ThomasEmil
Invisible Herrera Watcher
Van Dijk
Ramos
Varane
Chiellini
Kjær
Ramos
Varane
Chiellini
Kjær
I agree but it's no more crazy than Maguire being in there.Rudiger is underrated, yes, but no way is he top 5 in the world.
Yes it is - Maguire is top 5.I agree but it's no more crazy than Maguire being in there.
+ ThuramVVD and Dias are the standouts from our league. Ramos and Chiellini have been the top two of the last 10 years, but both are coming towards the end now.
Marquinhos is definitely up there and before injury I'd say Laporte as well.
Hard to believe that in the 00s Rio, Vidic, Terry, Carvalho, Stam, Maldini, Puyol, Cannavaro and Nesta were all playing. We had a real golden age of CBs.
Team achievements have got nothing to do with a player's individual quality.1) Varane (4x CLs and 3 league titles, a world cup and still 28)
Suppose there's not really any way of knowing, I don't see it myself but you could end up being right.No, but he will be.
"Nothing" seems a bit of an overstatement.Team achievements have got nothing to do with a player's individual quality.
Well a few years ago you had Bonnuci, Chiellini, Boateng, Hummels, Godin, Ramos, Varane, Thiago, Marquinos all playing together at close to their peak (not including VVD and Dias since ofcourse they weren't as good then as they were a few years ago). That's a very good bunch of players themselves. If you want to talk about the this decade you can include VVD, Laporte and Dias for latter part while including Pique and Masherano for the early half of the decade to that list too.VVD and Dias are the standouts from our league. Ramos and Chiellini have been the top two of the last 10 years, but both are coming towards the end now.
Marquinhos is definitely up there and before injury I'd say Laporte as well.
Hard to believe that in the 00s Rio, Vidic, Terry, Carvalho, Stam, Maldini, Puyol, Cannavaro and Nesta were all playing. We had a real golden age of CBs.
He's obviously a very good player or he wouldn't feature in their starting XI. But to simply state "he's top 5 in the world because he won X, Y and Z", that's not a justification at all. Vice versa, it's not because you've won nothing that you can't be a top 5 player at your position."Nothing" seems a bit of an overstatement.
More Wumstar than Dumbstar.There's biased opinions, then there's sheer insanity. Neither of those are better than Maguire, and its debatable whether they're even better than Lindelof.
VVD helped you win the leagueTeam achievements have got nothing to do with a player's individual quality.
Don't mean to be mean, but that's a stupid takeDon't mean to be mean, but I would take Matip, Gomez and Konate way before I had to consider the Manchester Barge.
When I was a lad I ate four dozen eggsDon't mean to be mean, but I would take Matip, Gomez and Konate way before I had to consider the Manchester Barge.
It's not mean. Just stupid. No need to apologiseDon't mean to be mean, but I would take Matip, Gomez and Konate way before I had to consider the Manchester Barge.
Liverpool’s three centre backs not named VVD. You honestly believe Liverpool have FOUR CBs better than Maguire, sorry FIVE as I assume you forgot about Fabinho.Don't mean to be mean, but I would take Matip, Gomez and Konate way before I had to consider the Manchester Barge.
And? So did 20 other players. He could’ve helped us win the league being the 10th best CB as well.VVD helped you win the league
He played 15 league games - pretty hard to understand that one.As a real madrid fan i can tell you that sergio ramos was still comfortably our best defender this past season
Or just Dumb.More Wumstar than Dumbstar.
yeah I didn't feel comfortable listing more than 3 eitherare there even 5 top defenders?
i struggle to name 3