To rate our transfer window, we need to look at certain things from last season and to determine our realistic goals for this season.
This season we all agree we must get in the top 4.
Last season we weren't bad in scoring goals, we're 5 behind Tottenham and Arsenal (2 goals below Tottenham and 8 behind Arsenal) but we were leaking goals in defense. We secured only 7 clean sheets (14th position in the EPL) while Tottenham kept 13 clean sheets.
Keeping that in mind, it seems we didn't need much to add to our front line, especially that almost all our academy grads play in the front line, I mean Chong, Greenwood and Gomez, so a good planning would be not to sign any new player in the front line and to give those guys a chance to see who can add to the team and who can be shipped out next transfer window. Unless Lukako is leaving then we have to replace him with a finisher, not a versatile forward in my opinion.
In the midfield, we lost Herrera and Fellaini, Matic is almost done those are 3 starters, not just squad players. We have/had chronic problems in RB and RW. And we lacked value and leadership in central defense.
So to sum up, we didn't need much in attack, our needs were basically 1 or 2 CB, RB, 2 CMs and 1 RW. And more importantly we needed to get rid of a lot of dead wood.
That wasn't much to ask for.
With Maguire and AWB we can rate the defense as 80% sorted since we can also count Tuanzebe who was highly rated from his last loan. James is a good addition but still it don't solve the RW problem as he looks like he prefers LW which already has 3 or 4 players fighting for it.
The midfield is the bigger problem, I think it will cost us a lot. No additions so far. Just imagine if Pogba and Matic both got injured, which is exactly what happened last season!!
Attack, I'm happy so far, if Lukako goes out, then we need to replace him, though I don't think there's time and we are stuck with him.
And yes, we didn't ship anybody out, which is appalling to say the least.
Our squad is completely imbalanced, a lot of dead wood in defense who aren't playing yet are on the wage bill, very thin in the Middle with our top 3 picks being a world class player, a kid, and an aging immobile Matic.
I guess 2/5 is really generous of me. However, the transfer window is still open, if we can get a CM then 3/5 might be fair.