training facilities. Maybe it would help him understand where things stand…
Nice way to treat a player that's been at the club for 10 years.
 

RedSinha

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 6, 2013
Messages
97
But couldn’t it be an additional motivation for Jones to move elsewhere? Anything that helps getting rid of Jones is worth doing, given he doesn’t quit himself
This assumption about Jones by a section of the fanbase I can never seem to understand. There has been no indication in his entire career that Jones slacks off at work or is picking up a paycheck while intentionally wasting time not keeping fit (a player like Anderson comes to mind). When fit, he always gives 100%.

If a club were to offer him decent wages, I'm sure he would move there. I'm sure it's not for a lack of trying. It's just that signing him with his wages and injury record is a huge risk for a smaller club. They'd rather sign a fitter yet inferior player.

Also, would you quit your job where you're getting handsomely paid to settle for less than half your current wages, to "prove yourself"? No. It's a job. Playing football is a job.
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,593
Supports
Mejbri
And we’re back to my original point.

Having money doesn’t a happy person make, Phil Jones must be in an absolute shambles mentally these past couple of years. The more he has injury woes, the biggger his meme becomes.

As I say, did Fergie ever strip a player of his number after 10 years service? Why the funk would Ole do it? Because feck Phil, some fans like nice numbers.
Yeah, I think you are way too high and mighty about this. I don't really care what SAF would have done in the exact same situation. You make it seem as if the club that is already paying Phil Jones more than he could possibly earn anywhere else on the planet, should be tasked with figuring out ways to minimise some meme-ification of Jones in order to protect his mental health. Now, if you were talking about sending him to a psychotherapist (on the hypothetical basis that he needs and wants one) I'm with you. Always. But to make sure his feelings aren't hurt over his shirt number, because he's already not turned out to be a great player for us and is always injured, that's just extreme preciousness and seems like something the lip-service-to-right-side-of-history Guardian editors would concoct in their soulless meetings.

Martial had to give Zlatan his number. Then Romelu. Definitely in the former case, that was an obvious thing to do. Probably also in the latter, given the outlay and expectations. And also, given that Martial is not an amazing #9, but an ill-defined forward player yet to really establish himself. And I thought, fair fukcing enough. If he had been dumped by his girlfriend the month before Zlatan's arrival, what then? Should we have taken it to a committee meeting to weigh the pros and cons of the potential mental breakdown looming if he were to surrender his number?

As I say, this is being framed in the most dramatic way possible.
 

Gopher Brown

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
4,549
This whole Varane thing is becoming a joke, for more than a month we couldnt tie him oown for various reasons and now finally about this shirt number.....so bad..

|Even i dont like to disrespect Jones by taking away 4 but i think Varane can handle taking any other availbalble number even it is 44 or 88///doesnt matter

No contract signed , no short number , not registered for Leeds match and struck in Manchester traffic :) welcome to Manchester Varane. I am sure you will get used to it
Not 88 though. He’s not a neo Nazi….I hope.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
22,931
Location
Somewhere out there
Yeah, I think you are way too high and mighty about this. I don't really care what SAF would have done in the exact same situation. You make it seem as if the club that is already paying Phil Jones more than he could possibly earn anywhere else on the planet, should be tasked with figuring out ways to minimise some meme-ification of Jones in order to protect his mental health. Now, if you were talking about sending him to a psychotherapist (on the hypothetical basis that he needs and wants one) I'm with you. Always. But to make sure his feelings aren't hurt over his shirt number, because he's already not turned out to be a great player for us and is always injured, that's just extreme preciousness and seems like something the lip-service-to-right-side-of-history Guardian editors would concoct in their soulless meetings.

Martial had to give Zlatan his number. Then Romelu. Definitely in the former case, that was an obvious thing to do. Probably also in the latter, give the outlay and expectations. And also, given that Martial is not an amazing #9, but an ill-defined forward player yet to really establish himself. And I thought, fair fukcing enough. If he had been dumped by his girlfriend the month before Zlatan's arrival, what then? Should we have taken it to a committee meeting to weigh the pros and cons of the potential mental breakdown looming if he were to surrender his number?

As I say, this is being framed in the most dramatic way possible.
Give me some examples of it happening after 10 years of service. Anywhere?
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,593
Supports
Mejbri
Give me some examples of it happening after 10 years of service. Anywhere?
I am not going to do that research. And frankly, you'd have to caveat that research with it being a player who is very likely being shopped around with no takers (or the player being unwilling to move). I've already laid out my opinion on the matter.
 

RedDevilQuebecois

Full Member
Joined
May 27, 2021
Messages
8,157
Nice way to treat a player that's been at the club for 10 years.
A player who hasn't done jack in half of those 10 years. I'm done with whatever sympathy BS one can throw at him; he is no longer earning it at all.

It's time to buy out whatever is left of his contract and then release him to free agency.
 

Tom Van Persie

No relation
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
24,575
A player who hasn't done jack in half of those 10 years. I'm done with whatever sympathy BS one can throw at him; he is no longer earning it at all.

It's time to buy out whatever is left of his contract and then release him to free agency.
Yeah because it's his fault he can't stay fit and should be punished. :rolleyes: You can go look up interviews or ask anyone who's been at United and they all speak highly of Jones. It's unfortunate how his career has panned out. I hope things work out for him.
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2020
Messages
1,424
Has Varane definitely passed both medicals ? This is starting to have the feeling of one of those cancelled at very last moment deals.