I would have liked to see Garnacho instead of Weghorst, he would have definitely given Arsenal something to think about. Apart from that I don't know what he could have done, our subs bench was fecking atrocious, I don't get all the crying here. We are way behind Arsenal but that's the reality, it cannot be fixed in 5 months. We are still doing fine, nearly 2 points per game on average, having already played both City and Arsenal twice. We are in a good position.
Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager
- Thread starter sewey89
- Start date
He's doing miles better than Ole, cool off before posting rubbish. Most people didn't even think we'd get top 4 this season, we're not "scraping" it, we're there because we're one of the best teams in the league.
Manager is doing a great job for year one. A few more signings in the summer and we will be ready for a full on assault on the league and CL next year imo.
If he had swapped Garnacho for Antony and stuck with the 4-2-3-1 Garnacho wouldn't have seen the ball once and we'd have conceded 4 or 5 goals.
We had no control of the midfield in this match, especially as Eriksen tired in the 2nd half. Switching up the forward players wouldn't have made a difference.
We lost because our midfielders aren't good enough. If we're still starting Eriksen every match instead next season we'll have the same problem.
He has a bloody fantastic young winger that could have gave us some life in the counter.
At the end of the day he made the wrong call.
Going in the right direction. Had absolutely nothing available to him to make any changes.
Factually incorrect all over the board other than Liverpool and Chelsea being in meltdown.
I don't think people mind criticism, it's just the over the top emotional drivel people don't like.
Go log off and never return, :vomit:
Our schedule and goal difference are very concerning and I do fear that it could cost us a top four spot.
Really not a fan that we didn't even try to play football today.
Agreed, it's very easy to forget how early into his tenure we actually are.
Weghorst brought nothing to the team in the last 30 minutes. He was a waste of space on the pitch. Give Garnacho a chance on the left, let Rashford play as a 9. Bruno on the right brings us nothing, sloppy offense, no defense. Even Elanga just running up and down on the right would be more effective. We had not much on the bench, but just waiting to concede should not be an option.
All sport across the UK was postponed that weekend due to the queens death. The Palace game fell during that week.
I’d suggest he study some football but it’s most likely a lost cause.
This Antony sub never really works. Bruno is fecking shit on the right
He's also incredibly inexperienced and when the rest of team have nothing left in the tank it's probably not going to help bringing him on while it's backs against the wall for the last part of the game.
It's a perfectly understandable decision from ETH.
I don't know, either.
I love ETH. I love the mentality that he's instilled and I think we're performing WAY above where we should be considering the club is skint. I just feel like both this and the Palace match were there for the taking and we let it slip away. That said, Palace was much more frustrating as we had Casemiro, and asking McTominay to do a job today was pushing him to his limits.
It is what it is.
We continue on and push for top 4 while hoping we're bought by someone willing to invest in the club and not just squeeze every last penny from it.
They need to stop calling him an attacking manager.
He sets up like Mourinho.
He sets up like Mourinho.
I think he has to take responsibility for this loss. He should have made substitutions around the 70 minute mark but I think there is a bit of an exaggeration from some of our fans.
We have definitely improved significantly under him. Still enjoying watching up play.
We have definitely improved significantly under him. Still enjoying watching up play.
I very much disagree.
We lost anyway so clearly he got it wrong.
Would have been better to sub off Weghorst and try and steal a goal on the counter.
Wouldn't have been a major risk but choosing to maintain no out ball was a major risk and it did not pay off.
Live and learn. Onto the next one
Elanga and Garnacho are the options we're killing the manager for not bringing on? A not very good young winger and a really promising but even younger winger? It's a bit tenuous really, if that's the best we have then maybe it's understandable he didn't use his bench. He nearly got a point, I fully expected us to lose beforehand and we nearly didn't, he didn't do a bad job.
Agreed, and I doubt there's a single fan who is unimpressed with the job he has done. However, this is yet another game where his in-game management was poor. McTominay and Antony "playing" the full 90? Shaw refusing to engage Saka for the whole game when Malacia is on the bench? Garnacho sat on his arse until extra time?
Even leaving aside subs (or lack thereof), he needed to change something going into the final 15 mins. Arsenal were all over us like they would have been against a conference side. Just getting our defence to play 10 yards higher would have helped but he left it well alone.
I would've gone with the threat of Rashford down the middle, Garnacho on the left. We could've even for the last 15 mins put Rashford on the right, leave Weghorst on and have Garnacho down the left. Rashford has been very effective down the right this season and could've helped us maintain a threat, keep the 2-2.
If we're going to concede then lets still give them something to think about with fresh attacking legs rather than dropping off and inviting the inevitable goal.
A lot of effort wasted for one point out of six due to conservative approach in the last parts of the game.
If we're going to concede then lets still give them something to think about with fresh attacking legs rather than dropping off and inviting the inevitable goal.
A lot of effort wasted for one point out of six due to conservative approach in the last parts of the game.
Sack ETH, hire Lampard.
Such a grating thread to read.
Remember, we've won more games this season then we did last. It's a work in progress and we're miles ahead of where we were last year. Midfield depth and a Striker and we beat these feckers.
Remember, we've won more games this season then we did last. It's a work in progress and we're miles ahead of where we were last year. Midfield depth and a Striker and we beat these feckers.
We're miles ahead of where we had any right to be after that opening two matches of the season, entirely down to having finally appointed a proper manager.
In six months the Cafe has gone from whining about Brighton and Brentford (quite rightly) to being outraged by us conceding an absolute worldy at Palace (when we should have had a penalty if VAR hadn't cacked themselves) and losing 3-2 at the league leaders who've dropped two points at home so far this season. The latter taking place in no small part because of us having 14 dependable players in the squad.
Anyone pretending he's not performed miracles is a complete WUM.
In six months the Cafe has gone from whining about Brighton and Brentford (quite rightly) to being outraged by us conceding an absolute worldy at Palace (when we should have had a penalty if VAR hadn't cacked themselves) and losing 3-2 at the league leaders who've dropped two points at home so far this season. The latter taking place in no small part because of us having 14 dependable players in the squad.
Anyone pretending he's not performed miracles is a complete WUM.
Bit confused with this post, in what way did we not try to play football?
Well, the Mourinho that was on a very steep downward because ETH 's second halves are still a mystery to me and they usually do not shut anything down while playing noticeable worse than the first halves.
Next joke. Have you had too many drinks mate, or do you just not know anything about football?He needs to make a strong decision and get rid of De Gea in the summer. He surely can't be happy with watching his distribution.
No, what some fans need to learn is that there isn't always a sub or tactical change that's going to win you the match.
We lost this match because we don't have a proper midfield yet. You can screech all you want about subbing Garnacho on but it wouldn't have made a difference because we couldn't get hold of the ball and spent most of the match in our own half.
Well said.
Some of our players are rancid and the squad is threadbare. Ten Hag is working miracles.
We don’t have a midfield without Casemiro and that’s where games are won and lost. Little to with ETH. He’s doing a great job.
We sat back like a bunch of cowards pretty much.
I have to agree many aren't being objective. The manager has overperfomed.
Needs to drop Antony from the starting XI as soon as possible and start making better subs early and often. Why was Eriksen on the pitch for 90 minutes? Or at all, in fact? Fecked the Casemiro sub last game also which had an effect now since we played with 10 men.
Needs to be supported in the summer but absolutely with input from the club.
Needs to be supported in the summer but absolutely with input from the club.
ASTRONOMICAL
Why don't you tell us which subs he should have made, if it's so obvious? Who was available to come on and win us some control of the midfield?
Think EtH got a few things wrong. One Casemiro = One McFred. Should have used similar tactics that he deployed versus Man City. Plus should have brought on Garnacho much sooner.