Once we get Greizmann, who cares what City do.
Bernardo Silva | Bouhafsi - 70m Euros, 5 year contract. Going to City CONFIRMED
- Thread starter RDCR07
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
- Status
All good, agree but uts bizarre that people are panicking while it's end of May..
Neither is Sterling. Both players occupy the same sort of areas.
Do they have "a pair"?
Aye. Bunch of fannies.
Jesus...But SAF still won the league without Hazard, though ?
Also for the question in the post, may be because our manager has another targets in his lost that are more priority for him ? May be Silva was a priority for fans but doesn't mean he's a priority for our manager. He's free to do what he want and he will hold responsibility for next season.
As I told you, we won't prevent our opponents from getting good players. They will get great players and we will too.
Devastated, the kid's a genius.
If we don't sign a player, either its the end of the world and we've fecked up or he's shite and we're lucky we missed out.
Look Silva is a massive talent, but he wasn't right for United.. he would be another Mkhi/Mata at this club but slightly better. We would have made him track back like a dog, barely give him any possession to work with and with his lack of pace, he'd have struggled to make an impact in our side as a right winger, that is a fact. There is no way with our style of play, we would make it work with Silva, Griezmann and Pogba.. almost three playmakers who like to operate centrally. It would have been the most expensive clusterfeck of all time.. and we'd still look shocking as an attacking unit next year, only an extremely pretty one with neat triangles and nice dribbling.
He's gone to the right club. He'll be a big success there, under a manager who will give him the right platform to succeed, someone who understands playmakers like Silva alot better than Jose ever will and will have team mates with the same wavelength.
He's not shit, he has the ability to be a world class player but he wasn't the right player for us. Good move for all parties concerned.
I honestly think someone like Mahrez/Costa out wide, would be a far better tactical fit for Mourinho style football than Silva ever could and we can get them at half the price. If we want to go real top dollar, Dembele/Bale/Mbappe.. are the guys we need out wide, not a playmaker who lacks top tier pace in Silva.
Look Silva is a massive talent, but he wasn't right for United.. he would be another Mkhi/Mata at this club but slightly better. We would have made him track back like a dog, barely give him any possession to work with and with his lack of pace, he'd have struggled to make an impact in our side as a right winger, that is a fact. There is no way with our style of play, we would make it work with Silva, Griezmann and Pogba.. almost three playmakers who like to operate centrally. It would have been the most expensive clusterfeck of all time.. and we'd still look shocking as an attacking unit next year, only an extremely pretty one with neat triangles and nice dribbling.
He's gone to the right club. He'll be a big success there, under a manager who will give him the right platform to succeed, someone who understands playmakers like Silva alot better than Jose ever will and will have team mates with the same wavelength.
He's not shit, he has the ability to be a world class player but he wasn't the right player for us. Good move for all parties concerned.
I honestly think someone like Mahrez/Costa out wide, would be a far better tactical fit for Mourinho style football than Silva ever could and we can get them at half the price. If we want to go real top dollar, Dembele/Bale/Mbappe.. are the guys we need out wide, not a playmaker who lacks top tier pace in Silva.
Looks like he's gotten worse in some United's fan views today and to others he's gotten better. Great to see.
We can't sign everyone you want to sign.
Maybe we're playing 4-3-3 next year and Griezmann plays Silva's position as an inside forward?
Maybe he wants to frontload the 3 attacking positions with goals to compensate the rest of our squad which Silva doesn't provide?
Maybe he sees Perreira as a legitimate option for next year? Maybe he sees Gomes coming through and doesn't want to sign a 22 year old in his position?
Shit chest control. Do not want.
Fantastic post. We already have a similar player in Mkhitaryan I think. Need someone with more speed.
Stop shitting beds guys, he wasn't that good anyway. We will make our own signings, if we were in for him he wouldn't decide on City so fast.
Tielemans signing for United would mean he would be expected to perform very well every game.
At Anderlecht, Monaco, he can afford to have off games or run into a bad patch of form because there's much less pressure.
Perfect D.Silva replacement 
Every single time one of our rivals signs someone there's mass crying. We can't sign evreyone ffs.
But can he control the ball with his chest from a 50 yard pass and lay it off like Fellaini?
Nah didn't think so. Do not want.
Nah didn't think so. Do not want.
The best attack in league just got better. Like De Bruyne and Sane, another one I think we'll regret not going for.
Feels a bit like 2010 when we missed out on David Silva.
Its alright guys we have our own number 10 at the club who will be better in a couple of years time... Angel
Thanks. To be fair, I wasn't expecting you to agree with me
I'm not going to get involved in the wider Silva discussion on this thread as emotions are running pretty high, suffice to say that both clubs were always going to spend big this window and as such United will sign some great players this summer too.
Great, informative post. Jose proved this year, he clearly possess a plan for a trophy winning team.
I can bet money that somewhere in the end of June, maybe couple weeks later this place will be a muppet heaven.
Anyone remember the summer we only signed Michael Carrick? How is that going to be enough to close the gap on Chelsea?! People cried.
11 years on it's the same story. Jose knows what he needs.
11 years on it's the same story. Jose knows what he needs.
Season was ok, he would possibly get into our team, yes, but he wouldn't make it better. Going forward he is not better then Mata, Micky..he is pretty similar to Lingard though, regarding work rate etc. Would not have made our team better, nor worse. Similar to Bernardo Silva. I'd rather get players that really make our team better.
Get a grip on yourself. They can absolutely have him for that price. How can you be so sure it will work out for him there? I can name plenty of players they have signed that have been absolute garbage for them. I do think he will do well there, but how can you say if we signed him that it would work out. City's style and ours are polar opposites.
Finally a sensible post. We have several more pressing concerns in the squad than improving on Mata and Mikhi. Silva is a great player but not the type of player we need right now
Does not make sense. City were already well stacked up front. Will have no effect at all. Guess Sterling is second choice now. They now have Sane, Jesus, Sterling, Debruyne, Bernardo Silva, Sergio Aguero for the top 3 positions.
Think we should put in a cheeky bid for Sergio Aguero.
Think we should put in a cheeky bid for Sergio Aguero.
Haven't seen enough of him to have an opinion either way. Everyone says he's really good though so City have done well to get him.
It's going to be a huge Summer of spending by City and hopefully by Utd as well.
Jose made 4 great signings last Summer, I'm confident he'll do it again this year.
It's going to be a huge Summer of spending by City and hopefully by Utd as well.
Jose made 4 great signings last Summer, I'm confident he'll do it again this year.
Great post. B.Silva is a top talent but he's gone to the right manager to help him thrive. I was always unsure about how he would actually fit in with us as we're more geared to constricting space in defence and then exploiting it on the counter in attack.
B.Silva doesn't fit the profile. He's better at City where keeping possession is what he'll be expected to do and what his game is.
Not sure about this strategy of keep throwing money at the attack when the midfield and defence is rubbish but maybe it's something we should do too, who needs defence when you're gonna outscore the opponents.
It's ok. We're getting Griezmann & Neymar.
You are expected to perform well everywhere you play. You think Anderlecht doesn´t have pressure to qualify for the CL domestically to maintain their financial dominance in their local market. B
Besides what´s he competing against? A 6th place finish, scoing less goals as a team than under Moyes and Carrick/Sideshow Bob/Herrera. Give me break. If you have 17-18 good players you can rotate the team through four competitions. United don´t even have 11 good starters.
Griezmann isn't a playmaker and Silva played on the right mostly. The part about possession is wrong as well, you're making it sound like we haven't had games where we've had a lot of possession and chances, he'd add to that, Jose doesn't go pragmatic against every team in the league. Mbappe is a striker, not really a winger.
Not that I'm losing my shit but losing out on this guy is a great loss imo, he'll be what Silva has been to them. Agree that he'll look better in their system than ours though.
needs to bulk upIts alright guys we have our own number 10 at the club who will be better in a couple of years time... Angel
Did they score the most goals this year?
- Status