We can accommodate him in 4-3-3 with front interchanging and we have many options to accommodate him in 4-4-2 or 4-1-4-1, 4-3-2-1 or 4-3-1-2 as long we can play 3 central midfield. To note, he likes to score a goal from out the box and play behind a striker, he's not the type of player you would want him to score a tap in.
Paulo Dybala
- Thread starter soap
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
I would love to see him at the club, but I don’t think he’d fit Mourinho’s tactical setup.
He's #10 so he'd be best in that formation? I don't see any logic against Dybala working in 4-2-3-1
Especially working off Lukaku...
He'd look incredible as either the second striker or in Lingard's role in our current diamond tbh. He can also play in a 4231 as his main role is off the striker.
He can play fine in a 4231 - it’s just not the best formation for the team as a whole.
We need 3 midfielders in the team. Dybala can fit in anywhere ahead of them, but we need 3 in the middle. A right- sided SS, similar to how Alli/Son play would be ideal I think.
The 4231 formation means that Pogba is expected to play a deeper role. He’s far to good a player going forward to waste him in a deeper position.He's #10 so he'd be best in that formation? I don't see any logic against Dybala working in 4-2-3-1
Especially working off Lukaku...
The best scenario would to play a 433, with Pogba given the licence to do whatever he wants and Dybala as one of the wide forward roles with the licence to drift about.
It won’t happen though as Mourinho seems to favour the awful 4321 setup.
Agreed. 433 would maximise Pogba’s influence and give us the Much needed control in midfield.
Capable, sure. He plays there occassionally for Juve but most of the time in the middle as far as I know.
I agree, even could fit in a modified 4231 potentially with Matic being the CDM, Pogba as the LM/CM ahead of him and Dybala ahead of Pogba. And if that’s the case he’s able to play RW I don’t see how José wouldn’t be able to find a fit for him. Simply put he’d be able to play a Griezmann type role where he can play either the #10/SS spot or RW depending on the formation.
José’s most successful formations were arguably the 4231 and 433 which he was famous for with Real Madrid.
RM 4231
————Benzema
CR7———Ozil———Di Maria
———Alonso-Khedira
Marcelo-Pepe-Ramos-Arbeloa
RM 433
CR7——Benzema——Ozil
Khedira-Alonso-Diarra
Marcelo-Pepe-Ramos-Arbeloa
...using those templates, Matic would be our Khedira. Pogba being a more up the pitch Alonso with license to roam as a creative attacker. Dybala becomes a Ozil/Griezmann hybrid.
Modified United 4231
————Lukaku
Martial————Dybala——New RW
————Pogba
——————Matic
New LB-Bailly-CB-Valencia
United 433
Martial——Lukaku——Dybala
———Pogba——New CM
——————Matic
New LB-Bailly-CB-Valencia
Is that too far fetched off or in the realm of possibility? I mean, we were interested in AG last Summer and he plays SS/RW similarly to how Dybala does, and how Ozil did as a #10/RW for Mourinho back in the day. I’m certain if it weren’t for the Atletico ban, Griezmann would be ours and José would play him as he used to played Ozil, either behind the main striker or on the right depending on formation. And since AG to United has sort of faded away, if Dybala is linked I don’t see why José wouldn’t play him in a similar sort of role. Makes sense too since we desperately need a CM and #10/SS + RW, the latter 2 of which a world class player like Dybala/Griezmann would be able to both fulfill.
Contracted until 2022 :/
United 433
Martial——Lukaku——Dybala/Griezmann/Mahrez
———Pogba——Savic/Kovacic
——————Matic
Rose/Alex Sandro-Bailly-CB-Valencia
Unfortunately, Mourinho's favoured modern formation is the 4-2-3-1. 4-3-3 is definitely something he has moved on from as his default formation. In my opinion he views the 4-2-3-1 as the counter to the possession based systems that have popped up in the last 10 years.
His best teams have been the 4-2-3-1. Mourinho has started with a 4-3-3 and switched to a 4-2-3-1 and won major silverware in 3 successive teams. Inter, Madrid, Chelsea.
Shame he signed a new contract in the summer
It’s more to do with those elite attackers coming to the end of their cycle and needing replacing.
Aye, age, wages & injury history is really going to hamper your ability to recoup substantially on the BBC. Still, it’s Madrid. It wouldn’t surprise me one bit if you managed to get close to €300m for them by shifting them to the EPL or ParisHazard+Dybala+Kane could come up to around €500m total between the three of them. If we can raise some €300m from the BBC it might be doable
Though you’ll probably sell them 1 by 1 over the coming 2-3 years. Makes more sense and it’ll be less expensive. But you’re in for an expensive rebuild over the next 5 years, unless of course your strategy of signing talented youngsters reap its rewards over the coming years.
Kane is simply unattainable, probably even for the Neymar fee.Hazard+Dybala+Kane could come up to around €500m total between the three of them. If we can raise some €300m from the BBC it might be doable
I think Chelsea wouldn’t sell for anything short of 200m Euros either. And that’s only if Hazard tried to force a move. I would think he is probably ready for a new challenge.
We should have been in for him before that, when the Griezmann move fell through.
So basically, he won’t be a free transfer?
Indeed he won't
I suppose the contract length doesn't normally matter all that much unless there's only 1 year left.
So we need CM x2, LB, RW and a AMC..
So Dybala or Griezmann could be used both in the right and up top.. Özil on free is a no brainer really. With Carrick and Fellaini on the way out we need to fill those slots and could buy a young player to fill the reserve LB slot.. In todays market we are looking at something close to 300m with either Dybala or Griezmann costing half of that..
I still think we have a bloated squad and should raise at least 50-70m from selling a few players..
So Dybala or Griezmann could be used both in the right and up top.. Özil on free is a no brainer really. With Carrick and Fellaini on the way out we need to fill those slots and could buy a young player to fill the reserve LB slot.. In todays market we are looking at something close to 300m with either Dybala or Griezmann costing half of that..
I still think we have a bloated squad and should raise at least 50-70m from selling a few players..
We can probably get away without a LB, at least for another season after this. Jose has apparently been impressed with Shaw recently and Young can do a job there. Unless we go for a world class player, I'd be happy with that. Makes the amount of acquisitions needed a little less daunting.
Its hard to figure out where he should play in these three-up-front times because he looks like a 4-4-2 player, a SS more than a wide striker that can play as winger, like Salah. I use to read that Juventuz site and they have similar opinion in his thread; they are talking about changing his role all the time.
The thing is, he is such a clinical finisher that it would be worth to give him a free role to flutuate in the attack as a false 9.
The thing is, he is such a clinical finisher that it would be worth to give him a free role to flutuate in the attack as a false 9.
If we fail to get this guy we will be screwed. For it seems barca will get griezmann
Real Madrid will surely be in the picture.
I agree. Quite frankly the service and build up play we receive from RB is more of a concern. I am talking about Valencia.
I think Griezmann is not the signing we want at all.... if Barca 'solve' that problem I would be very happy.
No. They want Hazard. Plus Kane or Icardi will interest them for the striker role
Is there anything actually in this? Or is it just hopeful speculation?
I think there was like one report that said we had bid a woefully small amount for him (like £68m) and afaik it's gone quiet since then.
Dybala will give this team some much needed stardust up top, building a top class front 3 is the bedrock of the elite clubs these days.
Minimum 150m Euros price-tag + astronomical wages to convince him to come, if at all possible (would depend on whether others are in for him).
See us trying it?
See us trying it?
What about PSG Chief? To replace Cavani. Maybe move Mbappe up top or use Dybala as a false 9?
Would love it but don’t see it
Unless we spend our entire transfer budget on 1 player.
Wages im sure we can afford though.
Is this even happening or is it just fans getting excited about nothing?
There are minimal, if any, links in the press.
He would cost 50% more than any player that we have ever bought. Wages too, likely.
Juve have not indicated any willingness to sell.
Real will probably buy him.
Nope, nothing happening. Just wishful thinking from Muppets.
Yeah, agreed. But Young has been quite good there too. If Shaw is a bit better we can manage with those for a little bit then get the RB position sorted for the future and reassess LB. In a perfect world that is. We'll probably end up signing two random players
1 of the CMs is Pereira and TFM will fit in somewhere too.
Mourinho did refer to 1 big transfer happening again for us in the summer.
You never know.
You never know.
Allegri just said he can't play CF(starting 20 meters from the goal) because he needs to start 50 meters away from goal and could play as a CM(mezzala -in a 3) in an attacking team(like city or barcelona)
Truth be told, he can start from anywhere, the important thing is he's given freedom to roam, play down the middle and generally find his own position on the pitch. If you ask him to stick to a wing/inside channel, you lose a lot of his potential
Would you rather United get Griezmann as SS/RW or Dybala who’s 3 years younger (24)?
I was all in for AG but kind of lost interest after all the commotion and let down from the past Summer. Still believe he’s the better player compared to Dybala but looking at that age gap wouldn’t be surprised to see Dybala leapfrog him in the not so distant future.
I was all in for AG but kind of lost interest after all the commotion and let down from the past Summer. Still believe he’s the better player compared to Dybala but looking at that age gap wouldn’t be surprised to see Dybala leapfrog him in the not so distant future.
- Status