De Gea - Class as always, thank feck we have the likes of herrera and mata who he's really close with, because it's amazing he's been happy to stay at United for so long despite being one of the top 2 goalkeepers in the world and United being shit in the last 4 seasons.
Valencia - One of the few who did well I thought. A few careless passes but generally held down that side well as always.
Lindelof - Definitely seems like a John Stones type in that he's better on the ball then at actually being a defender. Hopefully he adapts quickly, but he wouldn't be starting for me if all are fit.
Smalling - Did pretty well actually. Though he's sloppy at times with his positioning.
Darmian - Did alright as always. It's a weak position for us but he fills in decently.
Matic - MOTM for us, looked by far our best midfielder out there and defended well.
Herrera - Ran a lot but not his best game.
Pogba - Started brightly, fecked up a counter and then went to shit for the rest of the game. You expect a lot more from him. Outclassed by Isco, modric and Kroos today.
Lingard - He's a mid table player at best, no idea why he's starting in cup finals like this.
Mkhitaryan - Inconsistent like he was last season. Some moments of class, some sloppy, some invisible.
Lukaku - Meh. Missed a sitter, scored a slightly easier chance, some decent moments of hold up play and some really dumb moments.
Overall... bit shit overall. Yes Madrid are a level or 2 above us. Doesn't excuse some of those periods of play like the 15 minutes after their first goal. As a collective unit we still leave a lot to be desired and there wasn't so much in terms of actual cohesive play which was a problem last season. We got back into the game by making it a scrap and throwing fellaini on there to have big players in there.... That's not what we should aspire for even if it's effective at times.