James Peril
New Member
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2016
- Messages
- 3,576
Absolutely scandalous decision by the referees, that is not offside. I just knew he was going to decide this game. Absolute idiot
You can't be offside when your opponent plays the ballThat was offside because the rules state that there must be 2 players playing the attacker onside. Usually we forget about the keeper because he’s way back on his line and only think about the defender.
Liverpool to squeeze through but with Mane, Firmino and Salah all picking up reds. That's my preference.I know, it’s ridiculous - I don’t know what I want
Surely not if the keeper punched it at his own blokeThat was offside because the rules state that there must be 2 players playing the attacker onside. Usually we forget about the keeper because he’s way back on his line and only think about the defender, but Karius was way out in the mix in that scenario and there was only one player playing Sane onside.
They don't have Marcelo, they don't have Carvajal who deliver great balls from the full back position eitherCity won't score 3 more. It's hard for them even with this line up. They don't have Ronaldo.
Milner played the ball. Milner is a Liverpool player.That was offside because the rules state that there must be 2 players playing the attacker onside. Usually we forget about the keeper because he’s way back on his line and only think about the defender, but Karius was way out in the mix in that scenario and there was only one player playing Sane onside.
I see, thanks! So City have been robbed?That's correct, but the ball came off Milner. So it shouldn't be counted as a new "phase" of play. Therefore Sané was onside.
But it was Milner that assistedThat was offside because the rules state that there must be 2 players playing the attacker onside. Usually we forget about the keeper because he’s way back on his line and only think about the defender, but Karius was way out in the mix in that scenario and there was only one player playing Sane onside.
It came off Milner manNah you have to have two players between you and the goal to be onside.
Genuinely perplexed as to how that second goal was disallowed.Should be 2 up. Ball came off milner
Hopefully, let them put their UEFA tin hats on.I see, thanks! So City have been robbed?
double decker as in park the busSpent about 15 seconds trying pronounce that word. Failed.
Won't even attempt to interpret it's meaning.
They only need two.City won't score 3 more. It's hard for them even with this line up. They don't have Ronaldo.
Off Milner.Commentary saying offside Sané goal shoulda stood, was off a defender?
They'll see it that way, but the City and Liverpool players were in line so I can see why the linesman thought it came off the City player. I didn't see that until the replay.I see, thanks! So City have been robbed?