Schmeichel
AWB- Maguire - Fofana - Shaw
Pogba - Ndidi
Barnes - Bruno - Rashford
Vardy/Cavani.
It’s predominantly united players. Let’s not forget that Maguire was excellent for them, it’s only under Ole you would maybe not consider him. Shaw is nailed on based on this season. I think AWB is better defensively than any of their full back options but Castagne is obviously much better going forward. Lindelöf would be my pick after Maguire and Fofana
Tielemans would probably be my choice alongside Pogba but would be a very attacking side with him, so I’d lean towards Ndidi. The options after Tielemans would be Matic and Mctom for me.
Bruno and Rashford are shoe ins, Bruno is obviously better than Maddison and Barnes. Barnes over greenwood out wide but I’d have Greenwood over the likes of Perez. Martial also.
Up front it’s probably Cavani, better career and better this season (despite Vardy having more goals, scored a lot of pens, he’s really struggled the last few months). The next option after these would be Martial.
I think a combined United Xi would have more United players and the backups would consist of United players mainly too.
I think people are reading too much into current performances, which is mainly to do with the managers. United squad is comfortably better in terms of quality, they’re just underperforming due to a poor manager whilst Leicester are over performing.
I would also say that you could argue every Leicester players inclusion and provide a decent argument for not including them compared to their United counterpart. Rashford,Bruno, Pogba, shaw are all pretty much nailed on for anyone’s combined team I’d say.
Simply no way is AWB a better full-back than Ricardo.
From my biased Leicester perspective, the only shoe-ins from Man United would be Bruno (for sure), Rashford and Pogba (if it's the decent Pogba). I'd say the jury is out on Shaw / Justin (I'd say Shaw for longevity, though Justin was nailed on to get our player of the season had he not got injured).
As for center-backs, I'd go for any of Evans/Soyuncu/Fofana over Maguire.
As for the Cavani / Vardy debate. Vardy hasn't been in great form - he's been coming back from his hernia operation - and I can see why people might choose Cavani, but even if you discount goals, Vardy has 7 assists this season, which is nearly as many as Cavani's goals and assists combined (8). I suppose neither are particularly outstanding up front options this season though.
If Rashford could play as a striker, I'd take our Vardy and put another Leicester midfielder in there. Either way, this'd probably be my ideal team (at least player wise - I accept the formation may be a little iffy).
Kasper
Ricardo, Soyuncu, Evans, Shaw
N'didi
Tielemans Pogba
Bruno
Barnes Rashford*
*(Barnes and Vardy have played as a front 2, so maybe Rashford could play the Vardy role)